#21 ·
I’m leaning toward the idea that it all comes down to the celery acting as a diuretic, which essentially means this diet is just causing you to shed a massive amount of water weight rather than actual fat.
Started by Michael Fox46 · · 👁 6 views · 209 replies
Jeffrey Edwards5 :
Wait, what? I've seriously never heard of this "negative calorie intake" thing before...😕 😕 😕
Adam Torres62 said:I’m not even sure if the "onion" mentioned in this whole thing refers to the vegetable—it's all a bit vague...
Michael Fox46 thanks you for clearing that up.
Melissa Cruz2 said:Oh my goodness, ladies, please don't fall for that!
Now, look, a chicken noodle soup recipe can be perfectly fine—it feels healthy and all—but there is absolutely no way it should be your entire weight loss foundation. Sure, maybe use it for a day or two if you feel like you need a little internal reset.
But listen, our bodies generally need somewhere around 1,000 to 1,200 calories a day to lose weight safely, and those calories really need to be balanced out with carbs, proteins, plus your fats, vitamins, and minerals. You just aren't going to get the fuel required to actually function day-to-day, let alone keep up with a workout routine, from just soup.
Losing 7 pounds in 7 days? Honestly, aiming for about 1 pound a week is the sweet spot if you want to actually keep it off. This kind of rapid dropping is just asking for that yo-yo effect!
Personally, I think soup makes an excellent single meal—maybe just for dinner!
Michael Fox46 said:Look, you’re basically saying you could eat it for dinner, which isn't exactly against the rules... unless you think you aren't allowed to eat after 6 PM? Some people have dropped 20 or even 30 pounds just by having soup for lunch. Personally, I have it every single day, though I still eat other stuff—just in smaller portions and bits and pieces. It helped me drop 10 pounds; I went from 175 down to 165. Honestly, though... I don't think it's even obvious that I lost the weight...😁
Melissa Cruz2 said:You aren't actually losing weight because of the soup—since, let's face it, it still has calories—but rather because you're eating fewer meals overall. The soup just helps out by being light while filling up that empty space in your stomach.
And honestly, you can eat whenever you want and however you like; just check the calorie counts for different foods and build your meals around that. For instance, breakfast could be a slice of toast, some tea, and fruit. Lunch? I don't know, maybe some soup and boiled chicken with a salad. Dinner could be cottage cheese, boiled eggs, or even hot dogs. Timing isn't going to make or break your weight loss.
I have no problem grabbing a snack at 10 PM and I don't put on any weight. My main goal is just not to shock my metabolism. I try not to starve myself during the day only to overstuff myself at night; I prefer to just "maintain" things steadily throughout the day.
Larry Cruz51 said:What even is this?😕
Gary Watson4 said:I got this chicken noodle soup recipe from a nurse about a year ago.
It tastes kind of bland to me, but the best part is you can whip up a massive batch all at once to last the whole week.
I paired it with everything—just steamed veggies (no heavy flour or butter thickeners),
chicken, turkey, or fish with brown rice, and then green salad every other day along with two slices of rye bread daily.
I just had one cup of coffee in the morning and one in the evening, using 1% milk.
I stuck to five meals a day and always ate an unpeeled apple before lunch.
That’s how I dropped 45 pounds and got my cholesterol levels down.
The soup isn't just for dieting; it's healthy and really helps detox your system. 👍
Michael Fox46 said:Look, if you're eating it for dinner, that shouldn't be an issue—it's not like there's some rule saying you can't eat after 6 PM. Some people have dropped 20 or even 30 pounds just by having this for lunch. I personally have it every single day, though I still eat other things in small portions. I managed to lose 10 pounds; I went from 175 down to 165. Honestly, at my size, you might not notice the weight change right away.😁