stormybadger8 said:And I wouldn't exactly agree.
Hamilton passed the SC—though honestly, was that before or after he hit the track? Not sure. But Alonso definitely, 100%, passed the SC on track once it was out there.
So, by that logic, Alonso is the one breaking the rules.😳
How? Why? Does it even matter?
There have been races where it’s literally like this:
Driver A crashes, limps onto the grass in a totaled car, and tries to make it to the pits.
A few drivers blast past him under yellow flags and dodge a penalty.😳
It's completely nonsensical. The guy driving a wreck through the grass is the problem anyway—he’s got zero chance of finishing, and there's debris everywhere. Plus, the SC has to be on track.
Same deal here. Hamilton is "guilty" because he slowed down and then eventually passed the SC.
But Alonso is also guilty because he passed the SC. And does it matter if he did it at low speed or high speed? What was his lap time? Does any of that actually count?
Not to me, because he passed the SC on the track.
Sorry, but in my book, Alonso is undeniably in the wrong. As for Hamilton, I'm not even 100% sure myself—I honestly don't know what the rulebook says about passing when the SC enters the track in a situation like this.🤷
I have no interest in debating who is at fault here.
Race control made their call.
That said—the penalty didn't fit the infraction.
LH took a hit, but when you look at the benefit versus the penalty, he came out way ahead.
Again—let's not get bogged down in who did what.
Let's talk about whether the punishment actually made sense.
stormybadger8 said:And I wouldn't exactly agree.
Hamilton passed the SC—though honestly, was that before or after he hit the track? Not sure. But Alonso definitely, 100%, passed the SC on track once it was out there.
So, by that logic, Alonso is the one breaking the rules.😳
How? Why? Does it even matter?
There have been races where it’s literally like this:
Driver A crashes, limps onto the grass in a totaled car, and tries to make it to the pits.
A few drivers blast past him under yellow flags and dodge a penalty.😳
It's completely nonsensical. The guy driving a wreck through the grass is the problem anyway—he’s got zero chance of finishing, and there's debris everywhere. Plus, the SC has to be on track.
Same deal here. Hamilton is "guilty" because he slowed down and then eventually passed the SC.
But Alonso is also guilty because he passed the SC. And does it matter if he did it at low speed or high speed? What was his lap time? Does any of that actually count?
Not to me, because he passed the SC on the track.
Sorry, but in my book, Alonso is undeniably in the wrong. As for Hamilton, I'm not even 100% sure myself—I honestly don't know what the rulebook says about passing when the SC enters the track in a situation like this.🤷
Does that really sound right to you?
🤦