Joseph Edwards4
MemberOP
29 messages
joined Oct 2014
I would probably enjoy this more if it weren't on the level of the Election or the Drug War films I've seen from him, but it seems decent enough. It feels more like a drama than an action flick; sure, there are some action beats, but they don't take over. Some of those early scenes actually reminded me a bit of a Tony Scott movie.
In my opinion, the real strength here lies in the two leads. We don't get a deep dive into their backstories—they're mostly just written as "cool" characters—but they work. You have one top-tier police inspector and excellent hostage negotiator Ho Sheung-Sang, who is the smartest guy in the precinct surrounded by idiots, and then you have this mysterious high-level criminal with hidden motives. They're compelling because criminals are always more interesting than the cop; the officer is a total cliché, whereas the underworld perspective keeps things engaging.
As for the actual staging, that bus scene was great. I do wish they had expanded on the dynamic between the robbers and the girl a bit more; we could have learned so much about his character through that interaction, but instead, we're forced to learn everything through the investigation. Was that a mistake in direction? Maybe.
Overall, I found this to be a good, entertaining watch. The ending was a bit cliché and overly sentimental, but I guess it fits.
Johnnie is an interesting director. Even though I haven't seen much of his work yet, I'm digging his style so far.