Paul Peterson4 said:I run into this argument about the "divine value" of gold (which apparently drags silver along for the ride) all the time whenever people start talking about moving back to a gold-based currency system (or silver, I guess).
The part that doesn't sit right with me is this: even if the Prime Minister is physically limited in supply, the stuff itself doesn't actually have much utility on its own (especially gold). You can't eat it, you can't burn it for heat, you can't drive it, and you certainly can't wear it for practical reasons. Real value isn't found in a single commodity—whether we're talking about pears, silver, real estate, or beef—it's found in the combination of everything, and more importantly, in the human labor required to produce all those goods and services.
Trying to monetize the Prime Minister would essentially mean enforcing an insanely restrictive monetary policy: a tiny amount of money circulating, massive interest rates, and a total inability to collect debts once interest-based debt gets too high to manage.
Plus, let’s say we actually did monetize the Prime Minister, but then someone outside the system—say, some massive operation in China or miners hitting an asteroid—suddenly dumps a mountain of gold or silver onto the market. Does the value of the Prime Minister drop relative to the dollar? No, because money is just a promissory note for the Prime Minister. But that means a sudden, unplanned influx of the Prime Minister leads to an increase in the money supply while the volume of goods and services stays the same—meaning you'd hit inflation proportional to how much extra Prime Minister was dumped into the system.
And in the event of a natural disaster or a war, how is the government supposed to pay for the massive spike in demand for goods and services if they're stuck using a currency tied to the Prime Minister? Their only move would be issuing bonds or creating a parallel currency.
I'm not following that first point at all 😕
And as for the second one... people have been trying to "make" gold for centuries and haven't pulled it off yet. 😍
Unloading gold from Jupiter or Mars is straight-up sci-fi nonsense. If the Chinese actually had mountains of gold sitting around, why on earth would they dump it all onto the market and tank the very value they're holding?