Jerry Martin19 said:I’m not saying everything they say is gospel or anything, but in the eyes of a huge chunk of people—and even within the big Hollywood studios and the entire film industry—it basically carries a ton of weight. I mean, why would critics even exist if nobody actually cared about them? They exist because there’s a demand. It’s the critics who put together all those top-tier rankings and write those deep dives (🙄) into specific movies. Do you honestly feel like you need someone else's take just to figure out what you think? Personally, I don't. If I already have my own sense of what makes a movie good, why on earth would I care about some stranger's opinion? At the end of the day, who am I watching the movie for? That’s really the point I’m trying to make here. 🙂
First off, regarding whether I need a critic's input, I think I've made my position pretty clear.
What we're really getting at here is that we're all just defending our own perspectives, so I guess there isn't much point in us just shouting the same things back and forth indefinitely.
As for those rating lists... I was actually thinking about this earlier, and it made me wonder what those rankings will even look like fifty years from now. 😕 I honestly think that once a "new generation" of critics takes over, we're going to see some massive shifts in how those lists are put together.