#1 ·
They say humiliation acts on narcissists exactly how a lack of affection acts on the Depressive. It creates this twisted, perfect synergy between the two groups: they refuse to love us, while we find ourselves driven to belittle them; they envy our capacity for feeling, while we envy their total absence of guilt. Their interactions will only spiral further into dysfunction, yet neither group can seem to function without the other. This cycle continues until it inevitably hits a breaking point—either the narcissists flee because the degradation becomes too much to bear, or the Depressives bolt because they simply can't shoulder the weight of the guilt anymore.
Narcissists have turned guilt-tripping into a fine art, much like how Depressives act as absolute masters of self-abasement. Eventually, anyone watching from the sidelines won't even be able to tell the two groups apart; the narcissists will start mimicking the depressives, while the depressives begin to mirror the narcissists. A psychiatrist would probably try to untangle this mess with a laundry list of overlapping diagnoses—labeling a narcissist with comorbid Borderline or Bipolar traits, or calling a depressive someone who possesses the classic hallmarks of a narcissist. It just creates a massive, confusing blur.
Wouldn't it be much simpler to just label narcissists as "incapable of feeling guilt"? That would clear up the confusion immediately. As for the Depressive, we could probably call them "prone to belittling others." You see, a Depressive tends to put people down when they feel unloved, creating a cycle of guilt they desperately need to overcome; meanwhile, a narcissist withholds affection entirely, forcing others into a state of humiliation just so they can actually feel something. In the heat of the moment, the narcissist will whine about being victimized and look exactly like a Depressive, while the Depressive, through their constant belittling, will come across as nothing more than a narcissist.
This whole issue strikes at the core of my own struggles, and honestly, watching this interaction unfold is fascinating. I’m fully aware that in the real world, these kinds of "clashes" aren't clearly defined, which inevitably leads to a handful of people feeling insulted and digging their heels in. You'll have narcissists weaponizing their diagnoses because they can't wrap their heads around the concept of guilt—blaming the Depressives for being humiliated—while on the flip side, you'll have Depressives recoil when their own diagnosis labels them as violent, simply because they feel pressured by the narcissists.
A depressive, melancholic, somber, and sensitive soul: how could anyone ever look at them and imagine they possess a violent bone in their body? Conversely, a narcissist—someone brimming with confidence, brilliant, polished, always smiling and full of life—how could an outsider glance at them and ever suspect they are actually devoid of empathy?
Exactly. I’m a total aggressor! A Depressive soul—calm, sensitive, quiet, reserved, hardworking, respectful, and honest—but honestly? Don't you dare push my buttons. Because once you cross that line, you'd better run for the hills. It feels like that's the vibe here on this forum too: "If you leave me alone, I'll be your best friend; if you provoke me, I have more than enough ways to absolutely crush you." That is exactly how I operate in my private life as well. But narcissists just can't help themselves; they constantly poke at others because they're desperately searching for emotions they lack in themselves, even if those emotions are negative. And we fall for their little games every single time, losing our heads the moment they offer us any scrap of attention. In the end, both sides just end up creating their own misery.
In the end, those of us who struggle with being Depressive get absolutely devoured by the guilt of our own actions—specifically the way we hurt others. Rationally, you know deep down that you were just reacting to provocations, simply providing the exact emotional outburst they were fishing for in the first place. But the subconscious side of the brain doesn't give a damn about logic; it just hollows you out from the inside. It forces you to confront how much it would kill you if someone treated you the same way. You start spiraling into these endless, agonizing questions: How could I be so reckless with someone else's feelings? How could I just steamroll over them like that? Am I actually a monster? Why can't I just control my impulses? Is the flaw fundamentally within me? Am I nothing more than a cold, unfeeling narcissist? And now, how is that person supposed to move forward with the wounds I left behind? Are they the ones paying the price now? What is wrong with me? These are just a few of the relentless, gnawing doubts that keep us staring at the ceiling at three in the morning.
Then comes the depressive spiral. It’s followed by this relentless, burning anger directed at myself—this desperate urge to just stop weeping over my own failures and the wreckage I've left in other people's lives. This perpetual internal warfare is absolutely devouring me from the inside out. It isn't even just about what happened a few days ago or a few weeks back; it's the weight of everything I did ten years ago crashing down on me all over again. So, I just shut down. I withdraw completely because I can't bear the thought of having any contact with anyone, fearing I might hurt them—and more importantly, fearing I'll only end up hurting myself further by fueling this endless internal conflict.
“To err is human, to persist is diabolical.” It seems I’m either the devil himself or there’s some kind of demon living inside me, because I simply cannot shake this twisted way of communicating. Honestly, it wouldn't even bother me so much if I didn't end up carrying this crushing weight of guilt. It's soul-lacerating. Even after a meticulous deep dive into my family dynamics—identifying and feeling every single trigger from my past—the core issues remain stubbornly unchanged. I say "the core," because while there are significant shifts happening, they aren't quite enough to overhaul my current communication style. Some might argue that this requires time and grueling, relentless work. Of course it does, and I'm not throwing in the towel, but I find it much easier to process when I can hear more real-world examples and concrete cases. Everything helps, which is exactly why I started this thread!
The question is straightforward: how do I forgive myself? Or perhaps, how do I achieve emotional detachment from past events?
I find it far easier to forgive others than to forgive myself. In fact, forgiving others isn't even a question for me—it's incredibly easy and simple—though maybe that shouldn't be the case? I think it should! Yet, forgiving myself feels fundamentally impossible. As I’ve mentioned in other threads, I don't believe forgiveness is actually the solution to the problem. That is, it isn't the tool we use to reach a goal; rather, it’s the final result (the cherry on top). I'll try to clarify this so it doesn't sound contradictory, because it really isn't.
A narcissist unconsciously goads you into feeling something. I get angry, so I subconsciously belittle them. They get my anger, and I get their attention. Then, I am hit with intense guilt, while they walk away with a sense of bruised pride. They force guilt upon us, and we stomp on their ego: could that be it? Ideally, both parties would be self-aware enough to own their behavior and offer an apology. But in reality, that almost never happens. While we are ready to apologize—which often follows—the other side refuses to acknowledge it. We are ready because we feel deeply and empathize; we know exactly how it would feel if someone "stepped on" us. Meanwhile, anyone watching from the sidelines sees the narcissist as the balanced one and me as the aggressor. Naturally, everyone expects an apology from me, not them. Since I am aware of my own aggression, apologizing isn't hard, but apologizing to *myself* is the real struggle because I always fall for their games. Perhaps I’m secretly waiting for their apology just so it becomes easier for my own guilt to vanish. It’s as if I want them to fix my problem and ease my soul. As if I want to be respected. As if I've been cheated out of something. Yes, I feel cheated. Because they got exactly what they wanted—the emotions they craved and the apology to soothe their pride—while I only got attention, and no apology in return. Consequently, it is simply impossible to forgive myself until we settle the score. Either we learn to stop apologizing so we feel less guilty toward ourselves, or we learn how to stop falling for their tactics. The latter is clearly the better path. But how? How do you beat people who are geniuses at it, practicing 24/7 to provoke Depressives because they are constantly starving for emotion—whether they are in a crowd or alone? They don't care about social connection; they only care about knowing they can extract an emotional reaction through provocation. Otherwise, they choose solitude, continuing their training on how to manipulate others. You can never catch up to them.🙂 That’s why I believe true forgiveness is only possible at the end, once everything is clear and conscious; otherwise, forgiving oneself would suffice, but only once clarity is achieved. Maybe we should be learning how to dodge provocateurs and refuse to be baited? But how? When they are lurking around every corner? Even the socio-economic structure of our society seems designed to favor this; narcissists are the perfect managers, and that's exactly who we elect to lead us. You can't run away, even if you wanted to! Or are those just my excuses? Is there a way?
So, settle the debt and then forgive. Yes, but how do I reclaim what was taken from me so that I can finally "toast" to self-forgiveness? How do I give myself back something that someone else stole? Logically, that sounds impossible—unless my logic is flawed and I'm missing something obvious?
Wouldn't life be significantly less exhausting if we could spot a narcissist from a mile away? They have this uncanny, almost professional ability to mask their true nature—they spend their entire lives training to stay under the radar. You see it everywhere, even with those corporate suck-ups climbing the ladder at companies like Goldman Sachs. Once you finally see them for who they really are, things become clearer, but the damage is often done. Ideally, you just cut ties and walk away. But in the interim, they’ve already stripped you of so much, or worse, they've managed to entangle you in their web. If it isn't through external circumstances, it's through the mental loops you can't stop running, or ultimately, that crushing sense of self-blame. And what happens when walking away isn't an option? Like when it's a boss you can't quit, a spouse (especially when kids are involved), or a parent...
So, perhaps the only "solution" is to descend to their level by embracing envy, though the dream would be for them to actually emulate us—to crave the depth of feeling we possess. But dreams don't pay the bills; we live in the real world. Is finding a way to kill that lingering guilt the only actual path forward? Or am I just grasping at straws?
My apologies for the long-windedness here; I honestly wasn't sure how to condense this without stripping away the nuance. Please don't take this as me "laying down the law" or acting like some absolute authority on truth. This is simply my perspective, my observation, and my personal struggle with these concepts.
To wrap this up, the core issues are: the sense of being cheated out of what was rightfully yours, the cycle of retribution, the weight of guilt, and the necessity of forgiveness. If anyone here has navigated these waters or truly understands the visceral sting of these questions, I am genuinely asking for your insight.
Thanks in advance!
PS: I realize it's a bitter pill to swallow that Depressive individuals are often deeply angry people (and vice versa), just as it's hard to accept that they can sometimes be quite abusive. In that regard, I find myself agreeing with Hillman's assessment. It took me a while to get there, but I've realized I'm essentially living in a global society populated by terrorists and rebels. 😉
Narcissists have turned guilt-tripping into a fine art, much like how Depressives act as absolute masters of self-abasement. Eventually, anyone watching from the sidelines won't even be able to tell the two groups apart; the narcissists will start mimicking the depressives, while the depressives begin to mirror the narcissists. A psychiatrist would probably try to untangle this mess with a laundry list of overlapping diagnoses—labeling a narcissist with comorbid Borderline or Bipolar traits, or calling a depressive someone who possesses the classic hallmarks of a narcissist. It just creates a massive, confusing blur.
Wouldn't it be much simpler to just label narcissists as "incapable of feeling guilt"? That would clear up the confusion immediately. As for the Depressive, we could probably call them "prone to belittling others." You see, a Depressive tends to put people down when they feel unloved, creating a cycle of guilt they desperately need to overcome; meanwhile, a narcissist withholds affection entirely, forcing others into a state of humiliation just so they can actually feel something. In the heat of the moment, the narcissist will whine about being victimized and look exactly like a Depressive, while the Depressive, through their constant belittling, will come across as nothing more than a narcissist.
This whole issue strikes at the core of my own struggles, and honestly, watching this interaction unfold is fascinating. I’m fully aware that in the real world, these kinds of "clashes" aren't clearly defined, which inevitably leads to a handful of people feeling insulted and digging their heels in. You'll have narcissists weaponizing their diagnoses because they can't wrap their heads around the concept of guilt—blaming the Depressives for being humiliated—while on the flip side, you'll have Depressives recoil when their own diagnosis labels them as violent, simply because they feel pressured by the narcissists.
A depressive, melancholic, somber, and sensitive soul: how could anyone ever look at them and imagine they possess a violent bone in their body? Conversely, a narcissist—someone brimming with confidence, brilliant, polished, always smiling and full of life—how could an outsider glance at them and ever suspect they are actually devoid of empathy?
Exactly. I’m a total aggressor! A Depressive soul—calm, sensitive, quiet, reserved, hardworking, respectful, and honest—but honestly? Don't you dare push my buttons. Because once you cross that line, you'd better run for the hills. It feels like that's the vibe here on this forum too: "If you leave me alone, I'll be your best friend; if you provoke me, I have more than enough ways to absolutely crush you." That is exactly how I operate in my private life as well. But narcissists just can't help themselves; they constantly poke at others because they're desperately searching for emotions they lack in themselves, even if those emotions are negative. And we fall for their little games every single time, losing our heads the moment they offer us any scrap of attention. In the end, both sides just end up creating their own misery.
In the end, those of us who struggle with being Depressive get absolutely devoured by the guilt of our own actions—specifically the way we hurt others. Rationally, you know deep down that you were just reacting to provocations, simply providing the exact emotional outburst they were fishing for in the first place. But the subconscious side of the brain doesn't give a damn about logic; it just hollows you out from the inside. It forces you to confront how much it would kill you if someone treated you the same way. You start spiraling into these endless, agonizing questions: How could I be so reckless with someone else's feelings? How could I just steamroll over them like that? Am I actually a monster? Why can't I just control my impulses? Is the flaw fundamentally within me? Am I nothing more than a cold, unfeeling narcissist? And now, how is that person supposed to move forward with the wounds I left behind? Are they the ones paying the price now? What is wrong with me? These are just a few of the relentless, gnawing doubts that keep us staring at the ceiling at three in the morning.
Then comes the depressive spiral. It’s followed by this relentless, burning anger directed at myself—this desperate urge to just stop weeping over my own failures and the wreckage I've left in other people's lives. This perpetual internal warfare is absolutely devouring me from the inside out. It isn't even just about what happened a few days ago or a few weeks back; it's the weight of everything I did ten years ago crashing down on me all over again. So, I just shut down. I withdraw completely because I can't bear the thought of having any contact with anyone, fearing I might hurt them—and more importantly, fearing I'll only end up hurting myself further by fueling this endless internal conflict.
“To err is human, to persist is diabolical.” It seems I’m either the devil himself or there’s some kind of demon living inside me, because I simply cannot shake this twisted way of communicating. Honestly, it wouldn't even bother me so much if I didn't end up carrying this crushing weight of guilt. It's soul-lacerating. Even after a meticulous deep dive into my family dynamics—identifying and feeling every single trigger from my past—the core issues remain stubbornly unchanged. I say "the core," because while there are significant shifts happening, they aren't quite enough to overhaul my current communication style. Some might argue that this requires time and grueling, relentless work. Of course it does, and I'm not throwing in the towel, but I find it much easier to process when I can hear more real-world examples and concrete cases. Everything helps, which is exactly why I started this thread!
The question is straightforward: how do I forgive myself? Or perhaps, how do I achieve emotional detachment from past events?
I find it far easier to forgive others than to forgive myself. In fact, forgiving others isn't even a question for me—it's incredibly easy and simple—though maybe that shouldn't be the case? I think it should! Yet, forgiving myself feels fundamentally impossible. As I’ve mentioned in other threads, I don't believe forgiveness is actually the solution to the problem. That is, it isn't the tool we use to reach a goal; rather, it’s the final result (the cherry on top). I'll try to clarify this so it doesn't sound contradictory, because it really isn't.
A narcissist unconsciously goads you into feeling something. I get angry, so I subconsciously belittle them. They get my anger, and I get their attention. Then, I am hit with intense guilt, while they walk away with a sense of bruised pride. They force guilt upon us, and we stomp on their ego: could that be it? Ideally, both parties would be self-aware enough to own their behavior and offer an apology. But in reality, that almost never happens. While we are ready to apologize—which often follows—the other side refuses to acknowledge it. We are ready because we feel deeply and empathize; we know exactly how it would feel if someone "stepped on" us. Meanwhile, anyone watching from the sidelines sees the narcissist as the balanced one and me as the aggressor. Naturally, everyone expects an apology from me, not them. Since I am aware of my own aggression, apologizing isn't hard, but apologizing to *myself* is the real struggle because I always fall for their games. Perhaps I’m secretly waiting for their apology just so it becomes easier for my own guilt to vanish. It’s as if I want them to fix my problem and ease my soul. As if I want to be respected. As if I've been cheated out of something. Yes, I feel cheated. Because they got exactly what they wanted—the emotions they craved and the apology to soothe their pride—while I only got attention, and no apology in return. Consequently, it is simply impossible to forgive myself until we settle the score. Either we learn to stop apologizing so we feel less guilty toward ourselves, or we learn how to stop falling for their tactics. The latter is clearly the better path. But how? How do you beat people who are geniuses at it, practicing 24/7 to provoke Depressives because they are constantly starving for emotion—whether they are in a crowd or alone? They don't care about social connection; they only care about knowing they can extract an emotional reaction through provocation. Otherwise, they choose solitude, continuing their training on how to manipulate others. You can never catch up to them.🙂 That’s why I believe true forgiveness is only possible at the end, once everything is clear and conscious; otherwise, forgiving oneself would suffice, but only once clarity is achieved. Maybe we should be learning how to dodge provocateurs and refuse to be baited? But how? When they are lurking around every corner? Even the socio-economic structure of our society seems designed to favor this; narcissists are the perfect managers, and that's exactly who we elect to lead us. You can't run away, even if you wanted to! Or are those just my excuses? Is there a way?
So, settle the debt and then forgive. Yes, but how do I reclaim what was taken from me so that I can finally "toast" to self-forgiveness? How do I give myself back something that someone else stole? Logically, that sounds impossible—unless my logic is flawed and I'm missing something obvious?
Wouldn't life be significantly less exhausting if we could spot a narcissist from a mile away? They have this uncanny, almost professional ability to mask their true nature—they spend their entire lives training to stay under the radar. You see it everywhere, even with those corporate suck-ups climbing the ladder at companies like Goldman Sachs. Once you finally see them for who they really are, things become clearer, but the damage is often done. Ideally, you just cut ties and walk away. But in the interim, they’ve already stripped you of so much, or worse, they've managed to entangle you in their web. If it isn't through external circumstances, it's through the mental loops you can't stop running, or ultimately, that crushing sense of self-blame. And what happens when walking away isn't an option? Like when it's a boss you can't quit, a spouse (especially when kids are involved), or a parent...
So, perhaps the only "solution" is to descend to their level by embracing envy, though the dream would be for them to actually emulate us—to crave the depth of feeling we possess. But dreams don't pay the bills; we live in the real world. Is finding a way to kill that lingering guilt the only actual path forward? Or am I just grasping at straws?
My apologies for the long-windedness here; I honestly wasn't sure how to condense this without stripping away the nuance. Please don't take this as me "laying down the law" or acting like some absolute authority on truth. This is simply my perspective, my observation, and my personal struggle with these concepts.
To wrap this up, the core issues are: the sense of being cheated out of what was rightfully yours, the cycle of retribution, the weight of guilt, and the necessity of forgiveness. If anyone here has navigated these waters or truly understands the visceral sting of these questions, I am genuinely asking for your insight.
Thanks in advance!
PS: I realize it's a bitter pill to swallow that Depressive individuals are often deeply angry people (and vice versa), just as it's hard to accept that they can sometimes be quite abusive. In that regard, I find myself agreeing with Hillman's assessment. It took me a while to get there, but I've realized I'm essentially living in a global society populated by terrorists and rebels. 😉