Mark White11 said:I mean, seriously, if you consider Boogie Nights, Hard Eight, and There Will Be Blood to be his true masterpieces, then all this stuff he’s been pumping out lately isn't even in the same league.
When someone like you—who basically treats a first date like a hookup—says it, then it's probably the truth.
Hands down, *The Master* is Anderson’s absolute best. Seriously. And if you look back at those Oscar categories now, just remind yourself what a complete joke the Best Picture nominees actually were.
Brandon Fox2 said:It’s perfect for younger viewers trying to build a real sense of taste, and for us older folks to remember what actual cinema feels like! What a collection. I totally ignore Slavoj Žižek when it comes to defining quality—any sane person can tell good from bad on their own!
Check out what William Friedkin had to say about CC...
Brandon Fox2 said:It’s perfect for younger viewers looking to build some actual taste, and for us older folks to remember what real cinema actually feels like! What a collection! I totally ignore Slavoj Žižek when it comes to judging quality—any sane person can figure out what's good on their own!
Honestly, in the clip I posted, even Žižek is somewhat tolerable and interesting. 😉
androlog;51735790 said:Since they haven't actually dropped anything yet, they could start with some heavy hitters like 'Raise the Red Lantern' or 'Farewell My Concubine.' Then maybe hit them with 'In the Heat of the Sun'—it’s kind of like that classic American period piece everyone loves—which is always sitting at the top of those Chinese cinema lists. After that, you've got that killer noir melodrama 'Suzhou River,' and then move into modern stuff like 'Still Life' or 'Blind Mountain.' If they released 'King of the Children,' it would be a massive deal because finding a decent version of that movie is basically impossible right now.
It'll probably be right on the money. I'm guessing dealing with Chinese studios is just a bigger headache. Since you brought up Yimo, I’d definitely throw in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Story_of_Qiu_Ju. It's a total Film enthusiast dream!
hiddenbear4 said:Yeah, I see what you mean. Only that Godard guy sticks out to me a bit here...
Making a list of top movies without Anna Karina is a losing game. 🙂 Honestly, Vivre would fit better on this list, but I just can't resist that playful energy between Belmondo and Karina, or the way Fuller and the French Riviera vibe in Pierrot.
hiddenbear4 said:I wasn't talking about you, since you actually bothered to write a sentence or two about every movie you listed... honestly, it would be great if everyone else would just drop a quick note on why they love certain films. Even looking at Larry Thompson85's list, you can see a really specific, well-defined taste. You can tell exactly what this guy is into; those names together create one super interesting stylistic thread.
At the start, we just need to throw out enough bait to get people interested. Thank God the internet is packed with info on these directors and their work, so anyone can look them up. As for me? I’ve got a soft spot for refined stylists. Especially the ones who lean toward stripping down directorial technique and content to the essentials. 🙂
Michael Lopez2 said:Back to the thread—these are also sitting right up there among my all-time favorites from Criterion so far (and they haven't been mentioned yet):
Giulietta degli spiriti La strada La dolce vita Fiend Without a Face Kwaidan Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas The Killing 12 Angry Men Picnic AT Paths of Glory When Woman Ascends The Stairs It's Mad Mad Mad Mad World Chungking express Il
Carl Theodor Dreyer Box Set A Man Escaped Eclipse Series 3 : latiti Ozu Tokyo Story Pierrot Le Tokyo Story Pierrot Army of Shadows Le Le deuxieme souffle Jeanne Dielman Eclipse Series 5 : The First Films of Samuel Fuller Stranger Than Paradise nadati Stranger Than Paradise
Fassbinder's work absolutely wrecked me. For the first thirty minutes, I was sitting there thinking I was watching the most boring movie ever made, but once I finally 'acclimatized' to the pacing—that subtle, almost abrasive Fassbinder direction and the gritty, realistic design—I realized I was looking at a total masterpiece. Look, I'll be honest, it's definitely not for everyone.
Michael Lopez2 said:It’s not that the whole movie is a total mess, but man, some of these scenes are just nonsensical. The worst part? That bit where the brother, the sister, and the dying slave girl are all trying to make their break from captivity. The sister looks at her brother and basically tells him to just leave her behind in the woods because she'll only slow him down—but then insists he takes the dying woman along since she "can't" carry her, even though she’s the one who’s been lugging her around the entire time. Makes zero sense. And then the sister goes and tries to drown herself in the lake. That scene hits me right in the gut, mostly because... Sisterhood is a total scam. Victim mentality is everywhere. It really should’ve been the movie's big, climactic moment, but honestly? They totally fumbled the execution. It was just limp.
Some characters in this flick are just straight-up half-baked. You’ve got this brother who spends years in a POW camp only to turn into this cynical piece of work who's out there cold-bloodedly branding slaves with a hot iron, acting like he wants to stay in the camp forever. Then, out of nowhere, he’s suddenly all about smuggling stuff out and playing the human rights activist. It makes zero sense. One second he's a villain, the next he's a saint. Pick a lane.
Don't get me wrong—the movie is moving, gorgeous, and hits you right in the gut. It’s impressive, sure. But I am absolutely not buying the hype that it belongs on some "greatest films of all time" pedestal. Not happening.
Orson Welles is the absolute king. Look, *The Searchers* and *Citizen Kane* are total masterpieces, no doubt, but if we're being real, my favorite has to be *Sunset Boulevard*. If I remember correctly, his films make up the biggest chunk of my personal collection. Check out this latest drop from The Criterion Collection. They finally put out Sunset Boulevard. It’s about time, honestly. This thing is a total masterpiece, even if it’s a bit dark for some people. If you haven't seen it yet, you're seriously missing out on one of the best noir pieces ever made. Just go watch it already.
Michael Lopez2 said:The Hidden Fortress is absolutely killer—such a charming flick. I haven't even seen Star Wars yet (unbelievable, I know, but hey, some people exist). 😬Anyway, I'm curious to see how it stacks up against THF.
When it comes to those Japanese filmmakers, here are my absolute favorite titles from The Criterion Collection:
Hausu House of Onibaba Kuroneko Rashomon Rashomon Twenty-Four Eyes Gate of Hell Woman of the Dunes
Look, let's just be real here: THF is a much better directed movie than Star Wars. Period. 🙂
When it comes to the Japanese masters, I’m putting my money on Yasujirō Ozu. And honestly? Woman of The Dunes is just gorgeous.
Michael Lopez2 said:Dodes'ka-den isn't really much of an adaptation of that play compared to Donzoko (1957) - The Lower Depths (which might honestly be the most underrated Kurosawa-esque film out there).
Props to Kurosawa, but the Renoir version wins hands down.
Classic Jean-Pierre Melville. Totally Atmosferican, zero unnecessary fluff, and featuring an incredible Lino Ventur. This might honestly be his role of a lifetime.
I’m a huge fan of noir, and Jules Dassin has always been right at the top of my list for the genre. For a long time, I thought his best noir was The Naked City, but Rififi totally changed my mind. Because of the anti-communist witch hunts, Dassin actually had to leave the USA, so this one ended up being made in France.
If you’re digging Melville and Dassin, you’ve gotta check out Claude Sautet’s Class... assuming you haven't already.
As for Clouzot... yeah, pure classic French fatalism.
I honestly think this movie section deserves its own Criterion Collection thread, so let’s kick things off with a single link. Slavoj Žižek is picking his favorites from the collection. Look, I’m not exactly a huge fan of his, but this is actually pretty interesting...
Arthur Garcia59 said:Did you lose your "broken record" somewhere along the way? I just had this absolutely wild thought: what if Haneke actually ripped off Mirković?
Man, talk about an original—and totally unhinged—take!
Arthur Garcia59 said:the lineup at the New Horizons festival in Austin is basically the best programming on the planet right now.
Nah, I was actually picturing Haneke walking into his hotel room after bagging this second Golden Palm, popping on Mirković's "night boat," and getting absolutely hammered. Poor kid.
Comparing a guy whose films feel like they were directed by someone who learned the craft in an Algebra coding bootcamp to Haneke is just bad taste. 😉
I’ve never been much of a Cronenberg fanatic. Speaking of his recent stuff, I honestly don't get the hype surrounding History of Violence and Eastern Promises. With the first one, the whole preachy lecture on the nature of violence felt incredibly forced, especially when paired with that ending involving William Hurt—it almost felt like a parody. As for the second, there's one genuinely fascinating scene (the Turkish bath), but after that, I pretty much forgot how "interesting" the rest was.
Generally speaking, watching a lot of his movies feels like they were directed by HAL 9000. I'll throw Videodrome into that mix too, though I will say that remains his most intriguing and best work.
What we saw today was a masterclass in how to absolutely blow it. Seriously, get that poser Shane Valdes off the national team already. He belongs back on a boardwalk in Miami with two packs of Marlboros. And don't even get me started on Kopljar... if he’s really that soft, that timid, and that bad with women... ugh! 😉