Freedom and Education
in Philosophy ·
Laura Reyes3 said:There’s more red tape in the healthcare system than in schools—so why not start a philosophical debate about abolishing hospitals altogether?
There’s more red tape in the defense department than in schools—so why not start a philosophical debate about abolishing the military?
There’s more red tape in the banking sector than in schools—so why not start a philosophical debate about abolishing banks?
There’s more red tape in the legal system than in schools—so why not start a philosophical debate about abolishing the courts?
The Roman education system was pretty much what you're advocating for, and the most famous educational theorist in Rome concluded that public schools are actually a good thing...
If I don't like a specific approach or a treatment plan, I can just walk out of the hospital and seek care elsewhere—or try a different method entirely.
Our military is essentially pointless anyway since we're just playing proxy for someone else. Over the last year, we’ve handed over billions of dollars worth of weapons to a country we have zero connection with—that's nearly a thousand bucks per employee (30,000 machine guns, hundreds of mortars, 14 helicopters...).
We’re all forced to use banks to some degree, but crypto exists specifically because of the flaws in the banking system—it allows for direct transactions without middlemen or needing anyone's permission.
Our courts are such a mess that they might be better off non-existent.
Did the most famous education theorist in Rome have to deal with inspectors, endless regulations, and angry parents? Did he have to stick to a rigid curriculum and teach in one specific way, or did he have the freedom to explore topics alongside his students? Did he have the authority to remove a student who was sabotaging class or bullying others? Did he even have the right to discipline them? Just a reminder: in America, homeschooling isn't really a formal concept here—you basically have to hand your child over to "expert" strangers to be "educated."