Patrick Harris5 said:Just wanted to back up what was already said here.
And get this—Father John had this to say about the whole thing:
""I honestly don't know which parents are complaining; nobody has even approached me. I held a meeting with all the parents involved and handed out a flyer explaining everything. If any of these dissatisfied parents want to reach out, they should come to me directly. No one has contacted me or complained about the cost yet. Tell them to feel free to reach out if they're struggling financially—we'll just give it to them for free so they don't have to worry about paying," says Father John."
It’s pure conformism. Just keep your head down, stay quiet, pay up, and don't ask any questions...
Yeah, it's total conformism, but not even in the "keep quiet and pay" sense; it's more like everyone's whispering behind people's backs because that's just how things work at church nowadays.🙄
We had our First Communion ceremony this year, and the price was $67. The priest was actually really nice about it, laying out exactly what the fee covers and asking if anyone had concerns or needed clarification... out of maybe 100 people there, not a single soul spoke up. But then, later on, you see certain individuals outside the church spreading all these stories... He also made it clear that if someone can't afford it, they should just come to him privately. He asked that people shouldn't use their kids to pass along messages, because you don't want to put children in an awkward spot in front of their peers. But of course, what is a mom or dad going to say to a priest when they're broke? It's much easier to just send the message through the kid and act like they're all so enlightened and wise while standing out on the sidewalk.
Anyway,
$23paying $120 for a dress that’s basically headed straight to the dry cleaners just so we can wear it once is insane,
$27and the cost for two DVDs and three photos is also a total rip-off, especially when we're already paying $17 for a handful of tiny passport-style photos.
Then there's the church renovation fund $10—which costs about the same as two roses... and so on, and so forth.
Or maybe the real issue is these $13 donations for the church, which clearly aren't even covering the basic costs for the kids whose parents actually *can't* afford it and are too embarrassed to say so?
coppermarlin14 said:I don't have any issue with anyone; I’m an open-minded person and I respect everyone's choices... which is exactly why I allowed my child to attend religious education and everything else, and why I tolerate my husband's views... 😂
But I absolutely will not tolerate using intimidation against a child by saying, "We’re going to pull you out of the program and you won't receive your sacraments if you don't show up for Mass or class." It breaks my heart to see a child who has been up all night taking Ventolin and struggling with a fever, crying because they feel forced to go to church just to avoid being kicked out of the group...👎 They don't realize that these people are essentially brainwashing them by forcing their hand... they don't understand that the child is actually sick and physically cannot go... they just cry because they are terrified of the consequences of missing a service...🙄
That is why I want to withdraw them from religious education now; I don't want them going through the motions for a Confirmation that isn't even happening for another year...
And what has all this achieved? All it does is result in fewer kids attending classes and, eventually, fewer kids receiving the sacraments altogether....
Look, if you call out of school and tell them your kid is sick, you have just as much right to call the parish office or take a stroll down to the local church to sit down with someone and explain exactly what kind of health issues the child is dealing with.
But honestly, trashing the church and calling priests brainwashers just because they aren't meeting your specific expectations? That’s really not okay.
The sacraments actually mean something, right? If someone doesn't respect those traditions, why on earth would they feel the need to have their child receive them in the first place?
So, who’s really at fault here—is it the parents who push for sacraments through religious ed classes that aren't even mandatory, while refusing to admit they don't actually believe, or is it the clergy and the Church for expecting people who claim to be believers to actually act like it?
Just give it some thought.