swiftscout8 said:That isn’t what I asked! My question was: can an LLC have a director who is already employed by another company?
You didn't, but I did. I don't see why you're confused. 🙂 By the way, you got your answer.
swiftscout8 said:So everything is settled with the government, just not through the company where the director works. Next, does such a company need to hire an additional employee to meet the one-employee minimum requirement?
From what I can tell, there's only one solution: you have to have at least one employee. Either it's you as the director or someone else. But then what happens with payroll taxes and benefits? Am I forced to pay those in two different places, similar to how a sole proprietorship works?
You've scrambled the facts, and the solution is actually quite straightforward. Stop comparing this to a sole proprietorship; that is a completely different scenario.
Based on what the colleague is saying, you don't necessarily need to hire anyone.
Scenario A: You work a teller job at JPMorgan Chase, and alongside that, you decide to start an LLC for software sales. In this case, you don't need to be an employee of your own LLC or pay yourself payroll taxes because your employer is already handling that.
Scenario B: You have a degree but can't find a job, so you're scraping together pennies from your savings $2.75 just to afford coffee with friends. You have no health insurance or Social Security contributions. Since you can't find work anywhere, you decide to open an LLC for software sales.
Under previous laws, you would have had to officially employ yourself and pay yourself roughly $200 Social Security, $200 Medicare, and other various taxes every month. We're talking about $1,500-$533 total per month. That would have been a bad move, because you likely won't be pulling in enough software sales in those first few months to cover all those mandatory costs. In fact, you might never hit the level of monthly revenue needed to break even on those expenses. 🙂
Scenario C: You have a degree, no health insurance, no Social Security coverage, no money, and no luck finding a job. You decide to launch an LLC to sell software. You make a sale once in a while, the LLC stays active (it has revenue, pays sales tax, etc.), but there isn't a single employee on the books—meaning you aren't stuck with that $$500 monthly bill for Social Security, Medicare, and taxes. The downside here is that you have zero health coverage if something goes wrong, and you aren't building any retirement savings.