Timothy Jones85 said:...
Look, while I certainly respect your subjective reasoning—truly, I do—I have to tell you that you’ve lost your marbles just a little bit here. The band you’re so fiercely defending, specifically mentioning The Killers, actually releases through a much larger label than Franz Ferdinand does... and they command equal, if not greater, airplay. The only real distinction lies in which continent you're on or which MTV franchise is playing them. I honestly don't see what the issue is with FF being a pop band? Is it simply because they aren't afraid to show that they possess actual style in addition to musical talent? Furthermore—and this is a point worth noting—you have stated countless times that you haven't even listened to one of their albums from start to finish, so one might question how qualified you are to judge their pop potential. To be perfectly honest, I was also quite negatively predisposed toward that band until I actually sat down and listened to the album(s)... and things changed. They aren't my absolute favorite band in the world, but they are certainly among the better pop acts to emerge recently. I've even seen them live, and I must admit, I didn't experience a single shred of that indie snobbery or insincerity you seem to be describing. In fact, I had a wonderful time. I am a massive lover of pop music—in whatever sense you choose to define it—stretching all the way back from The Beatles. Sure, Top 40 music can sound polished and manufactured, and Britney Spears can be a pampered showbiz princess, but my goodness, Toxic is a million times better than, say, Speed of Sound. And strictly speaking, as a fan of guitars and drums, I really ought to side with Coldplay. But think about it... when you deconstruct those two tracks, one sounds like something Roy Orbison might have penned, while the other—if you were to swap in some American lyrics—could easily pass for a new single by Vatra. Franz Ferdinand certainly isn't the most original band on the planet, but within the framework of pop music, they definitely offer something a bit above average; intelligent lyrics, an energetic danceable rhythm, and infectious melodies. Does pop music necessarily need to offer more?
Ultimately, I find myself valuing the performers who aren't afraid to show who they are and where they come from, far more than those "true" punks or rockers who try to maintain their standing in pop culture through mere aesthetics and posturing rather than actual talent.