... what on earth?
I was just trying to float some high-level thoughts regarding the logic behind this forum's rules—purely out of good faith and in a relaxed tone—but apparently, people are catching fish in a net I haven't even cast yet... I don't consider the aforementioned post to be a violation of any rules, nor do I find it offensive, and I’m certainly not trying to hijack the thread (even though that very post serves as a perfect illustration of the point being made here)... but let’s move past that for a moment...
@Lisa Hernandez3, weren't you the one who once passionately defended
the idea that a user sometimes simply can't detach themselves from the topic they are representing, on the very subforum you now moderate? (Do I really need to dig up the link?) You say "technically speaking"... and at the same time, you position yourself as such an expert on the human psyche that you can judge what constitutes truth versus lies, or a joke versus reality?
Let me tell you what's actually bothering me: a mountain of common-sense nonsense threads being kicked off in the Psychology section (and elsewhere, since you're pulling my leg here...), started by users with exactly zero posts who rarely ever move beyond that number, all while attempting to project an air of profound seriousness. And heaven forbid anyone questions them if it doesn't fit the "vibe" of the subforum... for instance: our esteemed colleague
@Alex Lopez5 expressed doubt regarding the motives of a certain thread starter (whether argued or not—I'd say not), but when I (not that I mind, this is just an illustration of the illogic) write the exact same thing in another thread, my comment is deleted without a single word of explanation... Is
@Alex Lopez5 your clone? Are you someone's clone? If so, why?
So,
my question for the entity shaping this forum is this: what is the purpose of forum rules that
pro forma prohibit disrupting serious discussions (so-called trolling or spamming), when the system simultaneously allows or even encourages the disruption of entire subforums by letting people open short-lived profiles to babble whatever they want?
To be clear, I’m not against new users opening threads—it's hard to gauge authenticity, after all—but when someone who has established themselves on this forum with hundreds or thousands of posts creates a brand-new account that acts as their diametric opposite, and that account receives various interactions, shouldn't we question the motive?
What is the point of registering at all if cloning is perfectly acceptable? Do I really need to start citing specific examples?
Are we going to open a new user account for every single subforum and thread??
Or is the trick this: that I can essentially bypass the rules however I please, and when I get too close to a ban, I simply open a pristine, virgin profile and carry on with the same behavior... indefinitely? And then, "beautifully," it all shows up in the site statistics, making the forum look like the most visited or most registered site in the entire universe?
Please, enlighten me... I just need to know what I'm wasting electricity on, and how I should proceed... someone else, please...