Megan Smith2 said:Hey, I’m actually a speech therapist, and I wanted to share my perspective: I find that adults often find it easier to correct articulation issues than children do. This is especially true when you're working on an "R" sound—which is notoriously tricky—particularly since yours has that guttural quality. I’m not saying this to discourage you; I just want you to be prepared that this won't be solved with just two weeks of practice. Why do I think adults have the edge? It really comes down to the sheer amount of practice required, which demands high motivation. Little kids often don't care how they sound; they might go through a thirty-minute session with a therapist and then completely forget about it the moment they walk out the door. That makes progress nearly impossible. Adults, however, who are motivated to work with their therapist and follow through with home exercises, tend to see great results.🙂🙂 As long as there's motivation, and it looks like you definitely have that. Regarding the frenulum issue: in my opinion, if you can pronounce your "L" normally, that shouldn't be a major hurdle... a therapist will confirm that once they evaluate you, but I don't think it should cause much trouble. Think of the "R" as essentially an "L" with vibration; if your tongue is mobile enough for the "L"... you just need to add that vibration.
Wishing you the best of luck🙂
Thanks, you didn't discourage me at all. If it really just boils down to motivation and hard work, I know I can do it. I wasn't expecting a quick fix anyway. An orthodontist told me that my "R" is definitely tied to my frenulum and suggested surgery, but I'd much rather get a second opinion from a speech therapist first. It also makes sense to me that if I can hit the "L," I should be able to hit the "R."
Amanda Sanders44 said:Just to add, what you're describing is a guttural rhotacism, and the tissue connecting your tongue to the bottom of your mouth that might need trimming is called the frenulum.🙂
But honestly, if you've already had that procedure done once, I don't see why it wouldn't have been done correctly—it's not exactly a complicated surgery to get right...🤷 Since you can say "L," it might just be that the tip of your tongue isn't quite mobile enough yet; if it's a bit sluggish, it might struggle to create those necessary vibrations for the "R."
The chances of speech therapy working are 100%! Like Megan Smith2 mentioned, it's actually easier for an adult than for a kid. With your drive and persistence, plus the right therapy, you'll get there! 😉
Best, Megan Smith2, future speech therapist.😍
Thanks for the info. Interestingly, that same orthodontist who suggested surgery also mentioned that this hospital has had issues with improper frenulotomies before. That sounds a bit strange to me, but I can't say for sure. The best move is probably to go see a specialist.
I don't think I'm too sluggish for that, because I can actually "perform" a trilled French R—well, it’s not quite the perfect version, but I know my tongue is definitely capable of that vibration 🙂
I’d love it if one of you two could point me in the right direction. I really want to avoid ending up with some high-strung speech therapist 🙂 Gregory Martinez13, especially if you happen to know a clinic that uses that specific probe 🙂
Thanks so much!