CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Sports › Other Sports › Overrated sports icons?

Overrated sports icons?

Started by Raymond Anderson4 · · 👁 12 views · 164 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Raymond Anderson4Matthew Anderson4frozentiger6James Rivera2Carl Brooks22nimblesurfer17Grace Adams32darkjackal70Patrick Taylor9Peter Carter6Jessica Gonzalezjadeskipper74darkrider55gentlebear47Matthew Martinez7Lisa Miller7shadowridge14dustypanther6mistycyclist51Emily Thomas3Edward Kim76dustyridge3Henry Lee84darkwolf61 …
darkwolf61 darkwolf61 Member
15 messages
joined Jul 2012
#141 ·
Honestly, David Beckham was an absolutely phenomenal player. 🤷
The guy basically defined American soccer over the last thirteen years...
Now, I’m not saying he’s in that absolute god-tier category—you know, not quite at the level of Cristiano Ronaldo or Messi or Zidane—but he was truly an elite athlete.
Matthew Anderson4 Matthew Anderson4 Regular
598 messages
joined Jun 2013
#142 ·
honestly, David Beckham gets way too much hate
Jack Murphy5 Jack Murphy5 Active Member
59 messages
joined Feb 2014
#143 ·
Jason Fisher78 said:Michael Jordan, Ayrton Senna, Alen Boksic, David Beckham, Frank Lampard. ☕

Michael Jordan🤣
dustyridge3 dustyridge3 Active Member
62 messages
joined May 2012
#144 ·
Jason Fisher78 said:Michael Jordan, Ayrton Senna, Alen Boksic, David Beckham, Frank Lampard. ☕

If you ask me, not a single one of these individuals is overrated.
Maria Nelson12 Maria Nelson12 Member
37 messages
joined Aug 2010
#145 ·
Jack Murphy5 said:Michael Jordan🤣

Yeah, Michael Jordan ☕.
darkjackal70 darkjackal70 Member
23 messages
joined Nov 2024
#146 ·
Jason Fisher78 said:Yes, Michael Jordan ☕.

Come on, just give me one single logical argument, anything at all...

Or honestly, just go find a gun and end it already.☕
gentlebear47 gentlebear47 Member
27 messages
joined Jul 2009
#147 ·
dustyridge3 said:Honestly, I don't think any of these guys are overrated.

Man, we could go back and forth on this all day, especially when you bring up that brazilac!
Paul Lopez6 Paul Lopez6 Member
24 messages
joined Jan 2012
#148 ·
Jason Fisher78 said:Yeah, Michael Jordan ☕.

Oh yeah, Michael Jordan... ☕️☕️☕️

6× Super Bowl Champion
6× Super Bowl MVP
5× NBA Most Valuable Player
2× Gold Medal Winner in the Olympics
14× NBA All-Star
10× All-NBA First Team
9× All-Defensive Team
NBA Rookie of the Year

and so on, and so forth...
Jack Murphy5 Jack Murphy5 Active Member
59 messages
joined Feb 2014
#149 ·
Jason Fisher78 said:Yeah, Michael Jordan ☕.

How could he possibly be overrated? Please, enlighten those of us who aren't following your logic.
Chris Ortiz Chris Ortiz Active Member
88 messages
joined Dec 2010
#150 ·
Jason Fisher78 said:Michael Jordan, Ayrton Senna, Alen Boksic, David Beckham, Frank Lampard. ☕

Haha, I have to wonder how you managed to bundle that first duo together with those three in a single sentence.🤣

Roger Federer, Michael Schumacher, Lionel Messi, Kobe Bryant, Mike Tyson, and a legendary heavyweight boxer.
placidfalcon4 placidfalcon4 Member
44 messages
joined Feb 2010
#151 ·
Chris Ortiz said:Michael Schumacher

🙏

How did I forget about this absolute trash 🤣

The most overrated athlete ever. EVER.

Not planning on explaining myself—it just is what it is. 😁
wiredmason10 wiredmason10 Member
15 messages
joined Aug 2010
#152 ·
Is anyone actually going to mention Michael Jordan? 🙂

Speaking of overrated icons, here's a few that come to mind: Kakati, Cristiano Ronaldo, Maria Sharapova, Wayne Rooney, Marko Ukić, Lewis Hamilton...
darkwolf61 darkwolf61 Member
15 messages
joined Jul 2012
#153 ·
Look, we really need to distinguish between an athlete who is simply world-class in their field and someone who has become a global currency—a person the entire world recognizes because they’ve transcended their sport through sheer marketing power as much as athletic talent.
If we're talking about the latter... I honestly can't think of anyone who represents such an exaggerated value, because so many people the world admires are genuinely top-tier athletes (think Mike Tyson, Ayrton Senna, Pete Sampras, Roger Federer, Cristiano Ronaldo, Maradona, Tiger Woods, Michael Jordan, Babe Ruth, Pelé, Usain Bolt, Michael Phelps, and so on).
Now, David Beckham might not be in that absolute stratosphere, but he is a premier athlete, a consummate professional, and a phenomenal player who elevated his sport in certain respects—and he certainly isn't overrated as a high-caliber footballer.
Perhaps people tend to underestimate him because they don't want to accept that he isn't Kim Kardashian or Paris Hilton, someone who essentially exists to live off media hype. Personally, I've never heard of any scandal regarding his professional conduct that would diminish his standing as an athlete, and at the end of the day, that's the only thing that truly matters.

Overrated athletes within the context of their own sports? Vince Carter, most of the recent generation of footballers (Gareth Bale, Wayne Rooney, Robinho, Sergio Ramos, Nani, Mesut Özil, Karim Benzema, Edin Džeko, Carles Puyol...), Gary Hall Jr., Lewis Hamilton.... 🤷
Paul Lopez6 Paul Lopez6 Member
24 messages
joined Jan 2012
#154 ·
I honestly think the most overrated player in the entire universe has gotta be Ricky Rubio.
darkwolf61 darkwolf61 Member
15 messages
joined Jul 2012
#155 ·
Paul Lopez6 said:The most overrated player in the history of the universe is Ricky Rubio.

Honestly, he is massively overrated—I truly have no clue what people see in him. Maybe it's some sort of motor skills or something else that we mere amateurs just don't grasp... all I know is—whenever the ball is in his hands, it feels like you've just tossed it straight into a bottomless well.
Paul Lopez6 Paul Lopez6 Member
24 messages
joined Jan 2012
#156 ·
darkwolf61 said:Yeah, honestly? He’s massively overrated. I have no clue what people actually see in him—maybe some weird motor skills or something that us mere mortals just don't grasp. All I know is—when he gets the ball, it's like watching someone toss a coin into a deep well. Just... gone.

The thing is, everyone's been saying he's been "the next big thing" for like five years now, even though he's basically been stuck at age sixteen forever. That's just the general vibe in the States.
darkwolf61 darkwolf61 Member
15 messages
joined Jul 2012
#157 ·
It’s honestly just like what they’ve been saying about that young phenom for five years now—that kid is a total rising star... 🙂
Maria Nelson12 Maria Nelson12 Member
37 messages
joined Aug 2010
#158 ·
Jack Murphy5 said:How could he possibly be overrated? Explain it to those of us who aren't following.

Nice. Americans always need their all-American hero, I guess. Back when the NBA was expanding, someone just decided he was going to be that guy, and it worked. I’m not saying he wasn't a good player, but his god-tier status was mostly a marketing masterpiece rather than pure talent. He had this incredible PR machine that kicked off with those gold chains at the dunk contest and just kept rolling. The media treated every little move he made like some superhuman feat, even though plenty of other players were doing the exact same stuff—they just weren't under a microscope. Then there was all that hype about how he'd win a title anywhere he went, which we saw play out in Washington, D.C. If he didn't have that massive clout—the kind of authority he was handed before he even proved he was better than average, unlike everyone else—he probably would've ended up winning nothing. He likely would've just been one of those solid, above-average guys who couldn't win anything because of bad teammates, stuck in the same tier as Dominique Wilkins, Karl Malone, Patrick Ewing, or Clyde Drexler.

You see how the media operates whenever Jordan left. They were desperate to manufacture a successor—someone slightly less than Jordan, obviously—which led to that whole string of "Baby Jordans" until they finally landed on Kobe Bryant, who ran into a bit of a statistical hurdle called Shaquille O'Neal. Just imagine if Shaq had played more like Dennis Rodman, grabbing every board and feeding Kobe. Not to mention that Kerrov gimmick or that legendary game against the Utah Jazz. Without those guys, there wouldn't be any rings or half as much fame. Once Kobe became too much of a liability for the narrative, they swapped him out for LeBron James and so on. I'm not saying Kobe isn't great, but the media definitely plays a role.

I'd honestly love to know what makes Jordan better than someone like Bill Russell.
Maria Nelson12 Maria Nelson12 Member
37 messages
joined Aug 2010
#159 ·
Chris Ortiz said:hahhah, I don't know how you even managed to cram those first two legends in the same sentence as that trio🤣

Roger Federer, Michael Schumacher, Messi, Kobe Bryant, Mike Tyson, Barry Bonds

Roger Federer and Michael Schumacher? I mean, Federer is probably the most dominant tennis player ever, and tennis is an individual sport. Same goes for Schumacher. Sure, it depends on the car and the crew, but he actually knew how to pull off decent results even with a total junker like a Benetton. Honestly, I guess the whole of Formula 1 is just one big overrated mess. ☕
Maria Nelson12 Maria Nelson12 Member
37 messages
joined Aug 2010
#160 ·
darkwolf61 said:Yeah, he's massively overrated. I honestly don't get what people see in him.

It’s not even fans, really—it's just the media. It's that whole Michael Jordan syndrome, I guess. ☕

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads