Good grief, what a cliché-ridden, sugary mess. It feels like Once was really the peak of Carney's work, because honestly, both Begin Again and now Sing Street feel pretty lackluster by comparison.
The film is watchable enough, I guess, but there's nothing special about it. The songs are incredibly weak—even weaker than the ones in Begin Again (Once is just several classes above these two, where the tracks are totally forgettable and monotonous). It’s disappointing, really; there are way too many sappy scenes and the characters are just pure stereotypes...
If you want a actually good film about a band, you're better off just rewatching The Commitments.
Just dig some holes in the backyard, put up some cheap fencing from Home Depot, grab a bunch of balls at Walmart, and pick up some spray paint to color them all in ☕
James Harris34 said:As long as these kinds of movies keep printing money, they’re going to stay afloat—even if they are absolute garbage. We'll probably see this trend peak over the next 5 to 10 years, and then in maybe 20 or 30 years, the next generation will look back at us and think we were just as narrow-minded as we currently feel about those cheesy trash flicks from the 80s.
Honestly, I'd trade all that charming 80s trash for these superhero flicks any day of the week.
So, you're basically against the heavy hitters, right? Like, you're pushing back against classics like Scarface from '83, The Thing from '82, or even Ben Hur from '59, and so on...
What a load of nonsense. You’ve mostly got a group of actors who just can't seem to command the screen, whereas the original movie was anchored by some of the most legendary heavyweights to ever grace the silver screen: Steve McQueen, Yul Brynner, Henry Fonda, and Charles Bronson...
Honestly, maybe it’s better if we just stop trying to compare everything... I mean, what’s the point of having this forum at all if we’re always measuring one thing against another?
electricridge6 said:See, this bolded part right here? This is exactly what I mean when I say Method acting is just plain overacting!
Nah. Doesn't matter. What matters is what actually ends up on the screen.
DDL would deliver a top-tier performance even without leaning into Method acting, simply because he’s such a naturally gifted actor, but clearly, he’s chasing that absolute perfection. Take DiCaprio, for example—he was pretty rough in The Revenant, so I don't buy his process at all; you can just tell he's trying way too hard.
It really doesn't matter if someone spends five years prepping for a role or just an hour. The technique used is secondary to whether the performance actually lands. Nicholson could nail a role with almost no prep, while DDL might spend years getting ready, yet both come out with incredible results. Both feel authentic and believable to me, and that's the only thing that counts—not the specific way they prepared behind the scenes.
In my book, DDL is one of the most talented actors to ever do it, and hands down one of the best we've seen in the last 30 years. He's already sitting among the greats. He might not be my number one of all time, but he’s definitely in that top tier of 7 or 8 legends.
Joseph Edwards4 said:I’ve always felt Russell Crowe is a fantastic actor. There was this one role in Master and Commander—it was such a quiet, understated performance, nothing flashy, no big dramatic speeches or over-the-top sentimentality, but he just nailed it. I remember thinking that. It feels like people don't talk about that movie much lately. He's got such a wide range, too, moving from stuff like Insider to A Beautiful Mind and then Gladiator... it’s like the conversation around him just kind of drifted away.
What do you mean, Russell Crowe? He’s just an okay actor to me. Sure, he has some solid moments in movies like Stop & Go or Insider, but nothing that really blows you away. He's pretty middle-of-the-road.
Raymond Hill says: I also want to point out that by the end of August, we might be talking about another actor who’s probably underrated right now, but the whole world is definitely going to be buzzing about him once his movie hits theaters... And I'm talking about Jared Leto playing the Joker. 🍿
Quote:
The world would be buzzing if Brad Pitt played the Joker, too. That’s just the kind of role everyone eventually ends up chasing.