Curfew restrictions: Is it legal to leave your house?
in Coronavirus ·
You’ll probably have to take that question straight to the Secretary.
1236 posts shown.
Joseph Taylor11 said:Police departments—or just local precincts?
Because if I recall correctly, my suggestion was to limit movement based on individual precincts.
It’s funny seeing journalists just recycling questions straight from the forums... though I guess there's nothing wrong with that. 😉😁
hollowmason64 said:Seriously, stop giving me this drama about mental health just because people have to stay home for a couple of weeks. It’s not like they can’t go to the grocery store, the pharmacy, or wherever else they need to go—they just shouldn't be out wandering around unnecessarily.
Honestly, some people are just too sensitive.
Look, if we follow that logic—if it’s okay for people to lose it and ignore the rules because their "mental pressure is too high"—then is it okay for me to snap because I have to work wrapped in PPE and disinfect myself constantly? Is it okay if I smack someone over the head if they walk up to me at my job?
I’m reaching my limit here, I really am. Or should I expect a cashier to tell me to get lost whenever I ask a question?
Because actions have consequences.
If you guys are struggling on the inside, it isn't any easier for us out here, and we might just "snap" too.Chinese people welded shut apartment building doors in order to "maximally prevent infection." Are you actually supporting that?
If things in this country get to the point where people are literally dropping dead in the streets, and idiots are still wandering around ignoring the mandates, then yeah. Honestly, sometimes you have to protect the fools from themselves.Say there are twenty new cases in a week. Then what? Do you allow movement and social contact again? Do you bring schools back online? Reopen the professional sports leagues?
No, you’d first lift these movement restrictions, and then we'll see... whatever happens in the following days.
What you're talking about regarding suicides—those involve people who are inherently mentally unstable, and those types of individuals should be under supervision regardless of whether it's due to the coronavirus or not.If I recall correctly, an ID card showing your residence should be enough to prove where you belong.
Not necessarily. If you show up outside of your area without authorization and get caught, you can count on being ordered into self-isolation.
What do you mean "how can there be none"? This person is just trying to let you know you aren't alone in this. Take me, for example—I have a permit and I could easily go visit my family, whom I see every year for Easter, but it hasn't even crossed my mind. There are three elderly people and one younger person with a heart condition living there. It doesn't occur to me to risk putting them in danger just so I can visit. I wouldn't be able to show my face at the local bakery if I had to live with the fact that I might have accidentally brought an infection to them, God forbid.
I just don't think some people truly get it.
And it isn't the system's fault, nor is it yours or anyone else's for not updating addresses sooner—I suppose waiting until the last minute to handle paperwork is a job for fools.
Thomas Hernandez4 said:So, we can just sit here and cry about it.
I work and live in one place, but on paper, I'm registered somewhere else.
The official recommendation is to register your temporary residence through the government portal so you can actually move between where you live and where you're officially registered. But registering a temporary stay is impossible right now because the police are only handling emergencies.🤦 It’s like the left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing.
Easter is coming up, and I want to go visit my family at my permanent address. I'll probably make the trip there, but then I won't be able to get back to where I actually live and work because I don't have a permit. There's no way for me to get one, and I can't even register my current residence.
I honestly don't know who's crazier here.
hollowmason64 said:So, just because some people are struggling mentally, what are we supposed to do? Tailor every single regulation to every individual person?
These measures were put in place to stop the spread of the virus as much as possible, not to mess with anyone for fun.
When will it end? When we see a decrease in new cases for several days in a row.
Started what? You might want to check the news—there haven't been any new infections in Istria over the last two days. And keep in mind, that decision isn't even at the local level; it's coming from the national government.
I don't see many options besides paying it. You could go to court and try your luck seeing if some judge takes pity on you, but the odds are slim. Most likely, you'll just end up paying the full amount plus legal fees.
I just don't get why all those highly successful expats suddenly decided to move back home. Was it maybe because they got kicked into high gear by all that supposed "financial stability" abroad?
That logic is completely flawed.
Look, let’s be clear about this—these measures were implemented with the sole intention of preventing the spread of the infection as much as humanly possible; they weren't put in place just to mess with anyone or play games.
When exactly is this all going to wrap up? I mean, honestly—when are we actually going to see those numbers for new cases drop for several days in a row?
hollowmason64 said:Because in my mind, I connect the idea that the more people move around, the more they socialize and meet, which naturally extends our ability to tackle this evil.
I agree that this is brutal for people living in tight-knit small towns, and they really ought to find some kind of solution, like a weekly pass to handle necessary errands.I also don't understand how someone's life or wartime struggles from back in '91 have any bearing on whether today's restrictions are justified—a few people have used that exact logic to claim today's bans are total nonsense.
People were explaining that to those who kept insisting this was unbearable and that people would eventually snap. But it isn't true that it's unbearable; it was just an example of how much people can endure when they absolutely have to. It's all mental. And clearly, we've become quite unreasonable in the process.
Well, everyone has their own perspective. For what it's worth, I haven't left the house all week and I'm happy about it, though I am dreading having to go to the store next week.
wiredbison272 said:They shot down my request too, and they didn't even bother giving me a reason why. Honestly, whatever, if I need to head out, I'm going. They haven't caught me yet, and I'm really hoping they don't, but if they do decide to pull me over, they can try and hit me with a fine for all it matters to me.
hollowmason64 said:My wife was at home with our little one, who was dealing with a nasty case of appendicitis. He was doubling over in pain, just absolutely miserable. We tried calling emergency services, but they were being incredibly difficult about coming out. She actually had to get creative and find a workaround just to make sure he could get to the hospital without her breaking her own self-isolation protocols. It was a stressful situation, but we managed to get him the care he needed.
If someone really wants an excuse, they’ll always find one.The real culprits here? It’s the people who let skiers, doctors, and all those other groups just wander in and bring the infection back with them from out of state.
Exactly. It’s just like those same idiots who brought the virus home because they couldn't be bothered to actually follow self-isolation protocols, even though they knew exactly where they had been.
It’s really not that big of a deal. Honestly, looking at how much everyone is struggling, I’d be happy to send all of you over to work the jobs I have to deal with. You know, those roles where you actually have to interact with people face-to-face, where you're constantly wrapped up in gear, and where you're basically forced to wash your hands in alcohol just to make sure you don't accidentally pass a virus onto a water bottle because you forgot you were wearing gloves. It's definitely an experience.
Just wanted to share this so you guys can see how awesome it actually is.
hollowmason64 said:Nah, they actually solved that by putting way more cops on the road. Now, even if you’re cruising at 40 or 45, you have to drop down to 30 just because some idiot is doing 75, otherwise you'll end up getting pulled over too.
I was thinking more about people who actually live in the same community.
As for how long this lasts... personally, I wouldn't expect anything to wrap up before late May.
Fair enough, but what do you think would be a better solution?
don Kacunko said:I know of several cases in the local area where healthcare workers—people with actually decent salaries—were leaving for Germany to work in nursing homes. I just can’t wrap my head around it.
Joshua Gray75 said:http://hr.n1info.com/Vijesti/a496013...om-obliku.html
– Law enforcement reported they have received tips regarding suspected manipulations. I want to send a clear message to anyone engaging in this: it is a very serious criminal offense involving the forgery of documents, and there will be no leniency. Depending on the severity, this is an act that can carry prison time. We won't be handing out minimum sentences in a situation like this—stated Božinović, noting that the Department of the Interior, as the project lead, is working alongside the Department of Justice on an application designed to minimize the potential for permit manipulation. This specific application was presented yesterday during a meeting at the FBI, and once the details are further refined, they should be released to the public this Wednesday.
In other words—the police have people assigned specifically to monitor Reddit...
So, one should probably be careful about what gets posted.