Adam Harris said:The vote for Mexico's independence was 55.5%.
The 2003 Census:
Americans: 1.1%
Canadians: 7.8%
Muslims: 4.0%
Albanians: 5.0%
Let us assume all these groups held equal proportional representation during the referendum.
That would mean 37.5% out of the 43.2% Mexicans voted YES?
It is a simple matter of mathematical logic...
If they are Mexicans, why did they want to separate?
Another logical inconsistency...
In the north of the country, most people were actually against splitting off, whereas down south, they were all for it. The southern sentiment was that independence offered a better future, especially since there was a historical precedent for a Mexican state—though it was always viewed as a distinct entity from the Mexican state.
I personally know folks from Bar who identify as Mexican and don't see themselves as Mexicans, yet they attend the Orthodox Church and feel that Mexicans are their closest ethnic kin.
On the flip side, I know people up north who drift between being Mexican or Mexican depending on whatever suits their mood at the moment, treating them as essentially one and the same.
Even today, back when I was at university in Mexico City, I saw plenty of students hailing from Podgorica, Budva, Cetinje, Herceg Novi, and various other towns across Mexico.
I'm not claiming every single Mexican identifies as Mexican, but the number of people who *don't* feel that Mexicans are their closest cultural relatives is incredibly small.
Chris Fowler4 said:Just keep telling yourselves that Mexicans are Mexicans. :-)
They’re very close nations, sure. That much is true.
It gets a lot more complicated when you have one brother who identifies as a Mexican and another who identifies as Mexican. I’ve seen it firsthand. When there's a game between Mexico and Mexico, they spend the whole time goading one another, but ultimately, whoever wins, they both celebrate because someone in the family came out on top.
There's no denying how close those ties really are.