#1 ·
Huge thanks to NPR for airing The Piano; the movie was incredible, especially that soundtrack. Definitely worth a watch..
Started by Donna Garcia3 · · 👁 4 views · 16 replies
Larry Martin11 said:...no matter how bizarre it felt—given he’s been on NPR or something similar so many times before—watching him for the first time actually left me feeling a bit let down... it has its perks, sure (there's that lovely atmosphere built by the phenomenal music—the way the melodies contrast between scenes, specifically those with George versus the ones with her husband, I practically froze 🙂; there's the adorable little Anna Paquin and an unusually striking—if slightly unhinged—Robert De Niro; there's an overwhelming amount of beautiful—if occasionally over-the-top—symbolism; it has a gorgeous opening and a sooo beautiful ending...), but I still couldn't shake the feeling that I was watching a cookie-cutter exploitation flick. It exploits the setting and context just to pretend it has depth, and it exploits emotions just to squeeze out emotions. Then there's that tired, repetitive trope of the unloved man who can only ever become the "aggressor"—he's really just a catalyst for the other events, but he isn't even a caricature, let alone a fully realized character (and it's always been this way since Meat—well, even before that, but Baptiste's wife is the first person who comes to mind, and she was a much stronger "character" than this guy, since Neill's character doesn't truly exist—at least until Jane Campion arrived....)...I don't know, I spent the whole time thinking the film would be drastically better if it were "stripped down," taken out of its context and presented as a study of the "layers" between the characters. It would be fascinating to see how a slightly "grittier" director would handle it (my picks would be either Michel Chereau or Michael Haneke 🙂, though I suppose Arnold could do a good job too, but maybe I'm still just under the spell...)
...but even so, I have to admit, I was moved by 🙂
...but one thing occurred to me while watching—Matanović's "Fame" owes more to this than any other film 🙂 (some scenes are almost identical copies...)
Larry Martin11 said:...no matter how bizarre it felt—given he’s been on NPR or something similar so many times before—watching him for the first time actually left me feeling a bit let down... it has its perks, sure (there's that lovely atmosphere built by the phenomenal music—the way the melodies contrast between scenes, specifically those with George versus the ones with her husband, I practically froze 🙂; there's the adorable little Anna Paquin and an unusually striking—if slightly unhinged—Robert De Niro; there's an overwhelming amount of beautiful—if occasionally over-the-top—symbolism; it has a gorgeous opening and a sooo beautiful ending...), but I still couldn't shake the feeling that I was watching a cookie-cutter exploitation flick. It exploits the setting and context just to pretend it has depth, and it exploits emotions just to squeeze out emotions. Then there's that tired, repetitive trope of the unloved man who can only ever become the "aggressor"—he's really just a catalyst for the other events, but he isn't even a caricature, let alone a fully realized character (and it's always been this way since Meat—well, even before that, but Baptiste's wife is the first person who comes to mind, and she was a much stronger "character" than this guy, since Neill's character doesn't truly exist—at least until Jane Campion arrived....)...I don't know, I spent the whole time thinking the film would be drastically better if it were "stripped down," taken out of its context and presented as a study of the "layers" between the characters. It would be fascinating to see how a slightly "grittier" director would handle it (my picks would be either Michel Chereau or Michael Haneke 🙂, though I suppose Arnold could do a good job too, but maybe I'm still just under the spell...)
...but even so, I have to admit, I was moved by 🙂
...but one thing occurred to me while watching—Matanović's "Fame" owes more to this than any other film 🙂 (some scenes are almost identical copies...)