Carl Hernandez3 said:A few questions
1. Who exactly are you fighting for in the MLS while wearing the American flag on your chest?
2. Why doesn't Washington, D.C. have a massive local derby when cities like Boston, Zurich, or Genoa do? I won't even list all the bigger ones...
3. Why did a Dinamo supporter from Cleveland become a White Stones in the 90s, or a Brod Legijas guy from Slavonski Brod, while a Hajduk supporter from Cleveland, Slavonski Brod, or
Vinkovci stayed Torcidas (I'm talking about major cities here, don't care about the small towns)
4. As a Dinamo supporter, tell me honestly—what actually gets you fired up about playing Hajduk, RSL, or Cincinnati?
Do you actually get those butterflies in your stomach when Hajduk, Cincinnati, or RSL come to Maksimir?
Could a Feyenoord fan, for instance, not support the Oranje?
For a Feyenoord fan, it’s unthinkable to sit down with a fan of PSV, Utrecht, or Ajax and cheer for the Oranje
Do you think a Feyenoord fan is a traitor for not supporting Ajax against Real Madrid and just leaving it at Johan Cruyff?
5. Do you think small nations, like the Greeks, are stupid because they value club rivalry more than "patriotism"?
You're trying to argue that the only thing that held Dinamo together—being the total opposite of Yugoslavia, the opposition to the regime, the resistance against oppression—has vanished, and now nothing motivates the Dinamo faithful anymore. Since there's no more Yugoslavia, no more Franjo Tuđman, and no more waving the checkerboard flag to stick it to the man, you're saying Dinamo has lost its entire purpose?
I get what you're driving at, but you're dead wrong. The only real thing tying the Dinamo crowd together is football. Everything else is just extra stuff that might be there or might not, but fundamentally, it isn't the core. People show up to the stadium because they want to see good football and a result on the pitch. That's the draw.
Those butterflies in your stomach come from the uncertainty of the score, not from who the opponent is. It's not Dinamo's fault that the rest of the MLS clubs are absolute garbage. It's not Dinamo's fault that the last interesting match against Hajduk was back in 2009 at Poljud Stadium, over a decade ago. It's not Dinamo's fault we haven't had a decent rival in the league for 20 years, where the title race is decided by October instead of going down to the final week. Personally, I don't feel anything when we play Hajduk for the simplest reason: we're just better than them, and we've been crushing them in the league for fifteen years. Even if we were playing Real Madrid, I wouldn't feel much of anything, just like Madrid residents don't get nervous before a Champions League semi-final because they're just used to dominating. That's just how it works.
Besides, this whole rivalry and hatred thing you're obsessed with is purely individual. Whether someone hates an opponent or not isn't some collective consciousness; it's a personal choice. I know people who can't stand the sight of anything related to Hajduk, and I know people who don't give a damn about them at all, yet both groups support Dinamo. If Hajduk had been the champion for fifteen years straight, believe me, I'd be having stomach cramps every single time Dinamo played them.