CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Amy Brooks12 › Posts

Posts by Amy Brooks12

10 posts shown.

Colton Burpo: The boy who visited heaven in Spirituality ·
nimbleranger5 said:@ yakuzza I'm right there with you—really interesting stuff and some great posts here 👍


I finally finished the ebook after this Dr. Eben pops up in my feed on this thread. Honestly, I have to laugh at the part where he claims he saw Bog and basically sucked all the wisdom out of the universe from Him, only to be sent back because His son needed him. It’s just ridiculous.

There are some interesting bits, sure, but I can't help thinking they aren't necessarily his own insights—they might just be stuff he picked up from his neuro patients and shoved into the book because he decided to quit being a surgeon and start working for Bog in some high-paid spiritual marketing gig instead. Apparently, Dr. Eben used to be quite the big-shot surgeon, but now he’s moved on from neurosurgery just to travel the globe hawking this book.

It’s pretty wild how he describes the moment before waking up from his coma, seeing six people by his side—including his inner circle and two others who weren't even physically there in the hospital but were praying with him.

The part about that girl with the deep blue eyes wandering through the valley on butterfly wings caught my eye. He supposedly found out later she was actually his sister whom he'd never met, and she had passed away long ago—something he had no clue about since he was an orphan adopted into his family.

And then there’s the whole thing with his mother, who was nearly 90 at the time, and his wife driving to the hospital after he'd been in a coma for seven days—he was basically pumped full of sedatives because he was having seizures.
They both claim to have seen this stunning, perfect rainbow in the sky, even though it turned out to be a perfectly clear day without a single cloud in sight, right around 1:00 PM.😲

What can I say? Nobody seems to be making a huge fuss over this book. People aren't exactly tearing it apart or obsessing over it, except maybe some aunts picking it up because the title sounded catchy.

Even the Dalai Lama has latched onto the story, which is great for publicity, I guess... allowing him to stay relevant in the conversation about heaven. Ugh, I just can't stand those pseudo-spiritual gurus who don't really offer anything substantial.

It reminds me of how historical figures were supported by the powers that be back in the day. They'd be educated, fed, and married off to wealthy widows to secure their position... until they got too enthusiastic and decided to head in a completely different direction from the established centers of power.

..
Colton Burpo: The boy who visited heaven in Spirituality ·
nimbleranger5 said:But what has religion actually explained? 😬Aside from making a huge mess with its own dogmas and rigid rules—creating all this confusion that just clouds things over and pushes people away from the light and the simplicity of the Truth itself.
Religion tried to claim the Truth in such a distorted, broken way—trying to turn it into a concept, a dogma, a set of rules... and they really messed that up. You can't own the Truth or trap it in a mold; you can't take something infinite and just limit it. It’s like how freedom and love can't be forced to serve the petty, selfish interests of this material world, and that’s really what we're talking about here. It feels more and more to me like religion was built by people who had plenty of book learning, but lacked the actual experience of what the mystics and prophets were talking about. So, they just complicated everything with their dogmas and rules, turning it into a total mess that nobody can make sense of—and then, of course, they served it up to the public just to look smart and educated, because they "know" things, because they are "close" friends with God 😁 while all we got in return from "our" religions were endless religious wars, bloodshed, and constant fighting among people of different faiths.

Eben Alexander looks less like a messenger from heaven bringing what he calls a "shift in the scientific community," and more like a typical character from an American movie, where people always find a way to escape the ruins of their old lives through some grand act of self-reinvention.

Just a bit of friendly advice... don't judge a person by their looks, or a book by its cover... otherwise, your comments end up sounding pretty superficial. 🙂

Encounters with ultra-reality should be based on the images of the life you lived leading up to that experience. For instance, if you're descending into hell, that should serve as a warning to change your ways if you don't want to end up there forever. And vice versa—the experience of merging with Love... but let's not even go there right now.

🙂

They "should," they "ought to," it's "not like this, it's like *my* religion says"... blah blah blah... You just can't limit the infinite and try to squeeze it into narrow human frameworks and limited ways of thinking and perceiving... honestly, we don't have a clue. Most of what we know is just stuff we heard from someone else, who heard it from someone else, who told someone else, who wrote a book, which we then read and absorbed, puffing ourselves up with "knowledge" and information... It's just a never-ending game of telephone.
Jesus also said that once we realize the Truth, that Truth will set us free. Real knowledge comes from within—from our very own souls. It’s necessary for us to encounter the Truth in the intimacy of our own being, without any middlemen. Neither the Church, nor the Pope, nor a priest, nor a pastor, nor a religious leader, nor a rabbi, or anyone else can do that for you. A person has to reach a point where the Truth reveals itself to them... Maybe the main issue is that when the Truth *is* revealed to some people, they immediately try to translate it into their own "language"—basically trying to cram it into religious dogma and the specific way of thinking they were conditioned by. But instead of opening up to the experience, they just become slaves to their own surroundings, which shuts them off from new experiences and even deeper insights.

I honestly don't get how Dr. Eben Alexander's conscience led him to such a beautiful valley of butterflies during his seven-day "vision" or experience—especially when we know he dealt with several cases of medical malpractice in his life, which actually cost him his license to practice as a neurosurgeon!

What a jerk! Trying to force a one-size-fits-all experience on everyone, yikes.

False prophet.

And besides, who are we to JUDGE anyone?! 🤷

Anyway, most real prophets were seen as frauds at first by those who dominated the religious life of society back then. They were persecuted and even killed because their messages and actions threatened the influence those leaders held over society. Later on, the children of those "murderers" and "persecutors" would repent for the sins of their fathers and give honor and eternal glory to the prophets—never quite grasping the irony of it all, since they ended up doing the exact same things to the prophets preaching in their own time.

Again, I'll say it: who are we to JUDGE?!🤷

So what if you haven't heard of the person? Big deal... and for next time, maybe it would be better to do your own research instead of waiting for someone else to explain who it is and what happened. That way, you can see for yourself if the facts are right, and you can avoid taking on other people's opinions, biases, manipulations, or half-baked conclusions. Otherwise, without putting in your own effort to investigate, you just automatically adopt someone else's view and file it away in that specific little mental compartment they intended for it.😉

btw, I want to tell the author of this thread that whether you believe or not is absolutely irrelevant here. If we start focusing on believing or disbelieving, we're just playing a game of "telephone," making up all sorts of mental constructs just to support our own theories or assumptions. In the end, we don't gain anything except maybe a nice little story or a fairy tale...

What we really need to do is make our own breakthrough toward the Truth and into the Truth—but until that actually happens, we’ve got to find a way to shed all this extra, unnecessary baggage... 😉

I guess you actually enjoy it when he claims that hell isn't just temporary, but that it doesn't even exist at all. Yeah, right. That sounds like something straight out of a Hollywood script.

It’s honestly ridiculous. Most of what we think we know is just a game of telephone. You hear something from one person, who heard it from someone else, who heard it from some other guy, who then decided to write a book about it. So we read the book, swallow it whole, and suddenly we’re all walking around acting like we’ve mastered some profound "knowledge" or "information." It's all just secondhand noise passed down through a chain of people who probably didn't even get it right the first time.

Exactly. That’s how it goes. You’ve got one group of people just chasing whatever happens to be topping the bestseller lists this week, following trends like sheep. Then you’ve got everyone else—the ones who actually know what's up—who listen to the only Source that actually matters: Jesus Christ.

We really need to get to that point where we encounter the Truth within the absolute privacy of our own souls. No middleman. No barriers. Just direct access.Look, it’s not like the Church can do this for you. It doesn't matter if it's the Pope, a priest, a pastor, a patriarch, an imam, or a rabbi—none of them can pull this off on your behalf. No one else can step in and do the heavy lifting here. You have to reach that point yourself, where you've done the work and finally arrive at the stage where the Truth reveals itself to you.

You’re only half right. Honestly, whoever whispered that in your ear only gave you a fraction of the Truth. If you want the raw, unfiltered, all-powerful, and Victorious Truth, here it is...


There are no middlemen where the One resides.


There is only one Jesus Christ.

But instead of actually opening themselves up to those experiences, they just end up becoming slaves to their own surroundings. It’s like they get trapped by their environment, which ends up shutting them off from anything new or any chance at deeper understanding.

Everyone who chooses to be clothed in Jesus Christ through baptism doesn't have any business talking about bondage. In Him, there's no such thing as Jews or Greeks, no men or women, and no master or slave. Period.

And besides, who on earth are we to be JUDGING anyone?!

Let’s be real: most true prophets were branded as frauds by the religious gatekeepers of their day. They were persecuted and hunted down simply because their message threatened the status quo and the power those elites held over society. Then, fast forward a few generations, and the children of those very "murderers" and "persecutors" end up repenting for their fathers' sins, honoring those same prophets and giving them eternal glory. It’s pure irony—they end up doing the exact same things to the prophets preaching in their own era that their ancestors did.

Just half-truths and improvisations designed to brainwash people.

Jesus told the Samaritans:



You worship what you do not know, but we worship what we know



It's just like how Stalinists had no clue they were bowing to a system that would have wiped out brothers like Cyril and Methodius, completely indifferent to the fact that they'd leave everyone illiterate in the process.

What you're actually talking about here are those false prophets, because Jesus Christ, the Alpha and Omega, is the final prophet.
Jesus said:



Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets. I have not come to abolish them, but to fulfill them.



Watch out for any prophet who refuses to acknowledge what Jesus established, or any modern teacher who tries to elevate themselves above God.

the laziness of his mind

Whose mind? Are we talking about the one you claim knows nothing, or the one that Dr. Jerk calls an “unconscious mind” 😲 which is apparently too preoccupied suffering through these bottom-tier "insights," "awakenings" (if you want to use the jargon from this PDF), and those “out there memories” (in Dr. Jerk’s little vocabulary)? EEEK!

I’m honestly not surprised you're siding with Dr. Jerk while trying to guard yourself against every other "influence." You’re falling headfirst into his "out there" narrative—which, by the way, is a much more sophisticated attempt to dodge responsibility for the millions in legal fees, debts, and malpractice suits he racked up before being kicked off the list of practicing neurosurgeons. And that happened right before his little trip to the "other side." It’s a lot smarter than the attempts made by poor Michael Jackson, who, facing similar private crises, bounced from Judaism to Islam. Hmmmmm... well, this doctor actually managed to pull it off where Jack couldn't: returning from "beyond the veil" with amnesia and somehow managing to fix his pituitary gland back from what was likely, in my opinion, an eternal hell he was probably 😲 EEK creating by squeezing information out of his neurosurgery patients while they were in post-op amnesia.

It would be tragic if it weren't so hilarious.
Colton Burpo: The boy who visited heaven in Spirituality ·
Sean Mitchell said:Look, I genuinely believe those experiences are real. We aren't just talking about some random hallucination triggered by the last few electrical impulses of a dying brain.
There are people who have actually gone through near-death experiences (NASA) where doctors were right there monitoring their brain waves.
During those moments, there was absolutely zero activity detected in the brain, which, if you ask me, is pretty solid evidence that consciousness isn't just some function localized in a specific center within the brain.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nhah5WdWRCk

Enjoy 🙂

Thanks for the entertainment, but this guy is basically asking us to believe in things he can't even explain himself—things that religion has already had answers for ages.

Dr. Eben Alexander doesn't really come across as some heavenly messenger bringing about a "shift in the scientific community." Honestly, he feels more like a protagonist from a cheesy Hollywood movie where people constantly find ways to escape the wreckage of their old lives through grand acts of self-reinvention.

If these encounters with hyper-reality were legitimate, they should be based on the life you've actually lived leading up to that moment. I mean, if you're descending into hell, shouldn't you get a warning to fix your act if you don't want to end up stuck there forever? And the flip side—that feeling of merging with Love... we don't even need to go there.

But seriously, I don't get how Eben Alexander's "consciousness" guided him through a beautiful valley of butterflies during his seven-day "vision," considering the man had a history of medical malpractice and even lost his license to practice neurosurgery because of it!

What a jerk! Giving everyone this one-size-fits-all experience. EEK!

Fake prophet.
The Discipline of Spiritual Self-Improvement in Spirituality ·
I can't believe I'm even typing this out, but here we go again. It’s honestly exhausting watching how things are playing out lately. You look around and it feels like common sense has just packed its bags and left the building. Everything is becoming so polarized, so loud, and frankly, so ridiculous. I’m sitting here trying to make sense of it all, and honestly? I’m struggling. It feels like we're constantly being pushed toward these extremes, and nobody is willing to just sit down and have a normal, rational conversation anymore. It's maddening! kaže:
Honestly, there’s just something about that whole idea—losing yourself completely in the heat of the moment like that—that feels... I don't know, a little surreal? It sounds kind of bizarre when you actually stop to think about it.
Honestly, it’s just plain ugly.
You can't ever truly give yourself away to anyone. Not really. And why on earth would I??
We aren't exactly the type of people who go around handing out gifts.

Because it’s absolutely divine!
Because it’s pure heaven: spiritually, emotionally, and physically.



There’s an old truth people always talk about: you have to give to get. It sounds like one of those cheesy Hallmark cards, but honestly? It’s real. There's something about putting yourself out there and being generous that somehow fills your own cup back up in ways you wouldn't expect.
Francis of Assisi



There’s just no real selflessness in purely selfish physical gratification. When you have sex where only one person is actually craving Christ's presence, the whole thing feels shallow, hollow, and completely empty—it’s miles away from that heavenly bliss we're meant to experience. Instead, it just devolves into nothing more than some heated friction or a fleshy dildo that probably needs to be sat down for dinner and served a full meal just to stay useful.

@ Betty Collins5
Look, let’s get one thing straight about PPII and Damir Ercegovac—all that talk about "him" or "that guy"? It’s nonsense. There isn't some special divine figurehead sitting there. It’s all just the Holy Spirit. Period. It’s funny how people work, though. You've got some folks who act like they can slap a papal seal on spiritual gifts to make them look official. You've got others preaching away behind an altar or grabbing a microphone on a stage to command attention. Then you have the ones who claim they need a private, monastic cell encounter to feel anything at all. But then? Then you have the real ones—the people who don't need the spotlight or the fancy titles because they simply witness to the truth through the way they live their lives. That's where the real stuff happens.
The Discipline of Spiritual Self-Improvement in Spirituality ·
bluemason3 said:🤣 Well, at least the troll is entertaining. 😁

Hold your horses, where are you even going with this trolling talk?

What I’m getting at here is the absolute core of this entire discussion and spirituality itself. Take a second to actually contemplate it.

:: A person limiting themselves to the laws of Nature, instead of achieving spiritual maturity through the natural laws of Man

You seem to be totally fine with those ascetics living out in remote mountain monasteries, deep in the wilderness, contemplating the holy rivers far away from your doorstep. But then you turn around and call people "trolls" just because they try to live that same way right here in your own neighborhood—people who aren't just talking the talk, but are actually practicing discipline, honing high spiritual virtues, curbing their impulses, and constantly striving for moral growth.

Don't you see how you're completely undermining your own argument?
The Discipline of Spiritual Self-Improvement in Spirituality ·
Steven Cruz3 said:I don't find that cute at all—it's gross. If she loved him and wanted him, he just denied her a natural connection. It wasn't some deep spiritual "enlightenment," either; he was just a weakling terrified of female sexuality... These celibate types always wrap themselves in fancy spiritual cellophane, but the real reasons underneath are usually incredibly banal—fear of women and closeted tendencies.😍

Look, sorry, but that’s what being a Catholic and a real man is all about, not being a mindless dog. When Father Damir tells me there’s no better lover than a true Catholic who knows how to give himself fully—and when he does, he gives everything he has—it honestly gives me chills. It triggers these sinful thoughts where I suddenly wish I were some Buddhist just so I could be reborn and catch the eye of a real Catholic man from any corner of the globe. I want to be his queen, whether we're out on the street, at home, in front of the family, or especially in front of his mother. Though, if he ever did anything to hurt me, I'd want his father to slap him hard and remind him exactly who he belongs to 100%.
The Discipline of Spiritual Self-Improvement in Spirituality ·
be in the world without being of it. I’d highly recommend watching the documentary "majestic silence" or picking up some of those rare works by the Carthusian monks.

Look, as much as I love bells—and trust me, I’m crazy about them—having those constant, heavy monastery bells ringing here where I live would absolutely wreck the effortless, spontaneous, and natural silence we have. It's the kind of quiet that just absorbs and melts away every sound, creating this smooth, functional, laid-back, civilized daily rhythm. I live in the inner city of a massive two-million-person metropolis that’s constantly expanding, with the subway and transit lines stretching out 62 miles both south and north. And here’s the kicker: despite living in the heart of a giant city, my everyday life feels incredibly tranquil, almost festive, even though I’m pulling full-time hours five days a week. People aren't alienated or lonely here, even though everyone respects personal space. I don't know anyone around here who lives in a frantic rush, which seems to be the norm for you guys over in the European Union, even in the tiny towns. When being in a total whirlwind is your baseline, I guess I shouldn't be surprised that a monastic Shangri-La kind of peace feels like a foreign concept to you. But really, sticking a camera in someone's face during their most private moments with God—can that actually help a viewer? Or 😲 Would those people even know how to handle the challenges of real life once they step outside the monastery walls? And I mean perpetually, not just for a few fixed hours. Hmmm. Tibetan monks showed the invading Chinese Communists that they actually knew how to apply their traditional techniques to neutralize physical pain. It's like those Filipinos who volunteer every Easter to be nailed to crosses.

I wouldn't trade the daily peace I have here for any amount of conformity or cheap posturing found anywhere else in the world, specifically because of this [productive] silence. It doesn't even need the label of "majestic" because it simply *is*. I find my own asceticism through walking through the everyday grind. Plenty of opportunities 🙂 To the point where I might even let myself get screwed over by someone who lacks respect for me, treating me indignantly by keeping me at a lethal, insulting distance while still being within reach, all behind an iron mask.

But honestly, I think that peace is something we carry inside us. Looking back, I feel like my childhood and youth were filled with that same kind of quiet, cramped stillness, even though they were on the complete opposite side of the world from here. God knows us best, and He always honors us with what we long for and grants us what we are worthy of. All of this serves as a pledge of total devotion to Him.

Living in the world means being productive, doing what is required of you rather than just what you feel like doing (unlike those Carthusians making their own herbal liqueur), creating, being part of a global community, and contributing—all while remaining in divine silence, dependent on no one but God, to whom you dedicate every action, testifying to His beauty and magnifying the most holy love of Jesus.

Asceticism is born from spiritual growth when it becomes a constant, which is still a struggle for the modern person who is always prone to drifting in and out of it. Even though a person can carry their monastic cell with them wherever they go, in any world at all

.
The Discipline of Spiritual Self-Improvement in Spirituality ·
bluemason3 said:Father Damir definitely isn't a Carthusian. There aren't any Carthusians here in America; the closest you'd find would be over in Canada or maybe Mexico. Generally, contemplative orders don't make much of a public splash. Lately, though, some have been forced into the spotlight because they're short on vocations, but that’s a bad move. The whole point of being contemplative is that you don't need to chase numbers—if you start doing that, you lose what makes you unique and end up facing the exact same issues as everyone else.

As for Father Damir, he’s just a massive, childish, self-absorbed idiot.😳

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HuWftlc-msU

It seems like he started out with those charismatic, pseudo-Pentecostal revivals and eventually transitioned into this phase where he adopts these flashy, shallow, circus-like American showmanship styles—sometimes literally copying them. It reminds me of something Tomson might do. Sure, they’re technically Englishmen, but clearly, the right-wing conservatives there lack the imagination to come up with anything original.🤣

Contemplative orders often sit on the opposite side of the aisle within the Church; they aren't exactly big fans of this "new spirituality." But then again, to each their own.

Personally, I think monastic communities are the only truly interesting thing happening in the Church. This other stuff is just a political-manipulative circus.🙂

In the US, when it comes to monastic orders, I think you mainly have Benedictines and Cistercians (who are a bit stricter/more contemplative—basically just a reform branch of the Benedictines). Then there are the Paulines—I'm not sure if there are others?🤔

There are also a few mendicant orders that have a more contemplative side, like the Carmelites and such.

Beyond the mendicant and monastic orders, you have different types of groupings, like priestly communities or societies with specific "charisms" or focuses.

The Salesians are a congregation focused primarily on social work, especially education.

Father Damir articulates the message of God's mercy here with such incredible, piercing depth. 🙏

Father Damir is a total sweetheart from God—a down-to-earth, zero-ego, genuine man, and by his mother's grace, a sharp-witted guy who witnesses for Christ and preaches the penetrating Word of God. It’s honestly no surprise that American youth love listening to him; they flock to his Masses and show up at his rallies where he does nothing but preach Church doctrine. And that doctrine includes the fact that Satan loves to attack sacramental marriage and the priesthood (the marriage to the Church)—a topic Father Damir dives into with incredibly deep detail. It was actually beautiful when he shared how he held back from being intimate with his high school girlfriend, Colleen (he probably didn't realize back then that it was pure asceticism), simply because they weren't "one" yet, and who knows whose wife he might have ended up sleeping with otherwise!

I truly believe that for him, there’s an equals sign between asceticism and love. I mean, everyone knows the story about his Aunt Slavica, who was his ultimate example of ascetic love through her years of serving her sick, dying husband. While he saw it as asceticism at the time, for her, it was just a natural (spiritually uplifting) (Godly) love for the man she was sacramentally united to alongside Jesus. Back then, she represented a much more spiritually mature soul to him while he was still just a kid.

BTW, to me, Father Damir’s Salesians feel a lot like those Neocatechumenal groups where priests witness to God's love using examples from their own lives. It’s so educational when Father Damir describes his brother's love for his wife—a woman Father Damir describes as "not particularly religious, but hey, she's his wife," and it's no wonder he praises her everywhere and forever. He talks about how his brother is completely devoted to her, studying her "inside-out" with ascetic devotion even now after their second child, and how he literally breathes in sync with her because he knows her fertile days, her PMS days, and her post-PMS days, all of which 🙂
The Discipline of Spiritual Self-Improvement in Spirituality ·
Jeffrey Watson13 said:Are you sure? Maybe he's a Salesian? Carthusians usually don't leave the monastery...
Definitely watch that documentary. It's beautiful. Three hours of pure, majestic silence. Good for the soul...

Edit: Not exactly a fan of Father Damir, for other reasons...

Alright then, sounds like I can't miss out on all that monastic silence.

You don't have to be a fan of Father Damir himself, just the way of life he's actually living.
Hmm, let me guess what those "other reasons" might be... 🙂 Is it his family lineage, or maybe something he said that got totally twisted by those local Catholic enthusiasts over there—the ones he wasn't even talking to in the first place?
The Discipline of Spiritual Self-Improvement in Spirituality ·
Betty Collins5 said:Anyone looking for God through the New Age is basically looking for bread when they should be looking for cake. My dear philosopher, you've explained your very simple thought process with such expert precision. Asceticism isn't for people who haven't been called to that life; you can dive into it philosophically, sure, but it won't bear any fruit. You enter asceticism alongside God and your soul, and over time, your soul detaches from your intellect so you can fully immerse yourself in the onostran... being in the world, but not of it. I'd recommend watching the documentary "veličanstven tišina" or checking out some of the rare works by the Carthusian brothers.

Betty Collins5, aren't we all called to live out our renunciation through kindness and compassion? 🙂
Rather than embracing the cross of life, shouldn't we avoid trying to 'empty' ourselves or strip away everyday existence by chasing after who-knows-what powers that exist outside of God? 🙂

You put that so beautifully, and honestly, thanks for the tip about the Carthusian film. I’ll have to check it out tomorrow since it’s pretty long—on Vimeo, nearly three hours. I don't think I've seen it, though I've always thought the Carthusians were cool (like Father Damir, the university chaplain in a big US city, who's actually a born Canadian, a sturdy guy... basically a saint 😍)

...but I wouldn't go as far as to say, like you suggested, that the intellect separates from the being. In Christianity, a person is an inseparable whole—body, mind, and soul—and separating them would go against God's natural law. The intellect is simply redirected (toward God) and sobered up [1 Peter 5:8] by connecting the mind with the heart—and then everything rises together toward God.

nepsis is basically synonymous with Christian mindfulness—that ascetic alertness over one's thoughts, the discipline practiced by the ancient Church Fathers to maintain sobriety of mind and prevent thoughts from wandering or drifting away.

That is what living the faith looks like: applying it to daily life, right in the middle of everyday experiences and the temptations that pull us away from God.

The arena for Christian asceticism isn't at the peak of a mountain or tucked away in a monastery, nor is it found in some egoistic, self-indulgent meditation; it's right there in the heat of life.