darkowl72 said:It all comes down to how the amp and the enclosure are designed, the quality of the drivers, and a whole host of other variables. But primarily, you have to consider the intended use (personal) and the price point 😬 because we certainly aren't talking about audiophile territory here.
I still have a set of Logitech speakers on one of my old PCs from ages ago—a 12W wooden subwoofer paired with two 7W satellites. They were budget picks, bought back when I was shopping at Best Buy. I can honestly say they fill a room with sound quite effectively, and the quality isn't half bad. Of course, if you push those bass levels too far (with a 4" sub pushing a modest 12W), your neighbors might start twitching. You can actually feel the vibrations traveling through the floor; it’s not going to bring the house down, but it’s enough to make the windows rattle. As for component quality, you can tell they were built decently because distortion only starts creeping in once you crank them past 90%.
Honestly, it was one of the best purchases I ever made (!) for next to nothing. Even today, these modern, much more expensive speakers struggle to replicate what those could do... It’s a shame that brand doesn't exist anymore, but the best testament to its legacy is that Logitech bought them out back in 2001 just to crush the competition.
Well, obviously, you can't expect miracles at this price point, but technically speaking, there isn't really a "subwoofer" there... just a woofer. It’s like trying to market an integrated graphics card as a high-end gaming GPU; as cosmicheron48 pointed out, their frequency response reaches into the mid-range, which practically makes them monitors (satellites).
Of course, that doesn't mean they won't pack a punch. 😬
cosmicheron48 said:Come over and listen to my Adam subwoofer, it only has a 7" driver 😁
Another solid brand, if they even still exist—Microlab.
A long time ago, I picked up this for roughly $133 and it absolutely crushed everything you'd expect for that kind of money, and then some.
But the thing I could never get past with those 2.1 PC systems was the underpowered satellites, which forces the subwoofer to try and reproduce the low-mid spectrum—which isn't its job at all. The result? A lovely hole in the mids, and you can easily locate the subwoofer in the room because it's busy pumping out tones above 100Hz. 😁
Come on, at least your little subwoofer actually has a crossover! 😁
I’ve heard stories about some great ones, like Monsoon; they were being produced over a decade ago, but they were phenomenal. Their measurements were so good that they actually have a cult following of enthusiasts who guard them like gold. 🤣
I'm genuinely curious what is actually worth buying today in terms of affordable PC speakers. Does Harman Kardon have anything in the $500 range? $267