melloworca46 said:Which model should I go with? I don't want to drop a ton of cash, so maybe something used would work.
How can I tell if a model uses refillable cartridges?
If you're buying new, then
An HP OfficeJet is roughly $300 +
Hummingbird refillable tanks == $50 + tax +
Hummingbird or Magnetic ink (4 x 100ml) == about 80 cartridges == 150 or $33 + tax
Do the math and see what the total comes to
Same thing if you go the used route
An HP OfficeJet with refillable tanks + 4 x 100ml ink == 88 cartridges == $333
Or
An HP OfficeJet with refillable tanks + 4 x 100ml ink == 88 cartridges == $167
So what's the deal with the difference?
The difference is that the OfficeJet has 128 nozzles per color, while the other one has 90. But it's nearly 100% faster, so it makes up for having fewer nozzles with pure speed.
Then you've got the other OfficeJet with maybe 28(?) nozzles, which is painfully slow if you want the same print quality as the first two. Basically, if one nozzle out of 128 gets clogged, you won't even notice. Same goes for the 90-nozzle version. But with only 28, it's actually noticeable.
Now, if you consider that the OfficeJet also has extra consumables like a battery for the refillable system—which has an uncertain lifespan and costs about 15 - $6.75 to replace—while the other doesn't need that, then both options make sense depending on how you look at the price and usage.
If you aren't planning on printing a massive amount, just grab the cheapest All-in-One you can find and toss it once the ink runs out. Honestly, between the mess of swapping cartridges and the time or money spent maintaining it, it’s barely worth the headache. That's just how they design them now. It's like disposable pens, markers, or lighters. You don't really swap the internals anymore. Sure, there are third-party fixes, but they aren't nearly as reliable as the dedicated refillable systems for Epson.
In the higher-end tier, though, swapping out components because of those 90 or 128 nozzles actually makes sense.
It's a similar story with Canon or HP in that category. Epson just has the edge because you have reliable Hummingbird refillable tanks and ink to back it up. You won't run into issues even if it sits for a while, mostly because the print head is easy to clean. That isn't always true for the originals (pigmented ink tends to settle if it sits too long), let alone some random third-party stuff you pick up from different vendors every time. It's like when you constantly switch partners in bed and then wonder why things aren't working out.
But here, you get 4 x 100ml bottles, and for some people, that lasts them a couple of years.