brightwolf48 said:Don't try to play both sides with me here. It’s pretty obvious from that link you shared that we're talking about experimental music—if you actually listen closely for like, two and a half minutes (and I know you've looped this track a dozen times already), there’s this really pleasant melody buried in the background. My link? There's no melody there. Look, smarter people usually define music as a combination of melody, rhythm, and, in Western music, harmony. Whether I personally dig it or not is a whole different conversation. (By the way, Loveless is one of my absolute favorite albums, so don't think for a second that I'm not hip to noise.)
If nothing actually defines music as music, then how can we even call it that? Lemonzoo hit the nail on the head with that definition—it’s more like a sound installation. Sure, a piece like that can be super intriguing, genuinely interesting, or even just vibe-heavy and pleasant to listen to, but we don't necessarily have to label it "music." It’s kind of like hitting a tennis ball against a wall; it might be fun, but if you want to say you're actually playing tennis, you need a court, a net, and someone on the other side of the net to rally with.
Anyway, let’s try to find some actually decent sources for music theory instead of just relying on Wikipedia.
So, I was falling down a rabbit hole reading through some deep dives on the history of music videos, and man, it really makes you realize how much we take for granted today. It’s wild to think about how much the whole medium has shifted from just being a promotional tool to this massive, standalone art form that can basically define an era. I was thinking about those early days where it was all about the visual hook—something to get people to buy the record—but now? Now it's its own beast. You have artists who treat a video like a short film, completely independent of the track itself. It’s almost like when you listen to something heavy like Sunn O))) or experimental stuff from Merzbow; the visual element becomes this sensory overload that changes how you perceive the sound entirely. It reminds me a bit of how certain ambient projects work. Like, if you're listening to Stars of the Lid, you're already in this headspace, right? But if you pair that with the right cinematography, the experience goes from "background music" to "full-on cinematic immersion." It's that jump from passive listening to active experiencing. Anyway, I'm curious what you guys think. Is the music video still a vital part of the artist's identity, or has it just become another way to chase clicks on YouTube? Does a killer video actually make a song better, or does it just distract from the music? Personally, I think if a director can capture the *vibe* of a track—not just show the singer lip-syncing in a desert—it's pure magic.
Honestly, you could just throw a single record into the mix and end up with pretty much the same results as what we've been talking about above.
Look, even Merzbow has those lighter, more approachable albums if you know where to look. But honestly? If you just stick to Boris, it’s still a smooth ride. They’re incredibly versatile. I’d say they’ve mastered at least ten different genres over their career—maybe even more. Some tracks blend them all together in a single album, while others just drift through different styles seamlessly.
You could honestly just take some Merzbow tracks, bundle them up as a standalone album, and it would sound exactly how you’d imagine. It works perfectly fine on its own. As for Gensho, it isn't exactly "easy listening" by any stretch, but as a project? It's super interesting. And hey, this isn't even the only instance of Boris + Merzbow stuff out there—there's plenty more where that came from.
I’ll be honest, I don't really vibe with Merzbow—just doesn't grab me. I’m much more into stuff like Taj Mahal, Ben Frost, Fennesz, Oneohtrix Point Never, Stars of the Lid, The Caretaker, Boards of Canada, or Aphex Twin. Most of those aren't even strictly "noise" music, but they all have that massive ambient approach that I love. Actually, if I'm looking for something on the noisier side, I usually gravitate toward Noise pop or that specific sound Sonic Youth was doing back in their EP days.
Whatever, honestly—no matter how you slice it, it’s all just music in its own unique way.
You could literally just grab some old dial-up connection samples, throw them into a DAW, and suddenly you’ve got a whole damn musical composition on your hands.
If we’re talking about the whole Drone scene—you know, stuff like Boris, Sunn O))), and Earth—it's wild how much they've evolved when it comes to their gear and how they actually use it. In the early days, everything was super minimalist, just raw and stripped back. But lately? They've branched out into some seriously massive, complex territory.
There are certain things that just define what music actually is. This album hits on all of them, but it does it in such a stripped-back, minimalist way that it’s almost microscopic. It’s honestly tough to even pick out individual sounds, let alone find any kind of actual progression between them. I mean, we don't even have to call it music—if you can even call it that.
So I was just falling down a rabbit hole reading up on Merzbow, and man, my brain is kind of fried. It’s wild how much history there is behind this guy. If you haven't spent any time digging through his discography, you're basically missing out on one of the most intense sonic experiences possible. It's not exactly "background music" for a chill Sunday brunch, that's for sure. I mean, think about the sheer scale of it. We're talking about someone who has been pushing the absolute limits of noise for decades. It’s heavy, it’s overwhelming, and honestly? It’s kind of beautiful in its own chaotic way. It makes you wonder how anyone stays sane while producing stuff this loud. Anyway, I was browsing some old threads and saw Patrick Patel4 mentioning him earlier, and it got me thinking about how different the noise scene feels depending on what you're into. Are you more of a pure wall-of-sound person, or do you need a bit of structure? Personally, I can go for a long session of pure chaos, but sometimes I need to pivot to something like Stars of the Lid just to make sure my eardrums don't actually burst. What do you guys think? Is Merzbow a genre unto himself, or just the king of a much larger, much louder playground?
I mean, he’s literally spelling it out for you right there. Genre: Noise.
If it doesn't sound good to my ears, then I’m just not feeling it. Period.
You know, whenever I head out to a show, nothing gets me more hyped than that pre-set guitar tuning ritual during the opening act. It’s like this weird, anticipatory tension. Once the actual performance kicks off, though, I don't care nearly as much about those little details—everything becomes so clearly defined and intentional. Obviously, when the headliner takes the stage, I expect them to deliver exactly what I paid to hear, but there’s just something uniquely fascinating about what that tuning process can stir up. Some seriously chill sounds. I need to get myself into the zone before the band even hits the stage—honestly, I’m probably more hyped up than the guys playing tonight.