Morgan Cooper34 said:Go read the thread about violent children. Personally, I've sat there and watched kids slap, spit at, and scream at their parents while the mother just crouches down next to them saying, "Oh honey, we don't do that."
Those kids grow up to be delinquents.
As for that bolded part, I was talking about parental statements and parental actions. In the sense that you truly never know how a single critique, a smack, or even just a harsh tone might wreck a child's self-esteem and shape their future behavior.
John Parker5—you're comparing spanking a kid for every little thing to "major" offenses. Take me, for example. I got my first real beating when I swiped candy from a convenience store for the fourth time. I was four years old. For the first three times, my mom tried the gentle approach—"Sweetie, that's not right, that's not okay." But honestly? If she hadn't laid the hammer down on that fourth time, I probably would've kept stealing.
I'm right there with the author on this one. 👍
I definitely support discipline when it's necessary. I remember mine clearly, and even now at thirty years old, I know I earned every bit of it. 🤷
Once, my dad really laid into me because I went outside during a New Year's Eve celebration in a rough part of town where bullets were actually flying through the air. My dad had explicitly forbidden it, but I went anyway. When I finally walked through the door, he was absolutely white with worry and rage. He headed straight for me and I tried to lock myself in my room... 😁 but he kicked the door down and gave me what I deserved. It worked, too; I never thought about doing something that reckless again.
He once told me that every disciplinary measure he took was JUST ANOTHER FORM OF LOVE, because if he didn't love me, he wouldn't bother looking out for me in the first place. Looking back, I'm actually grateful to him and my mom for every lesson they taught me. 😍 And I don't carry any trauma from it!
I should also mention that having a busy modern schedule isn't an excuse for poor parenting. My parents held high-level executive positions and were incredibly busy, but they made up for it with the quality of the time they spent raising me, rather than just the quantity.
There was no way I wasn't eating whatever Mom cooked (if she got upset and stayed silent, I’d lose my dinner privileges!), which taught me to respect the food provided. There was no way I wasn't in bed by 8 PM, brushing my teeth, or greeting every guest who walked through our front door. No swearing, no cursing, 🙂 and so on... not to mention the absolute respect we showed our teachers and professors in school.
Nowadays, when I see my best friend, it’s heartbreaking. She has spoiled her daughter rotten because she refuses to discipline her when she deserves it. The little girl fights with kids in preschool and even hits the nannies watching her just because they won't give her everything she wants—just like her mom does, who just buys her gifts because she's too afraid to actually parent. This kid has been a little tyrant since she was four, and her parents can't even have a second child because she's too demanding, yet they refuse to see that they are the ones failing! Every time they go out, it’s a total meltdown because she’s hysterical when she doesn't get her way, and if they give in, there's no end to the demands. It turns a simple outing into whatever whim the child has. It's a disaster! 👎