Jacob Foster11 said:Alright, stepping in here as a moderator.
First off, regarding the "Hire/Offer" thread—it’s specifically designed as a spot where someone can say they need web development or offer those services. No links, no images, and zero company names allowed in the thread. Just a plain text ad, and all follow-up happens strictly via PM. Emails, phone numbers, you name it—none of that is permitted. Basically, the thread exists solely to connect people who need a site with people who build them. Because of those strict rules, there's zero chance for actual advertising since the only thing visible is a user's handle. No real names, no brands, no reviews... nothing. This is the one and only place in the entire Internet subforum where any kind of self-promotion is actually okay.
Daniel Garcia is selling books. Books have absolutely nothing to do with the purpose of the thread mentioned above. As for posting ads elsewhere, ads are banned everywhere else. And about that penalty—it was just a yellow card. So, Daniel Garcia hasn't been banned, he just got a warning...
If people want to post various other ads, there's the Classifieds subforum. Or even just put something in your signature like "selling this book, hit me up via PM"—I've seen plenty of users do that.
Look, that specific thread is packed with links, emails, and service prices, which makes them blatant ads. Plus, you see questions and advice about web development and tools popping up there too. It's clearly a space meant for trading services and expertise. Since these books are instructional and directly related to the subject matter and the whole subforum, it counts as offering knowledge—so claiming it's off-topic just doesn't fly.
How am I getting flagged for an ad in the Dreamweaver thread when people in the "Hire/Offer" thread are running full-blown commercials? I didn't drop any links or emails, so I wasn't running an ad. And since when does the rule change depending on which thread you're in?...