Best protein powders for muscle gain?
in Hobbies & Leisure ·
Whether soy is actually good or bad just depends on which study you decide to believe. Purely by the numbers, there are more studies claiming it's beneficial. According to general encyclopedic data:
I don't touch soy myself; I can't stand the taste. That DM powder has 4.5% soy in it. If you take 30g of powder a day, even if it does have estrogen, it’s at least a thousand times less than what’s in birth control pills—which, for the record, I take. Whatever. Personally, the artificial sweeteners bother me more, though people can never agree if aspartame is carcinogenic or not. Probably less dangerous than cell phone radiation...
It raises estrogen levels. It has a BV of 49. It digests much slower than whey (which is 104). It won't kill you, obviously, but there are better protein sources out there. Some claim soy has health benefits, but I'm not getting into that; I don't eat it either, for the same reasons you don't.
Regarding this idea that it's a milk protein rather than whey. Someone please explain the lingo to me, because in English "whey" refers to the liquid separated from milk during cheesemaking. Whey *is* a milk protein, so what else would it be? You guys always recommend cottage cheese or low-fat yogurt in the bodybuilding community—so why are these milk proteins suddenly bad?
Whey digests much faster than casein, making it the superior choice for PWM. Cottage cheese, for instance, is a great option for your last meal of the day. Micellar casein is designed to provide a steady release of amino acids into the bloodstream, which makes it an excellent long-term anti-catabolic protein.
To me, the posts on this fitness forum just sound like hearsay—people repeating negative opinions without any actual basis. Sure, maybe the powder tasted gross to someone a few years ago, but it doesn't taste bad to me today. I like vanilla, my friend likes chocolate 🤷 What kind of argument is that?
Yeah, there's plenty of misinformation passed around through word-of-mouth, but there's also plenty of useful stuff to read. For example, the FAQ is perfect for anyone who doesn't know the difference between steroids and protein, or sets and reps. I tried it two years ago, by the way, and it really was disgusting 😁
You're saying it's definitely bad because it's cheap, while others in this thread say it isn't even cheap and that there are better, cheaper options—but they can't explain why. What am I supposed to conclude from that?
No clue. High-quality whey certainly won't cost less than that protein powder from DM.