Anthony Evans78 said:Look, it's perfectly fine to call them that. There's a difference between having a different opinion and completely turning off your brain and pretending we're still in a normal market. We haven't been in a real market since 2008; it's just been constant intervention ever since.
And it wasn't a drop in value, it was a drop in price. We've already covered why that happened. Maybe you should go back and read our previous discussions.
And do a bit more homework. The dollar started its decline in 1971, not at Bretton Woods 🙂
Anyway, back to gold. I still think the paradigm has shifted. There will definitely be a correction, but one thing is certain: paper goes to zero, metals go to the moon.
Watch your wording: I said the rhetoric about fiat collapsing has been around since Bretton Woods (and even before), not that the dollar's value has been dropping since then. If we're talking actual purchasing power, that's been sliding since the 30s.
And whether people like it or not, value dropped in 2011. This isn't about hoarding indefinitely; it's about saving with liquidity in mind (which is a fundamental requirement for any store of value). Savings exist so that when you actually need them, you can turn them into liquid cash and use them. Someone who needed their silver stash back in 2011 lost half their value. Take it how you want.
You can talk all you want about "if only I had waited this long, I would have made X." Sure, absolutely everything in the world happens if you wait long enough.
But at that point, you're practicing religion, not dealing with reality.
To reiterate, I'm personally on the bullish side for PMs. However, I don't think for a second that people who aren't convinced about PM growth are crazy.
Especially considering that just a year ago, those same PMs got slammed by 50%. (Let's be precise: they dropped 50% twice in three years, so what are we even discussing here?) It doesn't matter what the reasons were. That's exactly the point of "caution first."