urbantinker8 said:Regarding that last point: you definitely have grounds for an appeal if things actually played out the way you described.
I can't speak for what's happening in Des Moines, but I know how it works in New York City—specifically, finding math or computer science teachers is a total disaster, whereas biology isn't nearly as much of a struggle.
I didn't bother appealing. They just reposted the job opening and picked someone else. I've realized that a lot of these hiring processes follow this frustrating pattern: post the job, cancel it, then repost it until they find exactly who they want. When you see that happening, it starts looking less like a fair search and more like a rigged game.
I even heard from my contact over at the State Employment Agency that finding Bio/Chem teachers is becoming a massive headache. Back when I was in college in a mid-sized city like Columbus, you wouldn't even see ten people enrolling in the teaching track. But nowadays, you have plenty of people who specialized in just biology or just chemistry, yet these job postings specifically demand a dual-certified teacher. They really need to split those listings up. Sure, it might mean some teachers don't get a full schedule, but isn't it better to have a biologist teach biology and a chemist teach chemistry rather than forcing a single person to do both just because the requirements are too narrow?
Honestly, I barely even apply for positions that require chemistry, even though I could technically cover it at a middle school level. I’d only consider it if it were out in some tiny rural town where they absolutely couldn't find anyone else.
Just recently, there was an opening in a small town outside of a major Midwestern hub for a Bio/Chem teacher, and twenty-seven candidates applied. So, it's not like there's a shortage of qualified people. I don't follow the trends for other science subjects—I stay focused on my own field—but it’s infuriating to read about a food technology major teaching biology while I, a literal biologist, can't even land a four-hour subbing gig. If anything, we're going to have a surplus of biologists soon enough, considering how many enroll in the big state universities.