Nicholas King said:Every single child has significantly more developed mechanisms and a much better capacity for recognizing things than some senile old woman—does that mean it’s perfectly fine to slap Grandma Hedwig when her own mechanisms and recognition skills fail her?
BTW, you are grossly underestimating both children and their actual ability to process things. On the contrary—and I am repeating this to counter the absolute nonsense that physical punishment from parents is actually a sign of neglect or a lack of care—a slap or a kick in the rear is nothing more than a disgusting shortcut. It's used because people want to follow the principle of "one kick in the butt speaks louder than a thousand words" just so they can get back to staring at math equations, sipping a beer, and engaging in typical male banter in peace.
You know that saying, "you can't teach an old dog new tricks"?😉
While there are behavioral similarities between the elderly and children, their brains are worlds apart—one is still developing while the other is essentially breaking down. One absorbs everything like a sponge; the other leaks like a cracked pot.
Positive reinforcement (rewards) and negative reinforcement (punishment) are both tools used to shape behavior. You don't use them on the elderly. With kids, it's your job to use them; otherwise, parents wouldn't be raising functional adults capable of living on their own.
Using something to vent personal frustration is one thing (that's just abuse), but using it as a method of conditioning is something else entirely.
We can debate whether certain conditioning methods are good or bad, but comparing them to the elderly is a non-starter.
I agree with the bottom half of the post. I haven't kept up with this deeply, but if my college developmental psychology classes taught me anything, it's that while violent upbringing is the worst, being overly permissive is arguably worse than being "firm." The issue seems to be inconsistency and motivation rather than the specific method itself. Given how fickle the subject is, I can't say for sure what my professor's exact stance was, but I haven't seen any evidence from other sources suggesting a smack on the rear is inherently harmful regardless of the context.
So, tell me, where did you get such expert knowledge on kids and their brain functions? Is this your profession, or have you just raised a lot of children?