CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Lifestyle › Hobbies & Leisure › Best protein powders for muscle gain?

Best protein powders for muscle gain?

Started by feralbison4 · · 👁 4 views · 1.9K replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants feralbison4Bryan Fowler4Jamie Ruiz5James Lewis6Matthew White3silvergull68stormyheron4copperwolf112Ryan Robinson10boldfox8dustyotter11Grace Taylor35Roger Richardson61Henry Alvarez78Mark Hill3briskjackal5Jason Campbell70ironwolf52vividorca453slytrucker47goldenfox24Michael Chavezjadetiger962Olivia Kelly46 …
feralbison4 feralbison4 MemberOP
19 messages
joined Jan 2008
#1 ·
Richard Bennett44 said:I want to jump in on this topic. I'm trying to pack on some muscle mass— 🙂
I hit the gym four times a week and picked up some Whey protein. I’ve been having one scoop (32g, which is 24g of protein) mixed with milk after every workout. I was reading up on it and now I'm wondering what the ideal dosage actually is. The label says for my height and weight (6'1", 154lbs), I could take up to 126g of powder, which is about four scoops. It's kind of confusing because the lady at the Vitamin Shoppe where I bought it told me not to go over one scoop since my body wouldn't be able to digest that much protein anyway...

Also, one more thing—do I need to drink protein on days I don't hit the gym? Like, when I'm just chilling at home doing nothing 😁 or should I skip it?

Thanks in advance

Protein is basically building blocks for everything—muscles, skin, hair, nails, all that.
You need to eat it regularly just to keep your body running properly.
If you're looking to build actual quality muscle, you should aim for about 2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight.
How you get there is up to you. You can use supplements, or you can just hit those numbers through your regular meals if you can manage it.
Either way, if you've decided on Whey protein, try taking it right after training with some dextrose and water. One and a half to two scoops should be absorbed just fine.
If you plan on drinking Whey during the day away from your workouts, mix it with milk to slow down absorption; otherwise, it might actually work against you.
That clerk told you your body can't handle more than one scoop? Just typical nonsense you hear from retail workers...
Even two scoops in one sitting won't blow it for an average body. And you can have multiple servings throughout the day depending on your goals.
Personally, I'd suggest keeping Whey protein for your post-workout window and focusing on solid food or maybe a casein blend during the rest of the day to keep things slow-burning.
Whether you train or not, you still need protein if your goal is gaining quality muscle. So yeah, consume it on both training days and rest days.
One more thing... for most naturals, gaining even a few pounds of quality muscle takes a year of consistent training and eating right (if not longer).
So just be patient...
Bryan Fowler4 Bryan Fowler4 Newcomer
1 message
joined Oct 2007
#2 ·
Look, if you want to see results, you really should be aiming for about 2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight. So, if you’re sitting at 175 pounds, you need to be hitting roughly 155 grams of protein every single day... but I’m not talking about just slamming shakes; you need to get that protein from actual food. Now, whey protein combined with glucose? That’s specifically for muscle recovery right after a workout. Personally, I’ll throw a scoop and a half of whey into my shaker along with a heavy dose of glucose—I'm talking maybe 40g of whey paired with 70-80g of glucose. You can also mix whey with milk if you need a quick meal replacement on the go.

If anyone actually wants to understand the science behind why we use glucose or how whey works, just ask. I don't mind breaking it down for you.
Jamie Ruiz5 Jamie Ruiz5 Newcomer
1 message
joined Mar 2007
#3 ·
feralbison4 said:if you're actually looking to pack on quality muscle mass, you need to be hitting roughly 2 grams of protein per gram of body weight.

"Uh, good afternoon, I'd like to order a whole truckload of protein just so I have enough to eat for a week" 😁

So, 2 grams per pound of body weight, just so nobody gets the wrong idea 👍
feralbison4 feralbison4 MemberOP
19 messages
joined Jan 2008
#4 ·
Jamie Ruiz5 said:"Uh, hey, you know, I'd just order a whole truckload of protein—just so I have enough to eat for a week" 😁

So, 2 grams per pound of body weight—don't go getting the wrong idea 👍

nahhh! just 2 grams of protein per pound of mass and see if Schwarzenegger doesn't show up at your door one morning😁

joke, obviously—didn't want anyone actually thinking I made a typo...
James Lewis6 James Lewis6 Newcomer
8 messages
joined Aug 2007
#5 ·
Richard Bennett44 said:I find myself compelled to weigh in on this ongoing discussion. I share the exact same objective: I am looking to add a few pounds to my frame, though my intention is strictly focused on muscle hypertrophy rather than mere mass. 🙂
I currently maintain a training regimen consisting of four sessions per week, and I have recently invested in some Whey protein to supplement my intake. My current protocol involves consuming one scoop—specifically 32 grams, yielding 24 grams of protein—mixed with milk immediately following each workout. In my research, however, I have encountered conflicting information regarding the optimal dosage. The nutritional labeling on my specific container suggests that, given my physical profile (6'1" and approximately 154 lbs), I could consume up to 126 grams of powder daily, which equates to roughly four scoops. This figure is somewhat perplexing, particularly because the clerk at the health food store where I purchased the supplement advised against exceeding a single scoop, asserting that the human body lacks the capacity to digest such an excessive amount of protein at once. I find myself caught between the manufacturer's broad recommendations and this more conservative anecdotal advice, and I would appreciate some clarity on how to proceed.

I have one additional inquiry: is it necessary to consume whey protein on those days when I am not visiting the gym—specifically, during those periods when I am simply remaining at home and engaging in no physical activity whatsoever? 😁 Or perhaps not?

I appreciate the assistance in advance.


It is truly amusing to me when someone approaches me claiming they want to build muscle, yet simultaneously insists they have absolutely no desire to actually look muscular.
Now, regarding your specific discipline—explosiveness is almost certainly a fundamental requirement for success there. It is an attribute that demands rigorous, dedicated training if you intend to remain competitive.
The situation is quite clear: you are currently sitting at a mere 70 kilograms, which suggests you are significantly underweight, wouldn't you agree?
If you can manage to pack on an additional 45 to 65 pounds of lean mass, you will witness a total physical transformation; you certainly won't end up looking like some hyper-inflated bodybuilder, but the change will be nothing short of profound.🙂...
Given the general level of difficulty involved, one might assume that shedding fat without significant complication is an impossible feat. However, if you choose to closely observe the regimens of professional bodybuilders, you will realize that even they struggle to pack on mass through nothing more than injections, let alone through the mere consumption of whey protein and some light resistance training.🙂
The prevailing logic remains that more is generally better, provided one maintains a consistent training regimen. As for my own philosophy, I have never felt any inclination to indulge in such trivialities as striving to become excessively large or unnaturally powerful.🙂
One must strike a delicate balance; to be too aggressive is a liability, yet to be overly excessive proves equally cumbersome.
One must maintain an ambitious trajectory, aiming for the absolute ceiling in every endeavor, while understanding that expansion occurs only through incremental, deliberate progress. You have to accept that even when you reach those milestones, the scale of what you have achieved will inevitably feel insufficient. Building significant muscle mass is nowhere near as effortless as the common rhetoric suggests; the reality of the process is far more taxing than most people care to admit.

There isn't much profound philosophy to be found here; everything ultimately boils down to executing a rigorous training session that leaves you nursing intense muscle soreness for the next few days, followed by an aggressive intake of calories...

A little philosophy for the morning. My routine remains disciplined: whey protein and oatmeal to start the day, followed by whey protein mixed with water and a bit of glucose—I usually just grab some dextrose from a local pharmacy—immediately after training. In the evening, I opt for milk or perhaps some low-fat cottage cheese to ensure a steady supply of slow-digesting protein. I’ve noticed a growing trend on the bodybuilding forums lately; there is a certain breed of idiot attempting to act like an expert on everything, though there are still intelligent voices out there—some of the moderators, for instance, actually know what they are talking about. As for me, I prefer to learn through direct experience. My philosophy is simple: consume meat and carbohydrates as frequently as your digestion allows throughout the day. Furthermore, one does not need to be a complete fanatic to enjoy life. You can certainly afford to sit down with your friends on a Saturday and indulge in a couple of breakfast sandwiches and two liters of beer without ruining your progress. The key is avoiding junk food on a daily basis. Even if you are trying to bulk up, having a single unhealthy meal won't ruin you—though, if you're carrying an extra 45 pounds of body fat, you might want to keep a closer eye on how many greasy sandwiches you're inhaling per week. Honestly, it's exhausting watching people obsess over trivialities, acting as if drinking a Coca-Cola is some sort of unforgivable sin.
And that concludes the matter. You can comfortably consume two scoops of whey protein daily—perhaps one in the morning and one in the evening—to achieve optimal results. Aiming for approximately 50 grams of protein per meal is a reasonable target, as the body can only absorb so much at once; it is physiologically impossible for every single gram to be directed toward muscle synthesis. If you choose to supplement, my recommendation is simple: following a workout, mix your whey protein with water and a bit of dextrose. If your budget allows for a little extra, adding glutamine can certainly aid in recovery. Of course, if you are feeling particularly extravagant, you could indulge in amino acid blends and other premium supplements, though I maintain that such measures are far from mandatory. The fundamental pillars remain consistent: whole foods and quality protein. Sugar, after all, is an inexpensive tool for those who know how to use it. Ultimately, the lion's share of your investment should go toward actual food, specifically high-quality meats. Bodybuilding is a prohibitively expensive pursuit; it demands a significant commitment of time, discipline, nutrition, and training to see any gradual improvement. As for physical stature, standing under 5'7" is perfectly sufficient for an athlete. Progress is achieved through incremental gains, and small successes are more than enough to satisfy.
Matthew White3 Matthew White3 Newcomer
1 message
joined Jun 2008
#6 ·
Hey everyone!!! Listen, I'm about to start hitting the gym regularly, so I have a few questions. I’m 17 years old, 6'3", and about 175 lbs—still growing, obviously. I've looked up a ton of info online, but I'd really appreciate it if someone with actual experience could weigh in on my plan: I'll keep eating normally throughout the day, run for about thirty minutes every day, and bike for another thirty. For lifting, I'm looking at Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Post-workout, I plan to take 40g of Whey protein, eat two bananas, take 5g of creatine, and drink plenty of water (this is strictly my post-training routine)... Please, I'm asking only those with real experience to reply...
silvergull68 silvergull68 Member
11 messages
joined May 2007
#7 ·
So, do proteins actually make you gain weight?
stormyheron4 stormyheron4 Active Member
86 messages
joined Aug 2009
#8 ·
So here’s some lady claiming that protein powder made her gain weight over . She’s acting like she’s suddenly massive because of all the protein, even though she was practically skin and bones just yesterday
.
Bryan Fowler4 Bryan Fowler4 Newcomer
1 message
joined Oct 2007
#9 ·
they aren't gaining weight
copperwolf112 copperwolf112 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Apr 2018
#10 ·
If you eat enough of anything in insane amounts, you’re going to gain weight. It's just math. But out of all the macros—proteins, fats, carbs—you're least likely to see that happen from protein alone.
Ryan Robinson10 Ryan Robinson10 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Jan 2008
#11 ·
stormyheron4 said:So, we have a woman over here claiming her protein powder caused her to gain weight. Apparently, she's convinced she's become massive because of all the protein—even though she was practically skeletal just yesterday.

🤣🤣🤣
boldfox8 boldfox8 Newcomer
5 messages
joined Jun 2008
#12 ·
It seems like everything is just getting a bit heavier, while some things are becoming slightly less frequent, I suppose.
dustyotter11 dustyotter11 Newcomer
4 messages
joined Oct 2007
#13 ·
diablo2110 said:I mean, if you aren't actually working out, yeah, obviously they'll just add weight. But if you're hitting the gym properly? They break down and go straight to the muscles. So, protein + training = fine. Protein without training = fat.

So, what you're saying is we shouldn't even touch protein unless we're doing some intense workout?😕
I guess proteins are okay for things like dieting—maybe as an afternoon or evening snack to keep things light so you don't gain weight (though, I suppose, it depends on the type of protein).

As for supplements like Whey Protein or those pre-made shakes... honestly, I don't know. Not really my area.
silvergull68 silvergull68 Member
11 messages
joined May 2007
#14 ·
The proteins are actually called Protein Delita. It isn't whey.
Grace Taylor35 Grace Taylor35 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Oct 2008
#15 ·
jadetiger962 said:if you want something better quality without breaking the bank—like, not crazy expensive—you could grab some Dymatize ISO100 (the 5lb tub, roughly $133). Pick whatever flavor you like; I usually just stick to chocolate.

I noticed there's cholesterol listed in the ingredients for that whey—does that mean people with high cholesterol shouldn't be drinking it?
Roger Richardson61 Roger Richardson61 Member
39 messages
joined Apr 2005
#16 ·
All I know for sure is that Whey Protein is the only protein that's ever given me such bad stomach issues. 😁
stormyheron4 stormyheron4 Active Member
86 messages
joined Aug 2009
#17 ·
silvergull68 said:The proteins are called "Protein Delita." It isn't whey.

So what's actually in it? What's the protein percentage and how many carbs are we talking about?
Henry Alvarez78 Henry Alvarez78 Newcomer
8 messages
joined Jun 2008
#18 ·
stormyheron4 said:so I just saw this woman claiming her protein shakes made her gain weight over here. She’s out here saying she’s gotten huge from all the protein, when basically she was underweight just yesterday

🤣 🙂
Zloko mali...
stormyheron4 stormyheron4 Active Member
86 messages
joined Aug 2009
#19 ·
Amy Long19 said:🤣 🙂
Zloko mali...

That protein looks intense, doesn't it?
Mark Hill3 Mark Hill3 Newcomer
8 messages
joined Dec 2005
#20 ·
copperwolf112 said:I suppose if you eat anything in extreme, abnormal amounts, you’re going to put on weight. That’s just physics. But if we're looking at all the macros—proteins, fats, carbs—I guess there's probably the lowest chance of that happening with protein.

👍

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads