Peter Greenaway
It’s a perfect example, really. There isn't much else to say. Honestly, I don't think his movies even make sense to him.
Narrative, visuals, and editing—if you hit that specific trifecta, you’ve got a masterpiece on your hands. Anything else is just a gamble that usually falls flat. Most filmmakers will tell you that the story is the bedrock of everything. It's hard to mess up direction too badly if the foundation is solid; basically, an average director can take a great script and turn it into something genuinely engaging. But if the story is garbage? You're fighting an uphill battle to make it anything remotely watchable. Which, honestly, explains why people struggle to call Signs a good movie. 🙄 😉 )
Film, being such a linear medium—not necessarily in terms of timeline, but just in how the information is fed to us—doesn't really leave much room for showing off. Unless, of course, the whole point is to make something completely incomprehensible from the jump. There’s this threshold where the average viewer's cognitive processes just... snap. If a movie doesn't actually keep the audience in mind, if it lacks that basic respect for the person watching, then it’s just a waste of time. Honestly, it shouldn't even be made. Take Lynch, for example. He’s one of those directors who constantly pushes that line right up to the edge where a film turns into pure chaos. Some of his stuff is just straight-up mayhem. You see similar vibes in earlier directors like Antonioni.
I can't help but feel like there’s this specific sweet spot you have to hit—you know? There needs to be a real balance between the actual story, the plot twists, and that raw dramatic tension on one side, and then the visual flair on the other. It’s tricky. Editing is basically the connective tissue of everything; sometimes it serves the narrative, and other times it’s purely about the visual rhythm. Finding a director who actually understands how to juggle both without leaning too hard into one or the other... well, that’s probably why truly great directors are such a rare breed. 🙂