Round 6 Elections: Let's hear your thoughts...
in Philosophy ·
Amanda Jackson5 said:I honestly don't see how pondering hypothetical extraterrestrial civilizations has anything to do with conspiracy theories.
It’s truly Fascinanto how certain people get so worked up over the mere idea of alien civilizations—ideas that, based on everything we know about the scale of the universe, wouldn't just be possible, they'd be statistically bizarre if they didn't exist. Yet, at the very same time, those same people cling desperately to notions of some fantastic supreme being, convinced that this entity "loves" them or will eventually "save" them (whatever that's supposed to mean). We're talking about beliefs in things that likely don't exist and lack even a shred of evidence, let alone any connection to common sense or critical thinking. It's pure bias. I’d love to hear a rational explanation from you religious types regarding why the concept of extraterrestrial life bothers you so much. Rational, mind you, not emotional. From an emotional standpoint, it's obvious that these ideas just mess with your head. Are you afraid your imaginary friend might run into some competition?
So, ancient aliens aren't a conspiracy theory? For those of you pushing the idea of extraterrestrial life, haven't you basically just copy-pasted "ancient astronaut" rhetoric over and over again? It’s really just a standard conspiracy theory, plain and simple. Besides—and this is my little gripe here—believing in galactic or intergalactic civilizations inevitably pushes people toward entertaining things like alien abductions and similar nonsense. Just because the CIA has been leaning into this whole UFO narrative for the last year or so doesn't mean there's actually any substance to it.
It’s fascinating how some people find thoughts about alien civilizations repulsive—even though, based on everything we know, it wouldn't just be possible for them to exist, it would be incredibly strange if they didn't. Yet, at the exact same time, they hold onto these ideas about some fantastic supreme being, convinced that they are "loved" and will be "saved" (whatever that means). So, they reject one possibility while clinging to something that likely doesn't exist, lacks any evidence, and flies in the face of common sense or critical thinking.
Actually, I find the opposite to be true. Religion is a universal human phenomenon, so there is plenty of "evidence" for the existence of God. Aliens, on the other hand, seem to be a curiosity born from a technological and materialistic society—sort of a ridiculous caricature or a watered-down version of those very same religious motifs and experiences that people otherwise tend to scoff at.
The Fermi paradox remains an impassable wall. The issue, I think, is that people don't really care about the arguments—because believing in aliens has just become a sort of liberal, techno-materialist pseudo-mythology.