hollowhound30 said:Hey everyone, I need some input. What are your thoughts on using the two programs mentioned in my title (AutoCAD & Vision) for drawing electrical schematics, equipment layouts (floor plans, exterior cabinet views, etc.)? Personally, I've always used AutoCAD... but I'm currently in a massive disagreement with my colleague over this. He insists that Vision is the absolute best tool for our field and claims AutoCAD is really meant for mechanical engineers or architects. He thinks Vision is more than enough for us electrical guys!😕 ...maybe he's right🙄 ...but I find it incredibly clunky to work in😠 and I feel like I'm moving at a snail's pace compared to when I'm using my beloved AutoCAD...
what do you think?... am I just being slow and awkward, or is Vision actually a success?
Neither of them is ideal for schematics. You should be looking at something else entirely—Electrical design software like AutoCAD, AutoCAD, or AutoCAD, which are actual E-CAE tools. These can automatically generate connection diagrams, specifications, and all the other paperwork required for a project, whereas otherwise, you have to manually assemble and cross-reference everything to other drawings. The only catch is they aren't free; they usually require a dongle for authorization, but they are worth every penny you invest. Honestly, it's not even that expensive, so don't panic—just do some research.
Vision is mostly fine if you just need to whip up a quick sketch to email from the shop floor, but it's not for generating full documentation. On the flip side, AutoCAD is too general-purpose; for electrical engineering specifically, it requires way too much manual labor.