Laptop around $750 - 17.3" for 3D CAD?
in Laptops ·
Look, this whole topic is a complete non-issue. It’s really not that complicated. 👍
Look, it’s a fool's errand to compare desktops and laptops. They aren't even playing the same game. The whole point of a laptop is portability and battery life, so every single component is engineered specifically to hit those targets. Everything is throttled—speeds are lowered and voltages are dialed back just to squeeze out a few extra minutes of juice. You don't deal with that nonsense on a desktop. Take the hardware, for example. An i7-8320 can pull 125W easily, and if you decide to overclock it, you're looking at pushing 150W without breaking a sweat. Meanwhile, an i7-5500U? Even with undervolting, you're hitting a hard ceiling around 15W. That should be enough for anyone to get the point. It’s the exact same story when you look at the GPU, the RAM, or the SSD. The math just doesn't work the same way.
It all really boils down to the software. You have to look at whether it leans more toward AMD or Intel, if it’s heavy on the CPU, or if you can offload work to the GPU via CUDA cores. Then there's the question of whether it actually utilizes video memory. The reality is that while the 940M is technically a newer card, it's stuck with a 64-bit bus and relies on DDR3 memory. I'm honestly not sure which versions of DirectX or shaders it supports, or if the 940M has any newer tech baked in since the chip itself is more recent. It's hard to say how that's going to impact whatever specific programs you're running.
The laptop has 12GB of RAM, which will definitely come in handy, but the desktop still has a fast drive plus an extra SSD on top of that!
There are just too many unknowns here. There’s way too much ground to cover and testing to do before I could even think about giving a definitive verdict. 🤷
Look, if you decided to go with a high-end configuration, then you did what you had to do—within the limits of your budget, anyway. You can always upgrade the laptop with an SSD, either by buying a new one or just repurposing that one from your desktop if you’re done with it. You just pop it into the DVD drive slot using an adapter. I don't know what to tell you. If you're looking for a caddy, just go find one. I'm not here to do your errands for you.Look, you can actually speed that thing up significantly if you just do it right.
Look, it’s a fool's errand to compare desktops and laptops. They aren't even playing the same game. The whole point of a laptop is portability and battery life, so every single component is engineered specifically to hit those targets. Everything is throttled—speeds are lowered and voltages are dialed back just to squeeze out a few extra minutes of juice. You don't deal with that nonsense on a desktop. Take the hardware, for example. An i7-8320 can pull 125W easily, and if you decide to overclock it, you're looking at pushing 150W without breaking a sweat. Meanwhile, an i7-5500U? Even with undervolting, you're hitting a hard ceiling around 15W. That should be enough for anyone to get the point. It’s the exact same story when you look at the GPU, the RAM, or the SSD. The math just doesn't work the same way.
It all really boils down to the software. You have to look at whether it leans more toward AMD or Intel, if it’s heavy on the CPU, or if you can offload work to the GPU via CUDA cores. Then there's the question of whether it actually utilizes video memory. The reality is that while the 940M is technically a newer card, it's stuck with a 64-bit bus and relies on DDR3 memory. I'm honestly not sure which versions of DirectX or shaders it supports, or if the 940M has any newer tech baked in since the chip itself is more recent. It's hard to say how that's going to impact whatever specific programs you're running.
The laptop has 12GB of RAM, which will definitely come in handy, but the desktop still has a fast drive plus an extra SSD on top of that!
There are just too many unknowns here. There’s way too much ground to cover and testing to do before I could even think about giving a definitive verdict. 🤷
Look, if you decided to go with a high-end configuration, then you did what you had to do—within the limits of your budget, anyway. You can always upgrade the laptop with an SSD, either by buying a new one or just repurposing that one from your desktop if you’re done with it. You just pop it into the DVD drive slot using an adapter. I don't know what to tell you. If you're looking for a caddy, just go find one. I'm not here to do your errands for you.Look, you can actually speed that thing up significantly if you just do it right.