It always strikes me as strange how our politicians love to brag about how public education is "free" here in the States. But what exactly is free about it? I mean, are textbooks, field trips, trips to the movies, or theater visits included? If those things are part of the curriculum, then the school should be funding them through government grants rather than asking parents to foot the bill. It feels like a total mess, I guess.
urbanpilot said:I think you should head down to the school ASAP to sort this out. I doubt the kid feels comfortable being cornered by a teacher about money, whether it's in front of the class or privately.
To follow up on the whole "optional" field trip thing.
Maybe things work differently in NYC, but at our school, trips to the movies or the theater are mandatory. After they go, they have to write an analysis for English class, which counts toward their media literacy grade.
When they do nature trips, those count toward their science and social studies grades...
That said, our teacher tries her best not to push for money too hard.
For instance, last month they went to the cinema, but we didn't have to pay a dime. A local community group organized it as part of a city event, so it was totally free.
About three weeks ago, they went to a play that did require payment.$6.75 But the teacher made it clear she knew it could be a lot for some families. She told us to just reach out if we needed help; she’d cover the cost personally, and one student could attend for free if needed.
Two weeks ago, there was a notice about donating to the Red Cross $1.75, plus a request for clothes or toys for a charity drive helping a sick boy... but nobody was pressured into doing it. It was purely voluntary.
Another cool thing at our school is the paper recycling drive. Basically, it's a competition, and whichever class collects the most to sell gets a field trip. Last year, our kids went to a botanical garden and had a blast. We just packed them lunches from home—zero issues, zero extra costs.
Our teacher really tries to minimize what parents have to shell out. She always gives us plenty of notice before any trip or event so everyone can prepare. We already have a trip to Chicago lined up for the second semester.
I find this almost too difficult to ignore because I saw a similar notice at my kid's preschool recently. I honestly don't know how they can feel okay using children as a way to squeeze money out of people. It doesn't matter who the cause is, really; using kids like that just seems wrong. It's shameful, I suppose.