lonetrucker4 said:So, if you’re 16, you don't have the right to vote, let alone the right to criticize anything. At what age does that rule stop applying? Can I, at 62, look someone who's 40 in the eye and say, "Listen, kid, you don't get to critique the mess my generation made"? 🤔 Joža Manolić claims anyone under 90 is just a kid. 🤣
Neurological development typically wraps up around age 25, specifically regarding those prefrontal cortex functions like analysis, strategic thinking, abstract reasoning, and emotional regulation. Personally, I’d say the window between 25 and 30 is when true maturity actually kicks in. That upper limit isn't set in stone, though. Cognitive decline isn't nearly as predictable as developmental milestones, so you could easily find an 80-year-old in better mental shape than someone in their 70s.
When it comes to technical discussions, years on the job aren't the only thing that matters—expertise is key. A sixteen-year-old still stuck in high school doesn't just lack the cognitive tools needed for a serious debate; they usually don't have the facts to back it up either.
Then there’s the whole conversation around her mental health and specific diagnoses—things like developmental delays (by their account), anxiety, depression, and Asperger. It’s a slippery slope, though. Depending on how you look at it, those traits could be seen as a weakness or an advantage. It all depends on your perspective.
If anyone actually wants to have a serious discussion, I’d suggest bringing in someone who actually works in the field professionally—someone with a PhD, proper academic credentials, and a solid history of relevant research under their belt. Age-wise, we’re probably looking at someone in the 30 to 60 range.
Dragging a kid with Asperger to the UN isn't exactly a scientific debate; it's just activist performance art.
I'm not saying it can't be useful, but personally, I find it pretty distasteful—even when it's coming from a platform I generally agree with. I have a real issue with the dumbing down of any subject, but unfortunately, populism is what drives politics these days.
Anyway, that’s a whole different debate and doesn't really matter for the question being asked here.