feralorca82 said:Plot, a book, and a screenplay aren't the same thing. How exactly do you think he managed to make a movie if he didn't stick to the script? 😕
What exactly do you think constitutes a "scenario"? Have you ever actually sat down and read a single script in your life?
I’ve been digging through Romero's original script for Resident Evil—back before Anderson took over and essentially kicked it to the curb. The gap between what Romero envisioned and what Anderson actually put on screen is... well, it's massive.
Pay some idiot to write the script, then fire them the second they try to have an actual vision. It doesn’t matter if they happen to be one of the greatest directors out there with the most visceral, stomach-turning special effects; apparently, the rule is that I am the law. I’m just Anderson, right? Just some guy who managed to scrape together one mediocre flick that everyone watched—you know, like that Mortal Kombat movie everyone saw. Blah, blah, blah...
There isn't much of a difference between them, really, except for one glaring issue: the movie should have leaned harder into the horror elements. I mean, what kind of "expert" are you supposed to be if you're going to deliver a sanitized version and rewrite the entire script halfway through?
Romero's script didn't actually stray that far from the core plot and dialogue of the game; the narrative beats remained pretty much intact. Plus, since Romero was also responsible for the special effects, the movie was always going to lean more toward an action-heavy thriller rated PG-13 rather than a pure, gut-wrenching horror flick.
Anderson is smart, sure, but he’s also an idiot. He let the studio take over because he wanted to commercialize the movie and make it palatable for a younger crowd. He basically took someone else's script—which is obvious when you compare his version to Romero's—and censored everything. He turned the whole thing into a generic action flick, and then he completely nuked the franchise with the sequel. In that one, the characters are such a mess they don't even belong in the story, and don't even get me started on that fake scene where Nemesis "senses" something... Long story short, the guy is a terrible director.
You really have to be a genius to let go of experts and people who actually know more about a subject than you do.
Even with Romero's latest film, I wasn't exactly blown away. Honestly, if he had just taken that same script from the Resident Evil movie and simply swapped out the characters and names, the film would have easily pulled a 4 out of 5 from me.
Here’s my take on Anderson and any director who decides to tackle a video game adaptation by just skimming the surface and assuming it’s all about the explosions. It’s pretty obvious that even if they actually played the game, nobody bothered to pick up a single note or read a single report scattered throughout the levels to understand the actual context. But hey, why bother with depth when you can just grab a walkthrough and call it a day?