Michelle Nelson4 said:Parents often try to "sneak" classical languages into their kids' schedules by enrolling them in specialized private academies where class sizes are smaller and the pressure feels a bit more manageable. They figure, "Hey, it won't hurt them," and they just get used to it.
And of course, the entry scores look lower because they’re pulling from a disproportionately tiny pool of students, which ends up stretching that grading scale from a perfect 4.0 all the way down to a passing grade. Given how many kids are hitting those minimum requirements at local three-year vocational schools, I suspect there are still plenty of them out there 😁
Honestly, all this outrage about needing such high scores to get into an elite school like Isaac Newton is kind of ridiculous. It's the perfectly predictable outcome of a policy that decides admissions should be based solely on classroom grades and absolutely nothing else. Any time you make a one-sided decision like that, you're going to see these kinds of anomalies. This isn't a new problem; the current system has been fundamentally flawed for decades, and this is just one more symptom of that deep-rooted issue.
If they actually implemented standardized testing for the specific subjects these schools care about, then a kid's history grade wouldn't matter nearly as much. That would give students the actual power to choose between a STEM-focused academy or somewhere like Isaac Newton.
Regarding Isaac Newton—it’s about damn time they implemented an entrance exam. I mean, maybe I'm being too harsh, but honestly? It feels necessary at this point.
Michelle Nelson4 said:Honestly, even these "standard" programs have relatively low average scores compared to the rest of our top-tier prep schools. It's not just that the classicist approach isn't trendy anymore; it’s been true for at least a decade now—these are some of the easiest high-level academies to get into, provided you aren't looking at the ones out in the suburbs or those private Catholic schools that take anyone with a decent attitude.
I've heard enough people claiming that the technical high school over in Newport is absolutely top-tier—so, I guess if you don't manage to get into Isaac Newton, that’s where everyone ends up heading.
Kate Jackson4 said:It all comes down to the demographics... urban centers require significantly higher scores than the suburbs, and New York City is likely the worst case scenario.
The entry threshold for computer technicians climbs by about two points every year; in New York City, if you aren't an honor student, you're basically out of luck.
My boy won't even consider prep school... he says he has no interest in studying everything, just the things that actually matter to him.😁
Yeah, the cutoff scores are climbing—it’s getting absolutely ridiculous at this point. I mean, honestly, every school that's being flooded by these incoming waves really ought to implement an entrance exam, and one that actually carries more weight than what we're seeing now. It just seems like the only logical way to handle the influx, I guess. Maybe it's too blunt a solution, but things are getting out of hand.
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy A13 via Reddit