CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Culture & Entertainment › Music › How much do you guys care about word choice?

How much do you guys care about word choice?

Started by hiddenskipper72 · · 👁 5 views · 98 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants hiddenskipper72ruggedridge45Jason Chavez32stormyviper11analogharbor442Daniel Bailey7gentlepuma20frozentinker432Lisa Moore7Nicholas Perez33stormywolf39fadedowlZachary Thompson9Noah Myers67Samuel Murphy6wiredfalcon2Samuel Ortiz3hollowseal33Sean Lee7lonebison37placidotter15AChloe Alvarez55Susan Edwards3 …
hiddenskipper72 hiddenskipper72 NewcomerOP
6 messages
joined Feb 2007
#81 ·
I’m honestly kind of floored by how many people claim they prefer the vocals to just be some background texture for the instruments—it’s wild. To me, there are certain artists where the voice is the entire soul of the track, and I feel like
they use their range and vocal power as the lead instrument itself. I'm talking about legends like Regina Spektor or Björk, and even looking closer to home, someone like Norah Jones (though, honestly, I'm not even sure what people mean when they call her "one of ours" 😬 since we're all over the map here)
. What do you guys think of
these musical examples?
Raymond Barrett12 Raymond Barrett12 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Jan 2008
#82 ·
Elizabeth Fraser
Nicholas Perez33 Nicholas Perez33 Veteran
1.4K messages
joined Jun 2005
#83 ·
unknown 🙂
hiddenskipper72 hiddenskipper72 NewcomerOP
6 messages
joined Feb 2007
#84 ·
Andrew Stewart2;7188771 said:
man, I’d honestly love to sit down and just vibe to Neil Young, whether he’s going solo or rocking out with Crazy Horse. But this D, A, G track? It wouldn't even feel like that unknown song if you stripped away the lyrics. It would just be D, A, G. You could basically listen to Thompson doing the same thing; she knows how to string a few chords together and belt out whatever comes to mind. Take her new single "Friški"—that's a perfect example of that style.



I’m totally with Andrew Stewart2 on this one, because that’s exactly where the issue lies—when the singer isn't really singing, but more like they're just reciting the lyrics like a poem...
Andrew Stewart2 Andrew Stewart2 Member
19 messages
joined Apr 2006
#85 ·
analogharbor442 said:Of course they aren't... have you even heard of MIDI or the concept of actual played instruments?

Aaaa, okay, so we're talking MIDI, then. My bad. I've never even been within ten feet of a setup like that, so honestly... I'm just shooting in the dark here.

But look, let's talk about songs with actual performances. Case in point: I just picked up that legendary '69 Stones live album everyone raves about. I'm listening to, say, unknown right now. The solos work fine, sure, but those verses? Without lyrics, they'd feel totally hollow. Yeah, yeah, the vocals carry the melody, but man, what they're actually saying matters to me. I need the songwriting to be at least decent, you know? Just can't stand empty filler.

Bottom line is, lyrics are huge for me. I'm a big Bob Dylan fan... I mean, what would masters of War even be without those words? Nothing. Absolutely nothing.
wanderingraven20 wanderingraven20 Newcomer
1 message
joined Jul 2008
#86 ·
analogharbor442 said:GOT ANY CASH? I NEED A BEER
(dedicated to Mars Volta)

in the darkness of a ratified fallacy
against stenographic minor keys
democratic Christians demystify the rallentando cephalic void
inspectors devour imaginary visualized hapax legomena through correction
a tourniquet drips from the theatergoer’s ear
vomiting retrobulbar taxonomic scripts
reality crawls through cosmolitic pores
the noctambulistic fistula becomes viscous
through Trojan palaces soaked in colodion
asbestos biotypes darken their minds
revising the process of toxicopathic decisiveness
stealing their proskinesic sense via defenestration

The verse-driven debut "Spirit of the Heartland," by young analogharbor442, is essentially a manuscript attempting to leap from the position of decentralized poetic scraps into the margins of two highly significant—yet overused—poetic "models" in modern American literature: first, the poetry of linguistic experience, and subsequently, the new textualism. It is, quite frankly, a manuscript that falls into an intermediate mess of literary script due to its chaotic and incoherent flow, returning to alternative music genres what those genres once borrowed from literature. The semantic concreteness of this poetry, obvious even in the title ("Got any cash?"), points the reader directly toward the author's aggressive confrontation with his own shame and existential poverty—he’s thirsty, and he needs money for a beer. That’s it. No fluff, no pretension, no deep metaphors here.

The somnambulant allure of this postmodernist palimpsest is undeniable. However, we mustn't forget that the American Midwest has produced several exceptional musical poets in the past. Whether this kid will stand alongside legends like Bob Dylan or Neil Young is irrelevant, because with his raw poetic directness and almost aggressive nihilism, analogharbor442 has inadvertently revised the metaphysical way we remember his predecessors. In fact, with lines like "...toxicopathic decisiveness / stealing their proskinesic sense via defenestration," he might have already surpassed them.

Will the deconstruction imposed by this writing find a positive reception among readers? Will this work successfully trigger an asbestos-like resistance to alcoholism in the audience—since the author himself clearly failed at it—or will we all just end up with "beer begging syndrome"? We'll see. At least until the latest cognitive theories from Dr. unknown, that influential researcher from the Linguistic Institute, are confirmed—suggesting that deconstruction is actually a serious infectious disease of the modern world, and beer merely exacerbates the contraindications for its cure.

Until then, my advice: avoid the deconstructivist analogharbor442 and just listen to Mars Volta. 😬
Nicholas Perez33 Nicholas Perez33 Veteran
1.4K messages
joined Jun 2005
#87 ·
:S
Jason Chavez32 Jason Chavez32 Active Member
56 messages
joined Dec 2007
#88 ·
Andrew Stewart2 said:Aren't karaoke tracks basically just the original song recordings, minus the vocals?

And don't even get me started on listening to Mozart's fugues on an old Siemens C35! 😲

That Viennese classical stuff is honestly pretty overrated... 😳
Jason Chavez32 Jason Chavez32 Active Member
56 messages
joined Dec 2007
#89 ·
Here are two music videos that serve as a perfect little case study in how differently people can connect with the same track—it really all comes down to what you value in a song and, ultimately, your own unique taste.

CAKE - short skirt long jacket (West Coast edit)
CAKE - short skirt long jacket (New York version)
analogharbor442 analogharbor442 Member
13 messages
joined Nov 2006
#90 ·
Samuel Murphy6 Samuel Murphy6 Regular
740 messages
joined Apr 2006
#91 ·
Honestly, it’s getting exhausting when it feels like 95% of all songs are just recycling the exact same tired lyrics:

call on me
i'm the same boy i used to be

👋 👋 👋
lonebison37 lonebison37 Newcomer
6 messages
joined Aug 2003
#92 ·
The absolute best lyric ever written is this one from Francijev:

WHAT THE HELL?!
what the hell..?
what the hell?!
WHAT THE HELL?!
😠 😠
boldscout72 boldscout72 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Apr 2007
#93 ·
analogharbor442 said:Speaking of Mars Volta—I actually sat down a while back and drafted some lyrics for them... just playing around with the vibe:

GOT SOME CASH, NEED A COLD ONE
(Dedicated to Mars Volta)

In the shadows of a ratified fallacy
Against the stenographic minor leagues
Democrat-Christians demystify the rallentando turicéphaly
Inspectors devour imaginary visualized hapax legomena through correction
The tourniquet drips from the theatergoer's ear
Regurgitating retrobulbar taxonomic scripts
Reality creeps through cosmolitic pores
The noctambulistic fistula turns viscous
Through Trojan palaces soaked in collodion
Asbestos biotypologies cloud their minds
Revising the process of toxicopathic decisiveness
Defenestrating their prokinetic sense

🙏 🙏 🙏 🙏 🙏

The lyrics have to be sharp. Witty. Sophisticated. 😁
analogharbor442 analogharbor442 Member
13 messages
joined Nov 2006
#94 ·
Samuel Murphy6 said:It’s honestly exhausting when 95% of songs follow the exact same lyrical formula:

call on me
i'm the same boy i used to be

👋 👋 👋

it goes:
"valerie, call on me
i'm the same boy i used to be"
and obviously, we're talking about the superior original version here. 😘
Zachary Thompson9 Zachary Thompson9 Active Member
73 messages
joined Oct 2006
#95 ·
hey, analogharbor442—mind if I ask what kind of "state" you were actually in (mental, physical, or just straight-up liquid...) when you sat down to write this masterpiece? 🙂
Kevin Chavez3 Kevin Chavez3 Veteran
2.4K messages
joined Dec 2002
#96 ·
He was from a place like St. Louis
gentlepuma20 gentlepuma20 Newcomer
1 message
joined Jun 2005
#97 ·
I haven't seen you write about kids like this before... I guess you're just being difficult 😈
Raymond Barrett12 Raymond Barrett12 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Jan 2008
#98 ·
Samuel Murphy6 Samuel Murphy6 Regular
740 messages
joined Apr 2006
#99 ·
analogharbor442 said:goes:
"valerie, call on me
i'm the same boy i used to be"
and obviously, we're talking about the vastly superior original version of the track 😘

no 😉 👋

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads