CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Miscellaneous › Feedback & Suggestions › Is it allowed for moderators to insult users?

Is it allowed for moderators to insult users?

Started by Peter Stewart6 · · 👁 9 views · 73 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Peter Stewart6Nicholas KingAlex Barnes8Chris Peterson53hiddenmoose20rowdyhawk10Brian Edwards6mistyseal11swiftorca57
rowdyhawk10 rowdyhawk10 Active Member
123 messages
joined Oct 2009
#41 ·
Brian Edwards6 said:
Susan Brooks83 said:Not even close, 😳 I suppose I’ll just add to your supposed "commitment" here, given your passion for God's Truth. 🥳
Maybe you have a "colleague" out there who could advocate for you as much as you seem to be advocating for her here. It's almost as if you're both complementing one another in this advocacy.

A true Catholic woman...👍
It might be best to remove the Good Pope from your signature. It doesn't quite align with the sentiment expressed above it.🤷

Well, she isn't exactly true, though perhaps she's close. 😉

GA, as I mentioned, please try to ensure things don't get any heavier than three pounds; anything more than that is hard to bear. 😍
Brian Edwards6 Brian Edwards6 Active Member
112 messages
joined Nov 2015
#42 ·
Susan Brooks83 said:Well, I suppose this is just who I am—far from perfect. 😁 The main issue is your attempt to categorize Catholics,
into "right" and "wrong" believers. 🙄 👍
First, you offer unsolicited advice about changing my signature, and then you seem unsure whether it even
fits the tone of the text. 😬 You haven't exactly convinced me that you have a firm grasp on what works and what doesn't. 🙂

Why is there always such a defensive posture here?🤷
I consider myself a Catholic as well, even if I’m not exactly a practicing believer. Personally, I hold my faith, and that suffices for me, while remaining respectful of others' beliefs. The difference is that I possess enough self-assurance to engage in conversation with those who don't share my views without feeling like I’m automatically destined for hell. Plus, I can generally resist the urge to immediately toss my interlocutor onto a bonfire for being a heretic.😉
Regarding the Good Pope, that was intended more as an observation than actual advice (it’s a bit late for me to edit the text now; perhaps a moderator could assist🙂).
And, as far as I am aware—though I could be mistaken—he championed dialogue and coexistence, so...🤷
In any case, we all have to start with ourselves, don't we?👍
Peter Stewart6 Peter Stewart6 MemberOP
18 messages
joined May 2010
#43 ·
Brian Edwards6 said:Why is it always so defensive?🤷

If you had actually spent some time looking through that Religion PDF, then maybe you’d finally get why things are the way they are. Just saying.
I can't explain it anymore. Just come down here and see for yourself. Once you write it all out, after a little while, you'll finally get it.
I can't help but wonder how anyone could call being in this environment "beautiful." It’s just so "beautiful" that we ended up here.
A few people over at the Vatican are acting all defensive. 😁

I’m Catholic, too—even if I’m not exactly a practicing believer.Personally, I believe what I believe, and that’s enough for me. I have no problem respecting someone else's views. The difference is just that I actually have enough self-confidence to talk to people who don't see eye to eye with me without feeling like I'm automatically destined for hell. Plus, I can manage to resist the urge to immediately throw them onto a bonfire as some kind of heretic.😉

What’s written in bold says enough for the rest of your text. Do you really think I don't have respect?
Is it about someone else's beliefs, or is it just one of us here complaining? It feels like a lack of respect and...
That’s just a really ugly way to talk about the saints, especially toward those of us who actually believe and try our best to live by those values.
Practical believers... you know, Catholics. I honestly envy anyone who can carry that much self-confidence.
Honestly, I’ve reached a point where I trust God more than I trust myself. It's the only way. With Him, I feel like I can handle anything.
And that’s exactly where you see the gap between just being a believer and actually being a practicing believer.

Anyway, you've got three different examples right here that back this up, found in the other users' PDF regarding Religion in the Vatican.
As for all that talk about burning heretics at the stake—honestly, I’ll pass. It seems like you don't quite grasp what this is actually about. Or maybe you do.
It’s funny how people in these discussions always jump at the chance to hunt down heretics and start a holy war. LOL

Regarding what I said about the Good Pope, that was more of a personal opinion than actual advice. It’s too late for me to edit the post now—maybe some moderator can help me out?🙂).
(And as far as I know—though I could be wrong,) He really pushed for dialogue and coexistence, so......🤷
Basically, we all have to start with ourselves, don't we?👍

Yeah, thanks for sharing your take. Of course, Holy Father John Paul II was a huge advocate for this.
For the sake of coexistence, maybe it would be better if you stuck to the Religion threads.
Maybe then they'd finally get why I've always stood up for what I believe in—as someone who actually tries to live out my faith in a practical way.
And it's not just my own smallness. 😁 And how exactly were we blessed, spat upon, and accused?
Say, like from a moderator who claims to be all about "tolerance." Someone I was actually defending just because...
So, you talk about "dialogue and coexistence" (or whatever it is you claim to be explaining to me). But when it actually comes down to "dialogue and coexistence" in practice? It’s nothing more than getting slapped around and being called out.
Labeling me with "hate speech, religious intolerance, and fanaticism," among other "epithets." Such great "love."
Because, listen, Brian Edwards6, words have the power to kill a person's spirit. But, I forgive—just like the Good Pope did when he
walked into the cell of the man who tried to assassinate him right after the attack, practicing the forgiveness of Jesus:
"Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do." So, my heart remains free from whatever labels people try to stick on me.
Just like the signature of the Good Pope, there was an attempt to extinguish the spirit of Jesus in him. Because that signature represents
science divine love. I haven't "graduated" yet, but I am trying to learn, following the example of Jesus through the Good Pope (who is called
John XXIII, by the way). And it certainly applies to John Paul II as well.
Similarly, being good also means having the strength to say NO; that’s a sentiment expressed by Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI.
So, I am saying NO to the hate speech and religious intolerance being "served" to Catholics and everyone else
practicing their faith.

The moderator in question is trying to kill the spirit Christian on this forum through these posts, simply because he doesn't know what he's doing. And he isn't the only one.
If he knew better, he wouldn't be doing it.

And because of this kind of "tolerance," there are so many threads on the Vatican forum, not just now.
This "tolerance" has been going on for far too long. ;raspa:

Maybe he could start with himself, right? 😉 Because I did that a long time ago, and I still do.
I didn't start with you, unlike how I see you constantly coming at me. 🤣
It seems to me that until now, you weren't interested in my posts, but suddenly—interest, hehe.
Well, maybe this is just your path toward becoming a practical believer. 🙂
Brian Edwards6 Brian Edwards6 Active Member
112 messages
joined Nov 2015
#44 ·
Susan Brooks83 said:If you had actually spent a little time digging through that PDF on Religion, you might have finally grasped why things are the way they are. But hey, I guess that's just how it goes.
I simply can't explain it anymore...

Susan Brooks83 said:... after some time, you'll find that you...
I can't help but wonder how anyone could find this environment so "pleasant." It’s just so incredibly "lovely" that we all ended up here.
A few people over at the Vatican seem to be digging in their heels, acting like they're under siege...

Susan Brooks83 said:It really comes down to a fundamental lack of respect, and...
That is an incredibly distasteful way to speak about the holy figures we believe in and strive to emulate.
Practical believers, they call us. Catholics, supposedly...

I find myself lurking in the religion threads, though I rarely actually participate. It’s because I realized quite some time ago that no matter how you frame it, these debates inevitably veer off course. It happens on both sides of the aisle, every single time. But look, if you’re walking around knowing you’re in the minority, you really ought to be prepared for the inevitable onslaught of attacks and condescension. That’s just how it works. After all, what doesn't kill you makes you stronger, right? Or are you planning to call upon a higher power to handle that one, too?🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:I honestly envy you. I wish I had that much confidence.
To be honest, I’ve reached a point where I rely on God far more than I ever rely on myself. It’s only through Him that I feel capable of handling anything life throws my way.
And that right there is the fundamental distinction between simply being a believer and being a practical believer.

Let’s be clear: there is a massive distinction between genuine faith and mere addiction. Similarly, there is a world of difference between true belief and pure fanaticism. In my view, a Christian fanatic is just as problematic as a Muslim or Jewish fanatic—and honestly, you could even make the case that an atheist fanatic is just as bad.👎
Whatever happened to the concept of turning the other cheek? Isn't that just as vital as all those other things you seem so fond of bringing up?🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:... So, I am saying I do NOT support hate speech or religious intolerance being "served" to Catholics and everyone else
who actually practices their faith...

No, you aren't saying NO to others because of their faith or convictions. Of course, that applies to most people when discussing religion. Everyone loves to invoke science and whatnot, but only when they’re talking about other faiths. As soon as their own doctrines are brought up, they start foaming at the mouth. If someone holds a different opinion, fine. But if they spit, insult, or disparage, it doesn't really matter anyway. Everything is recorded, and everyone will eventually answer for their actions, won't they? Or are we all just going to lump them together and let Him sort us out?
🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:... Because, my dear Brian Edwards6, even words can kill the spirit of a man...

So, is that why you write with such extreme caution?
👎

Susan Brooks83 said:... The moderator in question is attempting to kill the spirit Christian on this forum through his posts because he simply doesn't know what he's doing. And it's not just him.
If he did know, he wouldn't be doing it...

First, you claim he knows exactly what he's doing and is doing it intentionally, and now you're saying he has no idea.
My take is that he probably does know. And you know it, I know it, and I'm sure the rest of us do too.
Or perhaps we're all collectively clueless—honestly, I don't even know anymore.
🤔

Susan Brooks83 said:... As for burning at the stake and heretics, I'll pass, since it clearly isn't clicking for you what this is actually about. Or maybe it is.
It's interesting how many people in these debates constantly latch onto talk of burning stakes and heretics. LOL...

Susan Brooks83 said:... I didn't start this by picking on you—not that I have much choice, given how often I read your posts starting from my own perspective...
It seems you haven't had much interest in my posts until now, but suddenly, there's all this interest, haha.
Then again, perhaps this is simply your path toward becoming a more practical believer...

Isn't that a bit condescending? A little patronizing? The moment I disagree with you, you immediately assume I'm part of some conspiracy against you or against Christians at large? That I'm out here spreading my convictions with fire and sword?🤷
I like to remind those who take themselves far too seriously that this isn't real life. It applies to every sub-forum. This is just an online forum. Discussion is implied. I’ve clashed with plenty of users and mods for that very reason. It’s nothing new. Now, you're just next in line. And this has nothing to do with your faith or your character, other than your sheer fanaticism.
Besides, I'm feeling particularly sensitive right now. It's that Christmas mood. Since I was working the night shift on Christmas, that "mood" carries a certain weight for me and leaves me with very little patience for fanaticism.
But, it doesn't matter. I know I won't get anywhere here, so I'll head out. I don't want to cause too much of a stir.😉
In the end, everything settles as it should.
Regards.👋
rowdyhawk10 rowdyhawk10 Active Member
123 messages
joined Oct 2009
#45 ·
Brian Edwards6 said:
Susan Brooks83 said:Listen, Brian Edwards6, even words have the power to kill a person's spirit.

Why is your tone so incredibly polite?👎

The spirit is a matter of less is more... But she claims I'll be beaten with an iron Crucifix of Jesus that's measured in... By the kilogram. 😢 And I will. To forget. Oh boy, oh boy... I am just not feeling this at all. Oof. I suppose I'll just sit here and wait for Jesus Christ—who is, after all, God and overflowing with grace—to come along and bash my head in with that heavy iron Crucifix of Jesus. 🙄

Good morning, Peter Stewart6.
If it were possible, I suppose I would prefer that punishment to be spiritual rather than physical. 🙂

Susan Brooks83 said:No, I forgive. I’ll do it just like the Good Pope did—by visiting the cell of the man who tried to kill him right after the assassination attempt.

Your forgiveness is somewhat extreme, I suppose. 😁 It isn't exactly in the spirit of making wishes when I feel like a three-pound iron crucifix being driven straight into my skull; honestly, my head would probably struggle to handle that kind of weight. 😍 If you could, please implore for me—if only in the name of the old days—some kind of lighter sentence, maybe something like 1,000 Hail Marys (I happen to know that number by heart). 🙂
mistyseal11 mistyseal11 Regular
250 messages
joined Aug 2007
#46 ·
this is just absolutely mind-blowing.

seriously though, why are you guys so obsessed with making sure everyone hears your opinion online?
do you really not have any actual people in your real lives you can sit down and talk to?

plus, let’s be real—if this site actually followed every single law in the USA, half of you would be sitting behind bars right now.

it feels like the mods are just trying to dodge any potential headaches by protecting you from yourselves...
Alex Barnes8 Alex Barnes8 Active Member
131 messages
joined Nov 2010
#47 ·
rowdyhawk10 said:I guess it isn't exactly accurate, but it’s close enough. 😉

Anyway, like I said, just try to make sure it doesn't get three pounds heavier; one can endure things being slightly below that. 😍

Yeah, you're hilarious, haha. 🙄
That's why in your religion there aren't any punishments or threats, neither before nor after death. 🤣😂🙏 Right, because that's only found in Roman Catholicism, obviously. 🤣
Islam is generally known as a religion defined by tolerance, gentleness, and acceptance. 😂
Alex Barnes8 Alex Barnes8 Active Member
131 messages
joined Nov 2010
#48 ·
Brian Edwards6 said:I read the discussions on Religion in the Vatican, but I don't participate. I realized long ago that no debate ever goes anywhere but sideways. That goes for both sides, I guess. But if you know you're in the minority, you probably should expect the attacks and the condescension. What doesn't kill you makes you stronger, right? Or maybe you're calling on a higher power for that too?🤷

It’s really just the difference between faith and addiction. Or maybe between faith and fanaticism. I guess a Christian fanatic is just as bad as any Muslim, Jewish, or even atheist fanatic.👎
Whatever happened to turning the other cheek? I guess that’s just as important as everything else you seem to love bringing up.🤷

No, you're the one telling others "no" because of their faith or beliefs. I guess that goes for most people when they talk about religion, too. They always hide behind science and all that, but only until the conversation shifts toward other faiths. Then, suddenly, they're foaming at the mouth. If someone holds a different view, let them. Spitting, insulting, or belittling others... it doesn't really matter anyway. Everything is recorded, and everyone eventually pays for what they've done, right? Or are we just going to lump us all together and let Him sort it out?🤷

I guess that's just how I write. Maybe I'm being too polite.👎

First you claim they know exactly what they're doing and that it's intentional, but now suddenly they don't know what they're doing at all. I guess.
I guess he probably knows. And you know it too—honestly, I think we all do.
Either we all just don't know, or I don't even know anymore. I guess.🤔

Isn't this a bit condescending? A little patronizing, maybe? Just because I don't agree with you, you immediately assume I'm part of some conspiracy against you or against Christians. It's like you think I'm spreading my beliefs with fire and sword. I guess not.🤷
I like to remind those who take themselves far too seriously that this isn't real life. Across all the subforums, it’s just a forum. It's meant for discussion. I've clashed with plenty of users and mods because of that. Nothing surprising there. Now you're next. And honestly, it has nothing to do with your faith or anything else about you, other than perhaps a bit of fanaticism.
I’m feeling especially sensitive right now. It’s that Christmas mood. Since I spent Christmas working the night shift, this whole "mood" hits differently—it just makes me even less tolerant of fanaticism, I guess.
Whatever. I know I won't get anywhere here, so I'll just head out. I don't really want to cause a scene.😉
In the end, I guess everything just settles where it's supposed to.
Hey there.👋

Why would she, being a Catholic, post that on Reddit? I guess.HR She probably should have been. I guess she realizes it's happening. Maybe. I guess it’s just smaller. Maybe.Does that sentence of yours still not sound stupid to you?
And this part about having to be ready for slander and attacks... I guess. Maybe.😲First off, there’s a minority group here in America that isn't just "Catholic Americans." I mean, how would it sound if you gave that same advice to, say, a Muslim? How would it feel to tell a Muslim, "Just realize you're in the minority, so be ready for attacks and insults from Catholics"? And then, when they actually complain about being treated that way, you just side with the majority attacking them and start laughing or making jokes at their expense? I guess it's just how things work.
So, you see how it looks now?
What, if a Muslim goes through this, it’s a tragedy and a crime, but when a Catholic deals with the same thing, it’s just business as usual?
Alex Barnes8 Alex Barnes8 Active Member
131 messages
joined Nov 2010
#49 ·
rowdyhawk10 said:The spirit is less is more, I suppose... But she claims I'm going to be beaten with a heavy iron Crucifix of Jesus. Maybe just by the pound. I guess. 😢 I suppose I will. To forget, I suppose. Maybe. Man, oh man... I just can't. I guess I'll just be getting beaten over the head by Jesus Christ—who is God and full of grace, anyway—with that heavy iron Crucifix of Jesus. 🙄

Hey, Peter Stewart6.
If it’s even possible, I guess I'd prefer the punishment to be spiritual rather than physical. 🙂

That kind of forgiveness... it feels a bit extreme, I guess. Maybe just a little too much. 😁 It’s not exactly in the spirit of granting wishes. I guess if I get my way, an iron Crucifix of Jesus might just be driven straight through my skull; a three-pound weight that my poor head probably couldn't handle. 😍 If you could, maybe pray for me—just to honor the old ways—that I might receive some lighter penance. Something like 1,000 Hail Marys, I guess. I know them by heart. 🙂

Maybe it’s time to stop mocking Catholics and their faith.🙂
So why do you go out of your way to tear down the ones who actually support yours? Or I guess it’s just that we Catholics are expected to walk on eggshells around your sensitive feelings, while you don't feel the need to show us any of the same courtesy? 😉
Alex Barnes8 Alex Barnes8 Active Member
131 messages
joined Nov 2010
#50 ·
Brian Edwards6 said:A true Catholic...👍
Maybe you should take the Good Pope out of your signature. It doesn't really fit what you wrote above it.🤷

Yeah, right... That’s just how Catholics see things, I guess. As if other religions are infinitely tolerant and have never dealt with punishment. 🙄 Maybe try learning a bit about other faiths before claiming punishments are just some Catholic invention. 🙄
🙂
Peter Stewart6 Peter Stewart6 MemberOP
18 messages
joined May 2010
#51 ·
Brian Edwards6 said:I lurk on the religion subreddits, but I don't really jump in. I realized a long time ago that no matter what you say, the conversation always ends up veering off track. It happens on both sides, honestly. But if you know you're in the minority, you have to be ready for people to come at you and try to discredit you. What doesn't kill you makes you stronger, right? Or are you calling on a higher power for that one, too?

Well, you certainly went on a bit there, haha.
A believer who truly lives out their faith is always searching for God's proximity. The word "invocation" is...
That’s just not how we practice within Roman Catholicism. That kind of thing belongs more in those alternative circles. lol

No, that’s exactly where you draw the line between faith and addiction. Or between true belief and fanaticism. At the end of the day, a Christian fanatic is just as bad as a Muslim one, a Jewish one, or honestly, you could even say an atheist fanatic.
What happened to the whole "turning the other cheek" thing? Isn't that just as important as all the other stuff you're always bringing up?

Based on your theory, you're saying we should lean on God's strength rather than just our own fanaticism.
Since you're quoting my post and talking about Roman Catholicism, I guess that's just how you see it.
It's not just about "theory" for me—it's how I live it. I’m a fanatic believer, through and through. Everything is just more beautiful than the last, haha.
Who's stopping you from turning the other cheek, Brian Edwards6? You're a believer too, aren't you? ;not sure:

No, you’re actually saying NO to others because of their faith or what they believe in. Honestly, that goes for most people when it comes to religion. Everyone loves to hide behind "science" and all that, but only when they're talking about other religions. As soon as someone brings up their own beliefs, they start foaming at the mouth. If someone holds a different opinion, let them. If they spit, insult, or belittle others, it doesn't really matter anyway. Everything is recorded, and everyone will eventually answer for their actions, right? Or are we just going to throw everyone into the same bucket and let God sort us out?

You again. you know What I’m saying and why I'm saying it. Great.
What's actually the point of your post? I honestly don't get it. Are you just talking nonsense at this point? rowdyhawk10:

Why are you being so polite?👎

Maybe if they just scattered some mimosa and cotton around, walking wouldn't be such a struggle, right? 😂

First you say they know exactly what they’re doing and that it's intentional, but now you're claiming they have no idea what they're doing.
I honestly think he probably knows. And you know, I know, and we all know it too.
Either we’re all just clueless together, or I honestly don't even know anymore.

Hey Brian Edwards6, Jesus said, "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do." You can actually do that.
You can only truly understand through the Holy Spirit. Trying to force it by overthinking and straining your brain just hurts. It’s exhausting.
headache. ;teeth:

Isn't this just being condescending and looking down on people? Just because I don't agree with you, you immediately assume I'm part of some conspiracy against you or against Christians? Am I spreading my beliefs with fire and sword?

And what exactly counts as being condescending or patronizing? ;roll-eyes: You wrote yourself that
you aren't a practical believer, so why feel looked down upon? If that's how you feel,
then you're doing it to yourself, because that wasn't my intention.
It points to something else—something you're sweetly projecting onto me, something you mentioned earlier
about having huge self-confidence ;smile:

How could you possibly know what I'm thinking? ;clueless: Those are your own thoughts and insinuations that you
are trying to pass off as mine. No thanks, I won't be consuming that. ;D
Fire and sword? 🤣 Like I said before, you need the Holy Spirit to
understand the true meaning of those words, rather than taking them literally.

I like to remind those who take themselves too seriously that this isn't real life. Across all the sub-forums. This is just a forum. It implies discussion. I've clashed with plenty of users and mods for that very reason. Nothing unusual. Now you're next.

The bolded part refers to you. 😂
Because that's how you debate: "reminding people," "attempts at psychoanalysis and what everyone
thinks," insinuations about conspiracies, accusations of Catholic fanaticism, and other little
"details." ;roll-eyes:
How do you know how everyone perceives the forum? Maybe you clash with people
because you try to analyze how other users interpret things? And that's
not allowed, Brian Edwards6, according to the forum rules. That's probably why you've had issues with the mods. Because
users reported you via the red flag button, haha.

And that has nothing to do with your faith or any personal trait, except for fanaticism.
And now I'm feeling especially sensitive. Christmas mood. Since I worked the night shift on Christmas, that "mood" feels different to me and lowers my tolerance for fanaticism.

Not at all. 🤣 Fanaticism, and it has nothing to do with my faith? ;eek: And you think
you know my personality when you don't even know me? Are you supposed to be some psychic? 🤣
kae, you worked the night shift on Christmas? Well, someone has to do it; you're not alone. 😉 I'm sure you'll
get paid a bit extra for holiday work. ;lol:
Maybe have some mild tea, something relaxing, get some sleep, get some rest. ;teeth: That'll kick in during
the holidays for some people; in medicine, that sensitivity is called holiday depression.
That same "mood" lowers tolerance for all sorts of things, not just
"fanaticism." ;quirky: There are all kinds of fanatics out there today. 😁

But whatever. I know I won't get anywhere, so I just head out early. I don't want to be a bother too much.
In the end, everything works out how it's supposed to.👋 Best,

Oh, of course it doesn't matter. You've already judged yourself as incapable of succeeding,
which isn't right. Still, it's good that you leave quickly, so you don't get too worked up. ;mig:
Yeah, in the end, everything falls under God's control.
And greetings to you too; we had quite the fanatic little chat, Brian Edwards6. 🤣

Happy New Year. 👋
Peter Stewart6 Peter Stewart6 MemberOP
18 messages
joined May 2010
#52 ·
rowdyhawk10 said:Less spirit, more... well, whatever. But she actually said I’m going to be beaten with an iron Crucifix of Jesus that's measured in... kilograms 😢 And I will. forgetting Oh man, oh man, oh man... I just can't. Ouch. While Jesus Christ—who is, let’s be honest, God Himself and just overflowing with grace—is... He’ll probably end up getting beaten over the head with that heavy iron Crucifix of Jesus.

I wrote this part in bold. Where? Where did I ever say we were measuring in kilograms? And where was I...
So you're saying you'll "get your revenge"? Don't start making things up, rowdyhawk10. That's just what kids do when they're spinning fairy tales about some big bad villain.
Witches, right?
Still such a big kid, aren't you? 😂 So, one of your colleagues wrote that the other day, assuming you can actually read. Take another look at it.
That’s my post. You put the links in the quote block. Honestly, you need to slow down when reading so you don't skip over any letters.
Trying to wrap my head around what the writer was actually getting at here... hehe.

Hey there, Peter Stewart6.
If there’s any way to do it, I’d really prefer it if the punishment were spiritual rather than physical. 🙂

I’m neither good nor exactly an angel. My username actually means something else entirely.
Why are you asking me if I'm going to get penalized or not? That’s really not my lane. 😁
Anyway, the soul leaves the body when it returns to the Creator—you probably already know that. So, everything should go exactly the way you wanted.
It all depends on the spirit within a soul at the exact moment they leave their body.

That kind of forgiveness... it's heavy. It’s a lot to take in. 😁 It’s not exactly in the spirit of making wishes when I feel like a three-pound iron Crucifix of Jesus is being driven straight into my skull; honestly, my head is too soft to handle that kind of weight. 😍 If you could, please implore for me—maybe just in the name of the old days—a lighter sentence. Something like 1,000 Hail Marys. I know that number by heart.

Everything I write seems to rub you the wrong way, but honestly? You’re the one painting those dark pictures in your own head.
I chose them, in these texts.
And they have nothing to do with spirituality. The Crucifix of Jesus, being driven from above, iron nails piercing the skull? 😲
So, what are you even telling me? 😂
I've done enough praying for you, so you probably don't even need to recite the Our Father from memory.
Don't let yourself get worn out from praying too much. 🤣
All you can really do is try to understand that He is our Father. And because of that, you have to act accordingly.
moving toward His children.

P.S. 1.1. is the Feast of the Blessed Virgin Mary, which is also recognized by Roman Catholicism as the International Day of Peace.
So, I wish you Jesus's peace through the intercession of His Mother in this New Year, 2010. May it be a good one for you. 🙂
Regardless of what you write about my clumsy forgiveness or what you think of my smallness... well, you know.
Brian Edwards6 Brian Edwards6 Active Member
112 messages
joined Nov 2015
#53 ·
Alex Barnes8 said:Why would she, being a Catholic, even bother posting on Reddit?HR It should have been. I am fully aware that... manjiniDoes that sentence of yours still not sound ridiculous to you?

If half the comments here boil down to people claiming this is an atheist forum, then I suppose that just means we Catholics are in the minority, doesn't it? And honestly, what's so foolish about that?🤷

Alex Barnes8 said:First off, let's get one thing straight: in America, those who don't follow our traditions aren't some separate group—they are simply the minority within our broader identity as American Catholics.

In America, the real ones are always in the minority. You see people claiming they’re devout Catholics? Look, I work in law enforcement, and believe me, being an American Catholic doesn't automatically make someone a decent human being. Of course, since we happen to be the majority here, most of the idiots end up coming from our own ranks.👍

Alex Barnes8 said:Just imagine if you gave that same advice to someone else—say, a Muslim in this country. How would that even land? Imagine walking up to them and saying, "Look, just be aware that you’re a minority here, so you should probably brace yourself for attacks and insults from Catholics." It sounds absurd, doesn't it? When a Muslim deals with that kind of treatment, people cry foul and call it outrageous and punishable. But somehow, when a Catholic endures the exact same thing, we’re expected to act like it's perfectly normal. It's a massive double standard.

Let me be clear: I am a Catholic, so when it comes to our faith, I’m speaking from firsthand experience. Islam is foreign to me, and whatever little I might know about it is second-hand at best. So, logically speaking, it only makes sense that I stick to discussing what I actually understand, doesn't it?🤷

Alex Barnes8 said:And then, when you actually dare to push back and answer him that way, suddenly you’re the one being blamed? Apparently, by responding, I’ve somehow sided with the majority that was tearing him apart, and now I'm expected to join in on the jokes and laugh at him too. How convenient.

Are you seriously suggesting that I’m siding with the majority to attack an angel? You literally just wrote a moment ago that we Americans are mostly Catholic. So, if she’s also an American Catholic—which, again, constitutes the majority—how on earth am I "siding with the majority"? Am I supposed to be representing some sort of minority group here?🤔

Alex Barnes8 said:Oh, sure... That's exactly how Catholics think. Other religions are just infinitely tolerant and have absolutely never heard of the concept of punishment...
Come on, maybe try actually learning a thing or two about other faiths before you go around claiming that punishments are some Catholic invention...

Where exactly did I say that punishments were a Catholic invention? It’s perfectly normal for any organized religion to develop methods of harsh punishment at some point in its history, especially when clashing with another organized faith. And as I’ve already noted, Roman Catholicism is close to my heart, which makes it much easier for me to speak on our own affairs. I’m not out here fighting some holy war; we're just an obstacle to the blindness of one side. Whether they're the majority right now or a minority—honestly, I haven't quite figured that part out yet.🤷
Brian Edwards6 Brian Edwards6 Active Member
112 messages
joined Nov 2015
#54 ·
Susan Brooks83 said:... A believer practicing their faith is always seeking God's proximity. The term "invocation" isn't really
used within the Catholic faith. That’s more of a thing in those alternative circles...

Honestly, I have much more fun in those alternative circles.👍

Susan Brooks83 said:... According to your theory, relying on God's strength more than your own is just fanaticism...

I think we misunderstood one another. My theory is that God will grant you enough self-confidence to achieve your goals on your own if you truly believe in Him. I am emphasizing belief in Him, not in the Mother Church. Fanaticism is that constant habit of invoking His name and beating your chest because you're a believer, convinced you're absolutely right and playing the martyr that nobody else understands.👎

Susan Brooks83 said:... Who's stopping you from turning the other cheek, Brian Edwards6? You're a believer too, aren't you?..

If we both turn the other cheek, then the gesture becomes entirely pointless. We can't both be humble. 🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:... Maybe if they spilled mimosa and cotton wool everywhere, it would be easier to walk, wouldn't it?...

As I said, we'll all end up exactly where we belong eventually. And as the old saying goes: "Heaven is lovely, but Hell is where the party's at!"👍

Susan Brooks83 said:... How on earth would you know how everyone else perceives this forum? Maybe that’s why you kept picking fights,
perhaps because you were too busy psychoanalyzing other users and their understanding of the site? And that's
strictly against the forum rules, Brian Edwards6. That's likely why you ended up clashing with the mods. After all,
other users reported you via the red flag icon...

The only thing we actually do in threads like this is analyze one another. Or is there some grander purpose I'm missing? I've had direct run-ins with the moderators, just like I'm having with you right now. In those instances, I was in the minority. Or perhaps the majority—honestly, I can't quite tell myself.🤔

Susan Brooks83 said:... Don't be ridiculous... You're calling it fanaticism, but what does that have to do with my faith?...

I clearly wasn't articulate enough. It's not as if a higher power is speaking through me. If you were Muslim, an atheist (or whatever), it wouldn't make a difference. A fanatic is a fanatic. It truly has nothing to do with any specific faith. Besides, every religion claims its own Truth over everyone else's, but when you strip them down to the bone, they are incredibly similar. It's laughable. And rather pathetic.👎

Susan Brooks83 said:... And what exactly do you mean by being condescending and looking down on people?... You said yourself that
you aren't a practical believer, so why do you feel looked down upon? If you're feeling that way,
then you're essentially undermining yourself, because that certainly wasn't my intention.
It suggests something else entirely—something you were so sweetly accusing me of earlier, back when you were writing
about having massive self-confidence...

I didn't say I felt condescended to; I said that *you* are condescending toward others. There is a significant distinction there. Also, didn't you claim that analyzing fellow participants was forbidden? Or have you simply lost the nerve to stand by your word?🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:... kae, did you work the night shift on Christmas? Well, someone has to, you can't do everything yourself... I suppose
you'll get a little extra holiday pay for working through the festivities...
Have some mild tea, relax, get some sleep, catch up on rest... It might help you stay centered during the
holidays; in medicine, that kind of sensitivity is called holiday depression.
That sort of "mood" also lowers one's tolerance for many things, not just
"fanaticism"... Because there are plenty of different kinds of fanatics out there these days...

We clearly haven't understood one another. I’ve been doing this job for quite a few years now, so it isn't some matter of stamina. And let's be clear, it isn't a case of "holiday blues"—though it is somewhat amusing how every single state of mind nowadays requires its own specific label and a corresponding prescription. Whether you call it medical, religious, or alternative, it's all the same. My issue is simply that for a religious holiday, I have to spend the entire night patrolling the areas where American Catholics practice their faith. Between the blood and the vomit (not mine, thankfully), I had to change into a fresh uniform the following day. Honestly, I didn't even have the nerve to turn back.👎

Susan Brooks83 said:... Yes, in the end, everything falls under God's providence...

That is precisely the point. Everything else is just noise.

Susan Brooks83 said:... And greetings to you too; we had a lovely, fanatic little chat, Brian Edwards6.

The honor is mine.
🙏
Regards.
👋
Alex Barnes8 Alex Barnes8 Active Member
131 messages
joined Nov 2010
#55 ·
Brian Edwards6;24308134 said:If half the comments basically boil down to this being an atheist forum, then it means we Catholics are in the minority, right? Nothing stupid about that.🤷

If Catholics are the minority on Reddit, then something is clearly broken with this site. In the US, Catholics are the majority. So there isn't really this whole "being aware we're the minority" thing to accept as normal. I guess the moderators and admins should explain how it even happened—how Catholics ended up as the minority on Reddit.😉

In America, real people are actually the minority. Catholic Americans? I work in law enforcement and, trust me, being a Catholic American doesn't automatically make someone good. Of course, since we're the majority here, most of the idiots come from our own ranks.👍

Obviously, not all Catholic Americans are great people. There are good and bad everywhere. I don't have anything against people of other faiths or nationalities, but I do have an issue with injustice and privilege, regardless of what faith or nationality anyone claims.

Again, I am Catholic, so I can speak from experience regarding our faith. Islam is foreign to me, and whatever I do know about it isn't firsthand. So, I suppose it makes sense that I’m just rambling about something I actually understand, doesn't it?🤷

Your response doesn't really have anything to do with what I said.

Are you trying to say I'm attacking an angel because I'm on the side of the majority? Didn't you just say we American Catholics are the majority? If she's also an American Catholic (who are the majority), how am I on the side of the majority? I guess I must be part of the minority.🤔

Catholics are, for some reason, a forum minority. And atheists are the forum majority. You took the side of that majority. And joined in on the attacks.

Where did I say punishments were a Catholic invention? It’s pretty standard for any organized religion to have methods of harsh punishment at some point, especially when clashing with another organized religion. And like I said, Roman Catholicism is close to me, so it's easiest for me to talk about us. I'm not out here fighting some holy war; maybe we're just witnessing the blindness of one side. Either the majority side. Or the minority side, I don't know.🤷

You said: "a true Catholic woman."🙄
There is some "blindness" happening here, but maybe not the kind you're talking about.
Peter Stewart6 Peter Stewart6 MemberOP
18 messages
joined May 2010
#56 ·
Brian Edwards6 said:I have a much better time hanging out on alternative sites.👍

Yeah, just keep right on entertaining us.

I think we had a misunderstanding. My theory is that if you truly believe in Him, God will give you enough self-confidence to actually achieve whatever it is you're striving for. I should clarify—I mean believing in Him, not necessarily in the Mother Church. To me, fanaticism is just constantly invoking His name and pounding your chest, claiming you're right simply because you're a believer, acting like some martyr that nobody else can understand.

You aren't being clear.
In Roman Catholicism, just like in the Orthodox Mother Church, the Mother Church is essentially a family of believers.
Believers come to celebrate Holy Mass on Sundays, and also on other days during the week.
For those who are able, if they truly desire to be in God's proximity. To be nourished by the Body of Christ.
To live.
And all those theories you have about fanaticism, chest-thumping, and talking about martyrdom... that's just... well.
Let's move this to the miscellaneous section. I feel like you don't really grasp what you're talking about when you mention believing in God versus... well, something else.
Mother Church. What does it even mean to "believe in Him, rather than in the Mother Church"?
It’s not just about believing in God. What matters is actually living in His proximity. Otherwise, what's the point?
People really love to push these theories that someone is just a fanatic, all because they actually choose to follow God's commandments.
There's this tension between the Church, which actually teaches and follows the teachings of Jesus Christ, and then there's everything else.
The believers who act that way.
Look, if you're going to call me some kind of martyr, you've got it wrong. That's just not happening anywhere.
I didn't write that. Besides, dear Brian Edwards6, not many people truly understood Jesus either, so it’s the same story.
A fanatic to some, right? Look, I’m not Jesus, but I am one of His followers. So, yeah...
A student isn't greater than the Teacher.

If we both turn the other cheek, then the whole point of doing it just disappears. You can't both be humble at the same time. 🤷

Why doesn't it make sense? It absolutely does. It’s just that, in this situation, you're asking me to be a little too humble.
And you wouldn't even look at your own, would you? You know, that's just being a little condescending toward others. Because honestly, nowhere else... just nowhere.
I haven't called anyone out for being humble. Not even you. Honestly, if someone acts that way, it says enough about them on its own.
Humility... if we’re actually going to talk about it, it’s really just about being honest with ourselves before God. It's that realization of who I truly am in His eyes.
To truly grasp something like that, you first have to look inward. You need to analyze yourself—really sit down and examine your own actions throughout life—and then move accordingly.
Living in His presence while being present for the people around you... that's the goal. But I've learned that being humble doesn't mean you just let people walk all over you until you're completely exhausted.
That’s just being a sycophant, not actually being humble. All those other "stories" about humility? It's just hypocrisy, plain and simple.

Like I said before, we’re all going to end up exactly where we belong eventually. And you know how that old saying goes: "Paradise might be beautiful, but hell is where the real party's at!"

Life turns out exactly how you choose it. God respects freedom of choice and doesn't withhold it from anyone, so what you ultimately decide... well, that's on you.

All we really do in these threads is analyze one another. Or maybe there’s some deeper purpose to all this? I've gone head-to-head with the mods before, just like I am with you now. Either way, I was in the minority. Or the majority—honestly, I can't tell anymore.

Look, Brian Edwards6, personally, I have no need to analyze you, let alone pick a fight. You were the one who jumped into my posts with all this analysis. Everything else is just me responding to that. And kae, why should I care if you've had clashes with the moderators? I'm not a mod. And I'm in the minority here, right? It's just you and me, 1:1. I could probably hold my own against you in a spiritual
duel, haha, if you actually tried to challenge a believing woman. It's strange how you didn't feel the need to clash with others in the threads where American men, Christian believers, discuss the moderation style of certain mods on
the Religion sub. 😉 Why don't you call them out for fanaticism when we're essentially saying the same thing? They don't understand them either—are they martyrs too, according to your theory? Honestly, Brian Edwards6, it's easier to pick on a woman, isn't it? 😍

I didn't express myself clearly enough. It's probably not a higher power speaking through me. If you were Muslim, an atheist (or whatever), it wouldn't matter. A fanatic is a fanatic. It really has nothing to do with an individual faith. Besides, every religion/faith has its own Truth in opposition to others, but when you strip them down to the bone, they are incredibly similar. It's funny. And sad.

Of course you didn't. What's driving you is obvious from your posts.
The aggression was there right from the start. That's enough for me.

I didn't say I felt condescended to; I said that you condescend to others. There's a big difference. And didn't you say that analyzing a conversation partner was forbidden? Or have you lost your sense of integrity too?

You're being vague again. Go back and read your response in that post one more time.
The analysis is yours; my response is mine.
As for integrity and who has lost what, that's your business, Brian Edwards6, as they might say
down in the Deep South.

We aren't understanding each other at all. I've been working for many years, so that isn't an issue for me. It's not about "holiday depression" (though it's funny how every state of mind has a name and a corresponding pill. Medical, religious, or alternative, it doesn't matter). My issue is having to walk through beer halls all night for a religious holiday where American Catholics practice their faith. Because of blood and vomit (not mine), I had to change clothes the next day. So, I suppose I've lost my sense of integrity too.

Strange. I don't understand you, and Alex Barnes8 doesn't understand you either—so are you not a martyr? 🤣
Holiday depression is medically proven, and therefore medications exist if someone needs them.
It's necessary. I'm talking about mainstream medicine because it matters where you
turn when you need help. The alternatives aren't recognized by official medical institutions, thank
God. 😁 And regarding a spiritual cure, well, Brian Edwards6, every illness starts in the spirit,
which then manifests physically. So, the saying isn't without reason: "A healthy spirit
in a healthy body." You have to be careful about what you do with your spirit and how you "feed" it.
😉
I truly understand that it can't be easy walking through bars and experiencing and surviving
the horrors that happen in certain places. I really do understand, and I am grateful
as a citizen for the sacrifice and courage you put into your job,
which contributes to all of our safety. 🙂 However, it isn't right to say that
"Americans who are Catholic practice their faith" in bars. Because not all Americans "practice
their faith in bars," "don't vomit or spill blood in bars," etc. Every single person
has a conscience, and they live their lives according to that conscience. Now, would someone
who is an active believer—meaning they attend Holy Mass, go to confession regularly,
and nourish themselves with the Body of Christ (not once a year, or once every ten years, or
for long stretches, just passing through church on holidays)—would they come into a bar
after Holy Mass and vomit on a cop or spill blood and call that "practicing faith"? .......
I don't believe that happens, Brian Edwards6.
Why? Because such a person is in
Jesus and with Jesus, already here on Earth; the Holy Spirit dwells within them. People like that
don't do those things. That’s why we need the Mother Church, that’s why we need faith in the teachings of the Church
and the receiving of the sacraments—it's precisely for that, and more. Jesus is peace,
and He gives His peace to those who receive Him with pure hearts (a person's inner self).
And Jesus says: "From an impure heart come out robbery, fighting, slander, shouting, sexual immorality,
divisions, thefts..." The heart (every person's conscience) is cleansed in confession.
That is what practicing faith means. If that isn't happening and people aren't coming to the Mother Church,
but instead they are just beating their chests and screaming whatever they want to scream, then you're just seeing what you experienced during the holidays.
Many people experience similar situations, though they aren't in a workplace like yours,
so maybe you can better understand their helplessness against those "power players." Those people up top, especially when
they start invoking the government. 🙄

Greetings to you too.

👋
Brian Edwards6 Brian Edwards6 Active Member
112 messages
joined Nov 2015
#57 ·
Alex Barnes8 said:If Catholics are supposedly in the minority here on Reddit, then something is seriously off with this platform. In the US, Catholics make up a huge portion of the population. Because of that, there isn't really this idea of needing to "realize we're in the minority" and just accepting it as some sort of normal status quo. I’d much rather have the moderators and administrators explain how we ended up in this unbelievable situation where Catholics are treated like a minority on Reddit...

Why wouldn't it work? Anyone can register. Honestly, if there’s an issue with that, it says more about us than it does about the platform itself. We actually had a thread once where people were openly stating their religious affiliations, and from what I recall, the vast majority identified as Catholic, Christian, or similar. Yet, despite that, most of us don't bother labeling ourselves under the religion section. How is that even possible? It’s likely because we're all just trying to avoid getting on the nerves of the fanatics—regardless of whether they follow a specific faith or none at all.🤷

Alex Barnes8 said:Look, let’s be realistic: not every American who identifies as Catholic is a saint. It’s a universal truth that you’ll find good people and terrible ones in any group, regardless of their background. I personally don't have an issue with people of different faiths or ethnicities, but I absolutely draw the line at injustice and unearned privilege, no matter which religion or nationality is claiming them.

And what about the blatant favoritism shown to the majority faith? I’m talking about things like preferential access to taxpayer funding, the unhindered display of religious symbols in public institutions, or even the practice of dedicating public buildings through religious ceremonies. It raises some serious questions.🤷

Alex Barnes8 said:It seems Catholics have somehow become a tiny minority here on this forum, while atheists make up the overwhelming majority. You’ve clearly decided to align yourself with that majority, joining in on the attacks.

Attacks? Really? Isn't this supposed to be a discussion? Or is the expectation now that we should only stay on topic if we all happen to share the exact same opinion?🤷
It’s one thing to claim you have God on your lips constantly, but if a few lines written by some random stranger on a public forum like Reddit can shake the very foundation of your faith, then you clearly have much deeper issues to work through.👎
Brian Edwards6 Brian Edwards6 Active Member
112 messages
joined Nov 2015
#58 ·
Susan Brooks83 said:What exactly is meant by the phrase "believing in Him rather than in the Mother Church"?
The whole point isn't just about believing in God; it’s about actually dwelling in His proximity. Otherwise, what are we even doing?
It’s truly fascinating how some people jump to conclusions, peddling theories that someone is a fanatic just because they actually bother to respect God's commandments.
There are moments when it feels like we are witnessing a profound disconnect—times when the Church truly embodies the teachings of Jesus Christ, and other times when everything else seems to take precedence.
The believers who go about doing things like that...

So, let me get this straight: if we don't believe in the Church, then we don't believe in God either? I’m struggling to follow that logic. Belief in the Church isn't actually a prerequisite for faith. The Church exists as a tangible, visible entity—complete with all its virtues and, let's be honest, all its flaws. You can observe it, study it, and witness it for what it is without needing to "believe" in it. It's right there in front of us.

Susan Brooks83 said:Life works in a very specific way: you ultimately become the architect of your own fate. God respects our freedom of choice above all else; He doesn't strip it away from anyone or force a hand. At the end of the day, whatever direction you decide to take is entirely on you.

And why, then, are we withholding it from others in the name of God?🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:It’s you versus me, 1:1. I’m telling you, I can hold my own against you when it comes to the spiritual side of things.
Sword fighting? Heh. You’d probably have a much harder time holding your own if you tried picking a fight with a woman of faith. It’s funny how you never seem to find the energy to clash with anyone else on here—you know, the guys posting about the same topics, just regular Christian men discussing the way some of these moderators handle things.
Religion...? How can you avoid calling them out for fanaticism when we’re essentially writing the exact same thing? It's a double standard. If they don't understand it either, does that make them martyrs according to your theory? Honestly, Brian Edwards6, isn't it just easier to go after a woman instead?
It all starts with aggression. For me, that's more than enough...

So, is being a man suddenly the issue here? I thought we had already established that everyone is equal.🤷
Besides, what does gender even have to do with a discussion on a forum like Reddit? I could easily be some ten-year-old kid—male or female, doesn't matter—just pulling your leg, right? Of course, the reverse is just as true.🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:... Seasonal depression is medically documented, which means medication is an option if someone
finds it
necessary. I am referring to mainstream medicine here, because it matters deeply where
one turns for help. Alternative medicine isn't recognized by the medical establishment, thank God... And as far as a spiritual remedy goes—look, Brian Edwards6,
every illness begins in the spirit,
and then manifests physically.

Isn't this often a core component of alternative medicine? Treating the spirit to heal the body? Aren't you taking His name in vain?🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:... However, it isn't quite right to claim that
"Americans who are Catholic practice their faith" in bars. Not all Americans
"practice their faith in bars," nor do they vomit or spill blood in them, etc. Every individual
has a conscience, and they live according to that conscience. Now, would someone
who is an active believer—meaning they attend Holy Mass regularly and go to confession frequently,
nourishing themselves with the Body of Christ (not just once a year, or once every decade, or
for long stretches, merely passing through the church on holidays)—would such a person come
into a bar after Holy Mass and vomit on a police officer or cause a bloody scene and call it "practicing their faith"?
I simply don't believe that happens, Brian Edwards6.
...

Not "right to say"? You don't believe it? Unfortunately, that skepticism has nothing to do with faith itself. I wish you could join us for one night. I’m sure you’d be a help to some, and perhaps even save a soul or two. But your entire perspective would shift. You have no idea how much.

Susan Brooks83 said:... And many people experience similar situations, though they aren't in the kind of workplace you are in,
so perhaps you could better understand their helplessness against those "power players." Those at the top when
they start invoking "the authorities"...

What authorities? They are just people like you and me. And we are the majority in power, aren't we? Invoking "their" authority is essentially inviting your own martyrdom.👎
Peter Stewart6 Peter Stewart6 MemberOP
18 messages
joined May 2010
#59 ·
Brian Edwards6 said:So, if we don't believe in the Church, we don't believe in God either? I don't really get it. The Church has nothing to do with belief. It’s just there, visible with all its virtues and flaws. We can know about it without needing to believe.

It's not clear to you, right? Your text doesn't show how you see the connection between God,
faith, and the Church.
You can't separate God from the Church, nor the Church from God. If you did,
faith weakens; it just turns into tradition. You believe because you feel you have to "check the box."
After nurturing that kind of approach for a while, people eventually stop looking
for other "spheres or beliefs." Not everyone, but quite often.
There are plenty of examples, and many people here on Reddit write about this based on their own
experiences. There are all sorts of reasons why people leave.
Just read my previous post again; I explained my reasoning well enough.

The Church is both holy and sinful, made up of believers. Some live holy lives
right here on Earth, while others... well, not all of us do. Examples of holiness are declared Saints.
Ordinary people who strived to live holily within the embrace of the Mother Church. And they succeeded through heroic virtue. For instance, look at our contemporary, Holy Father John Paul II, whose beatification is expected soon. 🙂

Then why are we withholding it from others in the name of God?

Withholding what, and from whom? 🤷 Be specific.

Is the problem now that I'm a man? Aren't we all equal?
Besides, what does gender have to do with a discussion on a forum? I could be a ten-year-old kid (boy or girl, doesn't matter) leading you around by the nose, couldn't I? Of course, the reverse is also true.

You're just fooling yourself with posts like these, Brian, though you haven't realized it yet. 🤣 Fine, if you're a ten-year-old
kid, then I guess I'm Hillary Clinton. 😂 Or maybe I'm Inspector Kluzo, whatever. It won't affect me one bit,
hehe.

Isn't this often a key part of alternative medicine? Healing the spirit to heal the body? Don't you mention His name in vain?

You can't compare the healing provided by the Holy Spirit to alternative medicine. 🙂
In the Church, we know that alternative practices try desperately to mimic the Holy Spirit's
gift of healing. You see various "healers" acting as "examples."🙄
No, we're talking about different kinds of spirits, Brian Edwards6, not the Holy Spirit.
Got any more critiques regarding my questions? 😁 Don't worry about me. 🙂

Isn't that a mean thing to say? You don't believe? Unfortunately, that doesn't have anything to do with faith either. I wish you could join us for a night like that just once. I'm sure you'd help someone, and maybe even save a few souls. But your perspective would change. You wouldn't even realize how much.

No, it isn't nice to say because you're generalizing. It’s impossible that every American Catholic "practices their faith in baby bottles." Not to repeat what I already wrote in my previous comment on your post. That’s just my opinion, and you can keep insisting it has nothing to do with faith if you want. That's your opinion.
Since you're inviting me, thanks, I actually had the chance recently. Whether I helped or not, only those who were with me for safety reasons know. My perspective hasn't changed, though whether my heart might harden over time is a different story. And yes, it's hard. It's hard. Enough said.

What government? We're just people like us. And we're the majority in power, aren't we? Invoking "their" authority is basically just asking for martyrdom.

You didn't catch what I meant. I wasn't talking about invoking "their authority," but rather how many people invoke someone else's power and influence to justify doing things that aren't acceptable. In those cases, someone always ends up suffering, Brian Edwards6. The news columns and other media outlets are full of examples like that. I was speaking generally, not directly regarding
the specific topic of this thread.
But go ahead, keep telling your story about "invoking martyrdom." 😬

🙂
Brian Edwards6 Brian Edwards6 Active Member
112 messages
joined Nov 2015
#60 ·
Susan Brooks83 said:It’s just not clear to you—not at all. It is painfully obvious from the way you write that you don't quite grasp the inherent interconnectedness of God.
Beliefs and the Church.
You can't separate God from the Church, nor can you strip the Church away from God. If anyone tries to make that distinction... well, they're missing the point entirely.

The issue here isn't a lack of clarity on either side of this argument; it’s simply that we fundamentally disagree. The supposed connection between any church and God is an invention manufactured by the institution itself, designed primarily to serve its own interests. It functions much like a middleman in a retail transaction—just another layer added to facilitate a deal.🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:The Church is both sacred and sinful, a paradox built from the lives of ordinary believers. Within its ranks, you’ll find some who truly strive to live a holy life, while others are just passing through.
Even here on Earth, there are those who embody true holiness—individuals whose lives serve as living examples of virtue, even if they haven't been officially canonized as Saints just yet.
Just regular folks who actually made the effort to pursue a life of holiness within the embrace of the Mother Church. And they didn't just try—they actually succeeded through sheer, heroic virtue. Take this contemporary of ours, for instance; he’s a true example in the vein of Holy Father John Paul II, whose beatification we're all eagerly anticipating soon...

We’re largely in agreement here. However, we have to acknowledge that there are plenty of non-believers out there who possess more integrity than many of the faithful, even if they don't live under the umbrella of the Mother Church. For some, the Church hasn't been a sanctuary; it's been more like a stepmother. Forgive me for bringing up history again, but I don't believe forgiveness should ever be synonymous with forgetting—or at least, it shouldn't be.

Susan Brooks83 said:You simply cannot draw any meaningful comparisons between the healing power provided by the Holy Spirit and anything you might find in the world of alternative medicine. It’s not even in the same league.
Look, those of us within the Church are well aware that the alternative is trying far too hard to mimic the Holy Spirit.
The charisma of healing... It’s funny how people point to various so-called "healers" as their primary "example."
No, Brian Edwards6, we're talking about an entirely different kind of spirit than the Holy Spirit...

Isn't that exactly what we're talking about—that sense of exclusivity and the systematic stripping away of one's freedom to choose?
Why couldn't these two things be compared? In both instances, you're attempting to heal the spirit using something that requires faith. Both sides possess an equal amount of absolute proof and an equal amount of absolute charlatans. What’s actually the difference between a massive Trade Fair in Chicago and a summer Camp in rural Montana? (Those are just the ones close to home; if anyone knows about similar setups in Islamic or Orthodox traditions, please feel free to weigh in.) The goals, methods, and faith are identical; only the name of the force changes. Isn't that right?🤷

Susan Brooks83 said:... No, that isn't a fair thing to say because you're generalizing. It's simply impossible for all American Catholics to be "practicing their faith in bars." I'm not going to repeat what I already wrote in my previous comment regarding your post. That is my perspective, and you are more than welcome to keep insisting that it has nothing to do with faith. That's your opinion....

I never claimed that everyone was like that. However, others often turn a blind eye to their own brothers who have lost their way. And yes, that has nothing to do with your specific faith. Blindness is a common trait among most religions—just as it is among alternative groups.👎

Peter Stewart6;24334127 said:... You didn't quite grasp what I wrote. I wasn't referring to appealing to "their own authority," but rather how many people invoke someone else's power or influence to justify doing things that aren't acceptable. In those cases, there's always someone suffering the consequences. News columns and various media outlets are full of such examples. I was speaking generally, not directly addressing
what this specific thread is about...QUOTE]

Actually, you were the one who missed the point.👎

Best regards.👋

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads