briskbison55 said:In the US, those kinds of options are already on the table if there's a need for them. And honestly, this whole part about kids wandering off during class still doesn't make sense to me. I mean, I was a kid once, right? We used to have gaps in our schedules all the time, and we'd just go wild—playing football, tag, trying to talk to girls... 😁
Huh, wise words. I guess if you had said that about Archimedes it would be one thing, but specifically for Newton...
If you made a list of everything you haven't heard anything about, it would probably shame every book ever written.
Anyway, it seems like everyone is just hyper-fixated on religious education because they're hyper-fixated on the church. Maybe you guys think our society is good enough that kids will just pick up basic ethics and morals on their own, but I don't really have that much faith in a nation that uses more tobacco products than almost anywhere else and sees alcohol consumption rising year after year while health issues are climbing too.
That's a stellar argument, suggesting that sexual harassment of young girls happens during those unsupervised gaps. I wonder how we ever thought to protest unnecessary scheduling gaps when children might be subjected to THAT while they're unattended...
briskbison55 said:In the US, those kinds of options are already on the table if there's a need for them. And honestly, this whole part about kids wandering off during class still doesn't make sense to me. I mean, I was a kid once, right? We used to have gaps in our schedules all the time, and we'd just go wild—playing football, tag, trying to talk to girls... 😁
Huh, wise words. I guess if you had said that about Archimedes it would be one thing, but specifically for Newton...
If you made a list of everything you haven't heard anything about, it would probably shame every book ever written.
Anyway, it seems like everyone is just hyper-fixated on religious education because they're hyper-fixated on the church. Maybe you guys think our society is good enough that kids will just pick up basic ethics and morals on their own, but I don't really have that much faith in a nation that uses more tobacco products than almost anywhere else and sees alcohol consumption rising year after year while health issues are climbing too.
Religious studies and the church teaching children ethics and morality? What kind of ethics? Discriminating against your neighbor because they don't share your faith, or judging them because they don't feel the same way you do? Or perhaps it's that particular brand of morality where you "sell sheep a bill of goods," telling believers they should live impoverished for earthly riches while being "rich in spirit," all while you drive a brand new Ford and sip wine from a golden chalice—funded by the donations and taxes stripped from the poor and the elderly retirees who can barely afford groceries on the 9th of the month, yet still left $1.75 at the service the other day? Or maybe it's that chauvinistic morality where men rule the planet. A male God, a male Savior, a male priest, a man chosen by God... while women are treated as second-class citizens, mere appendages, deemed unfit to pass down something as "high" as the Word of God. Honestly, please... the very notion of such "ethics and morality" makes me sick...
shadowcrane91 said:Whoa, where am I even claiming that???
It *can* happen, it just isn't happening right now.....
Personally, I don't have an issue with it
It’s quite sad to see one self-proclaimed "educator" addressing everyone else with such a condescending tone in every single post, using those question marks... not to mention that this "educator" doesn't seem to care about the welfare of all the children in the school. 🕺
Would you really send half a preschool group out into the hallway for an hour just so you could teach religious studies to the other half?
briskbison55 said:Since we're being ridiculous—well, obviously there's going to be plenty of evil until religious studies becomes a mandatory subject through every single stage of schooling. 😁 But honestly, if I started writing about the old American educational system and how the government treated every single counter-revolutionary element... maybe it's better not to go there here.
briskbison55 said:Well, personally, I find the exaggeration a bit much. Like, do you have an issue with the Ten Commandments? Of course not. Sure, how someone chooses to follow them is another story, and that’s why we need actual laws, but those general guidelines are just as important as how you're raised at home or your own character. I see religious ed no differently than any other lecture; you get a framework and some principles, and then it's up to you how you use them. I think anyone who views it strictly as brainwashing is totally missing the point and looking at the whole thing through a really narrow lens.
The Ten Commandments? It’s truly pathetic that a believer needs a deity to instruct them "thou shalt not kill" or "thou shalt not steal" and similar trivialities. For us secularists, we don't require a god to tell us those things are wrong, nor do we need the threat of hell to ensure we behave ourselves.
Ethics and morality don't originate from God; they originate from humanity.
Studies have shown that children raised within religion tend to be less tolerant and more aggressive toward their peers. One might wonder why...
It is because they are indoctrinated from infancy into value systems that insist THEIR god is the only true one, that THEIR believers are the ones headed for heaven, and that THEIR commandments are the absolute truth, rendering all other global religions incorrect. Religious education teaches children
discrimination, not morality. True morality is taught by parents and society. And frankly, one has to question the morality of a small believer and their deeply religious parents, who teach the child that non-Christians are destined for hell, telling an innocent child that the devil will torment them simply because they don't believe in a god—that is a lived experience. That is your "ethical and moral" faith and religious education: a foundation for discrimination from the very beginning...