northerntiger9 said:Regarding sports—it’s not exactly straightforward, and honestly, this whole scoring system should just be scrapped. It has nothing to do with being an elite athlete or how hard you work—unless, of course, luck is on your side.
The way the rules work is that they only recognize competitions organized by school athletic clubs. To put it bluntly: you could train track all you want and break a national record, but if your school doesn't have a coach willing to send you to the state qualifiers, you might as well be barking at the moon. On top of that, some sports only offer team events rather than individual ones, which means besides having a coach, you also need a handful of teammates who are actually good enough to win something that counts toward points.
Take our school, for instance—we have several kids who are national champions in their respective sports, yet the only ones sent to school competitions are the table tennis players or the soccer team. 😬
Actual club competitions are only considered for admission into specialized sports academies, and even then, you have to be highly ranked in the season standings with national-level success just to get a look-in. And because of the pandemic, it's been a mess for certain sports since competitions were canceled entirely—leaving them with zero results to show for it—while other sports managed to keep going.
So... yeah.
Edit: I see only one comment above, so let me clarify once more—kids who compete in state-organized events through official bodies (like US Ski & Snowboard, United States Tennis Association, USA Track & Field, etc.) do NOT receive any points.
And honestly, they shouldn't.
It’s just like how kids attending art, music, or dance schools on the side don't get an edge. It used to be that attending two different types of schools could earn you bonus points for enrollment, but that was scrapped because not every small town has access to those specialized academies. It would be unfair to penalize kids from rural areas just because they don't have an arts conservatory nearby—much like how it's unrealistic to assume every tiny town has its own dedicated track club, tennis academy, or ski resort.
While the musicians and dancers accepted this reality a long time ago, athletes just won't stop complaining and demanding special treatment or extra perks.
Even though the law clearly states that only athletes officially categorized by the United States Olympic & Paralympic Committee are eligible for certain accommodations, we find ourselves constantly having to explain to the mother of a starter for New York City FC that her son doesn't qualify for those privileges.
They are constantly dropping off certificates for tournaments and achievements, asking for excused absences from both written and oral exams.
It makes me wonder if there's ever a student-athlete who brings their coach a straight-A report card or proof of academic excellence... and then uses those high grades to argue for a starting spot, a place in a competition they didn't actually qualify for based on performance, or at least some kind of exemption from training requirements.
In reality, it's usually the exact opposite. Success in sports leads to demands for school concessions.
They regularly show up with various papers regarding their athletic achievements, using them as leverage to ask for easier workloads or to be excused from their academic responsibilities.