stormytiger4
Active Member
148 messages
joined Feb 2020
Comparing different sports is a messy business. Look, you can't really compare the UFC to a single gym; it's more like comparing them to an entire league. They might look like a club, but they’ve got over 500 fighters under their roof, 400 employees, they handle all their own fight promotion, manage their own rankings, hand out their own belts, and even self-regulate when they travel to parts of the world without an MMA commission. A gym doesn't do any of that. And a league? A league is made up of tons of individual clubs that handle their own business, so the math still doesn't add up. If you try to compare the UFC to boxing, you run into the same wall. There, promoters just promote fights—they don't distribute belts and there isn't this level of self-regulation. I read somewhere that the biggest boxing promotions—excluding Showtime, since they're part of a massive organization which makes things blurry—run their whole operation with just a handful of people. We're talking two offices and maybe ten employees being the entire promotion.
Honestly, no matter how you slice it, you're comparing apples to oranges. Even if a massive outfit like Matchroom has 40 or 50 people, they're still ten times smaller than the UFC, so you can't accurately compare what percentage of revenue goes to the fighters. And even with those high percentages, the boxers on the prelims get paid peanuts. I highly doubt those promoters have taken on the responsibility of guaranteeing three fights a year for every fighter under contract. If you try to drag the NBA into this, it gets even messier. In the NBA, the teams pay the players, and the prestige comes from playing in the best league in the world, not from being part of a specific franchise. To what someone said earlier: fighters grind to get into the UFC because that's where the prestige lives, not because they want to be members of a certain gym like AT&T. Gyms are a bit like clubs, but they're a totally different beast. Plus, the UFC signs fighters, not gyms. You'll see fighters from all sorts of different promotions training at the same gym. Fighters can switch gyms while staying with the same promotion, or vice versa.
Bottom line, I don't think the payout percentage is the most important factor here, and I'm totally with danini on that. The UFC builds these fighters from scratch and handles everything. Then, once they become stars, they start screaming, "Where's my money?" Instead of focusing on revenue splits, I think fighters should focus on things like health insurance and stopping those shady, mafia-style threats that Fran and Stipa used to deal with. Contractual stuff like automatic extensions if you turn down a fight is also super problematic. There's definitely room for improvement there. But trying to turn the UFC's business model (or Bellator's, which is smaller but runs on a similar blueprint) into a boxing-style model would absolutely destroy the sport, just like it ruined boxing. Since I expect regulators will eventually step in sooner or later, we might as well enjoy it while it lasts. We'll probably be telling our grandkids stories about the days when there was one organization providing killer fights every single weekend, or at least every other.