CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Culture & Entertainment › Movies › Acting Legends: Robert De Niro's Best Performances...

Acting Legends: Robert De Niro's Best Performances...

Started by hollowsailor19 · · 👁 6 views · 27 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants hollowsailor19briskhound2Noah Roberts46Grace Edwardsironranger67Richard Wilson4ironraven45James Harris34Ashley Newman67nimblescout50Lisa Patel4Emily Fox2Casey Cox2Patrick MartinSamuel Scott54
hollowsailor19 hollowsailor19 Active MemberOP
54 messages
joined Aug 2007
#1 ·
image

Robert De Niro was born into a family of artists. His mother, Admiral Virginia, was a painter, while his father—who happened to share his name—was a bit more of a polymath, working as a painter, sculptor, and poet. Growing up in such a creative environment gave him a lot of freedom, though being the fair-skinned kid in his neighborhood near Little Italy earned him the nickname "Bobby Milk." His parents split when he was only two, and there’s always been that bit of neighborhood gossip suggesting his father might have been gay, which led people to link him to figures like Robert Duncan, Tennessee Williams, and Jackson Pollock.

Even though he lived at home with his mother, his father used to take him to the movies whenever they could get together, and apparently, the kid would spend the entire walk home imitating the actors who caught his eye. Up until he was ten, people say he was incredibly shy and kept to himself, but everything shifted after he played the Cowardly Lion in a school production of The Wizard of Oz. By the time he hit thirteen, his mother enrolled him in a pretty progressive private school, New York's High School of Music and Art, but he wasn't quite ready for that level of pressure yet, so he ended up dropping out.

He’ll be heading back to the classroom soon, specifically to the legendary Stella Adler conservatory where he studied the Method alongside Lee Strasberg. It’s that kind of pedigree—that deep dive into character psychology and actually walking a mile in someone else's shoes—that defines his later career. He actually earned his first paycheck at sixteen acting in Chekhov's *The Bear*, before spending the next decade grinding it out on stage in various Off-Broadway productions.

De Niro’s real breakthrough actually traces back to his early work with a then-up-and-coming director, Brian De Palma. He had a tiny role in the 1963 film Wedding Party, though since it didn't hit screens until 1969, he mostly flew under the radar. His next two projects were also De Palma collaborations—Greetings and Hi, Mom!—both of which offered these biting, satirical takes on sex, consumerism, and the counterculture movement. It wasn't until 1973 that people really started paying attention, though. That was when he played the dying ballplayer Bruce Pearson in Bang the Drum Slowly, a performance that finally earned him an Oscar-level nod from the New York critics.

De Niro was on fire that year. It all kicked off with Mean Streets, marking the start of his legendary run with Martin Scorsese—who, let’s be honest, found him to be an incredibly prolific muse. Over the course of their partnership, they would go on to film eight movies together. In between those Scorsese collaborations, he hit global stardom and earned the title of a "new icon" thanks to Francis Ford Coppola's The Godfather: Part II. He actually snagged an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor for his portrayal of young Vito Corleone, a role for which he spent four straight months mastering the local dialect just to get it right.

After that minor role in the film I mentioned earlier, Scorsese basically handed him the keys to the kingdom, landing him lead roles in films that have since become absolute staples for any serious cinephile—we’re talking *Taxi Driver*, *Raging Bull*, and *Goodfellas*. They aren't just movies; they're essential viewing. We find ourselves circling back once again to De Niro's intense method of preparing for a part. For his portrayal of the boxer Jack LaMotta in *Raging Bull*, he actually packed on about sixty pounds. He actually told the press later that he sparred so many rounds with De Niro during rehearsals that he could probably send him into a professional ring without a second thought. It’s hardly surprising that Bobby Milk walked away with an Oscar for that performance. It seems his most brilliant work happens under Scorsese’s direction, playing those brutal, volatile characters who dance right on the edge of a psychotic break.

He picked up an Oscar nod for his turn as the unforgettable lunatic Travis Bickle in *Taxi Driver*, just as he did for his portrayal of Michael Vronski in *The Deer Hunter* back in '78. Naturally, the trophies and the praise started stacking up. But looking back at those late seventies, it feels like De Niro might have fallen slightly too deep into a specific groove—that "master of the mobster" archetype, complete with a heavy Italian-American accent (even though his roots lean more toward Irish than Italian). He ended up paying for that pigeonhole in the nineties, when his films tended to drift by without much of a splash or any real cultural footprint.

During those strange years in the nineties, we actually got to see him in some newer releases—like his take on 'Frankenstein' (1994), or tracking a samurai through the underworld in 'Ronin' (1998). It’s practically impossible (and frankly, a bit pointless) to list every single one of his films since he's racked up about seventy of them by now. That said, lately, he seems to have pivoted toward comedies quite often—starting with 'Analyze This' (1999), then 'Flawless' (1999), 'Meet the Parents' (2000), and the massive hit 'Meet the Fockers' (2004). He still finds space for thrillers too, like 'Godsend' (2004) and 'Hide and Seek' (2005).

At the end of the day, the nickname De Niro says a lot about his career moves (and his paycheck, obviously). He’s spent years polishing his reputation through his own company, Tribeca Film, while keeping his private life strictly under wraps. He's notorious for rarely doing interviews, and when he does, reporters usually get a list of topics that are strictly off-limits. Still, his chaotic personal life hasn't exactly stayed hidden from the public eye—between being married twice and having kids scattered everywhere, there are always rumors about his ties to beauties like Naomi Campbell.
.
hollowsailor19 hollowsailor19 Active MemberOP
54 messages
joined Aug 2007
#2 ·
So, which film features the absolute best performance De Niro has ever given?

Mean Streets
image

The Godfather: Part II
image

Taxi Driver
image

Novecento
image

New York, New York
image
hollowsailor19 hollowsailor19 Active MemberOP
54 messages
joined Aug 2007
#3 ·
The Deer Hunter
image

Raging Bull
image

The King of Comedy
image

Once Upon a Time in America
image

The Mission
image
hollowsailor19 hollowsailor19 Active MemberOP
54 messages
joined Aug 2007
#4 ·
Angel Heart
image

The Untouchables
image

Midnight Run
image

Jacknife
image

Goodfellas
image
hollowsailor19 hollowsailor19 Active MemberOP
54 messages
joined Aug 2007
#5 ·

Awakenings
image

Cape Fear
image

Mad Dog and Glory
image

A Bronx Tale
image

Las Vegas
image
hollowsailor19 hollowsailor19 Active MemberOP
54 messages
joined Aug 2007
#6 ·
Heat
image

Ronin
image

Everybody's Fine
image

Silver Linings Playbook
image

Red Lights
image
briskhound2 briskhound2 Regular
411 messages
joined Mar 2009
#7 ·
Analyze This...
Noah Roberts46 Noah Roberts46 Regular
407 messages
joined Jun 2021
#8 ·
So many incredible movies, yet there’s no real debate here—Raging Bull features one of the greatest acting performances ever put on screen. As far as supporting roles go, that performance in Angel Heart is absolutely top-tier. Scary shit.
Grace Edwards Grace Edwards Active Member
184 messages
joined May 2023
#9 ·
Dirty Grandpa - I mean, you've got this 70-year-old guy who can pull off one-handed pushups and actually looks better than Arnold Schwarzenegger ever did back in his bodybuilding days.
And yeah, he was pretty decent in Taxi Driver and Las Vegas.
ironranger67 ironranger67 Active Member
52 messages
joined Oct 2018
#10 ·
I’m having a bit of a hard time making up my mind—part of me really wants to just go out there and pull off a performance that crazy in 🙏
.
hollowsailor19 hollowsailor19 Active MemberOP
54 messages
joined Aug 2007
#11 ·
ironranger67 said:I can't quite settle on a label, but I'd definitely play that kind of idiocy in Cape Fear.🙏

Psychopath, lunatic, maniac—those would be more accurate terms.🙏
Richard Wilson4 Richard Wilson4 Veteran
2K messages
joined Sep 2009
#12 ·
I went with Casino.

Everyone’s gonna pick The Godfather or The Deer Hunter first, and honestly, they've got a point, but for me, this one was absolute perfection too.
ironraven45 ironraven45 Member
31 messages
joined Jul 2012
#13 ·
hollowsailor19... You're really putting me through the wringer here! 😁

Fine, let's just go with Taxi Driver.
James Harris34 James Harris34 Active Member
63 messages
joined Jun 2014
#14 ·
In my opinion, Godfather 2 is incredible. I’m really impressed by the sense of calm authority he brings to the role; you can clearly see how the character evolves from what we saw in Godfather. Plus, the way he handles all that Italian dialogue is so seamless and authentic, you'd never guess it wasn't his native language.
hollowsailor19 hollowsailor19 Active MemberOP
54 messages
joined Aug 2007
#15 ·
My top 5 performances of all time:
1. Raging Bull - hands down the best work De Niro has ever put on screen. He earned that Oscar, and it belongs in any conversation about the greatest performances ever captured.
2. Taxi Driver - honestly, it sits right up there alongside Raging Bull.
3. Cape Fear - this was a masterclass. He showed off his full range here, delivering a chilling performance as a pure-evil redneck that easily outshines Mitchum.
4. The Deer Hunter - one of his most emotional turns. He isn't playing some mobster or psychopath here; he’s just a regular guy, a soldier trying to process everything after coming home from Vietnam.
5. Awakenings - seeing De Niro play a sick patient? It’s actually a shame he doesn't lean into these kinds of heavy, character-driven roles more often.

Top 5 underrated roles:
1. The King of Comedy - criminally overlooked. De Niro absolutely carries this movie; if you ask me, his performance here was even stronger than Kingsley's in Gandhi.
2. Midnight Run - definitely much more than just your standard comedy.
3. Casino - as someone already mentioned, it's a brilliant turn.
Playing Sam 'Ace' Tohstein—that greedy, composed Casino manager.
4. Heat - released the same year as Casino (1995), featuring that iconic De Niro vs Pacino showdown. In my opinion, De Niro had the edge here.
5. A Bronx Tale - more of a supporting role, but it served as a great directorial debut and offered excellent casting. For an actor known for playing ruthless mobsters, seeing him play against that type was refreshing.

Top 5 overrated roles:
1. The Untouchables - even though his screen time wasn't massive, he felt completely wooden as Al Capone.
2. Jackie Brown - De Niro & Tarantino; you'd think it would be a slam dunk, but it felt like Robert was more interested in the paycheck than the craft.
3. Analyze This - no comment needed.
4. Analyze That - no comment needed.
5. Hide and Seek - what can you say when you can figure out who the villain is just by watching the trailer?
Ashley Newman67 Ashley Newman67 Newcomer
1 message
joined Dec 2022
#16 ·
It's a tough call... I'd give The Deer Hunter a tiny edge over Taxi Driver and Godfather 2.
nimblescout50 nimblescout50 Active Member
88 messages
joined May 2012
#17 ·
It’s a shame there aren't any more options left on the table. Everything feels pretty much picked over at this point—kind of like looking at a menu where everything has been crossed out except for the one thing you didn't actually want to order. You just kind of sit there, staring at the limited selection, wondering when things got so narrow.
I would've gone with at least two, honestly—but I had to settle for just one.
So, if we had put Taxi Driver before Once Upon a Time in America, we probably would have stumbled upon another title or two.
Lisa Patel4 Lisa Patel4 Active Member
195 messages
joined Oct 2014
#18 ·
Since I view him as being in that elite tier alongside Pacino, Brand, and several other icons from old Hollywood, picking just one film is tough.

Maybe it's Godfather because of that Italian heritage he learned back in Sicily, or The Deer Hunter since it’s such an anti-war masterpiece, or maybe Raging Bull because of those intense physical preparations for the role.

Personally, I can't forget his work in Cape Fear, though I'd say Taxi Driver is his greatest performance. I guess that's the film that really defined him.
Emily Fox2 Emily Fox2 Active Member
103 messages
joined Oct 2012
#19 ·
Once upon a time in the USA
James Harris34 James Harris34 Active Member
63 messages
joined Jun 2014
#20 ·
I think Robert De Niro killed it as Al Capone in Untouchable, though he definitely didn't get enough screen time since the movie focused so heavily on that specific role. Still, that opening scene and the one where he uses the baseball bat to take out that guy were pure genius. I also feel like he was fantastic in Analyze This and Meet the Parents—he really showed off his comedic timing there, even if the other two movies felt a bit forced...

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads