northernangler8 said:I don't mean you actually sat there watching it back in '78. I just mean that the movies you grew up with can easily get rewritten by nostalgia. Since zombies are having a huge moment again, that's probably why people are revisiting it. But if you ask me, it’s definitely one of those overrated films.
I didn't actually see it until I was in my mid-twenties, if I recall correctly, and that was after I'd already sat through some "heavy hitters" like The Exorcist... so for me, it's still the best one simply because the execution is solid. There’s zero nostalgia factor involved here—if we were going by that logic, I should be obsessed with Night... since I saw that as a kid, but in reality, it’s a pretty mediocre flick. Not a bad concept, necessarily, but it just really rubs me the wrong way how banal and, frankly, stupid it is. I actually think the remake is better, mostly because Savini gave the female lead some actual agency instead of treating her like a piece of furniture... I mean, if Dawn of the Dead (1978) is considered "bad," then Diary or that last one, Survival... are basically unwatchable. They aren't even in that special category of being "so bad they're good." And no, people aren't revisiting this version just because zombies are "popular" again—it's more about Snyder's version (which is also a good movie) being modern and hitting that sweet spot for younger horror fans today. Dawn of the Dead (1978) is all about pure atmosphere—those shots of the empty city center, the soundtrack, characters who aren't exactly lovable at first glance... it all works, even now, and that's why it holds its ground.