Jason Ortiz5 said:The truth is, kids feel the weight of their family's finances whether we want them to or not, simply because they see what their classmates can afford. The real question is: should we be teaching them that it's shameful not to have enough cash for everything (especially when this specific thing is totally useless)? Should a mom have to go into debt just so a teacher doesn't end up having to tell the class, "Hey, even sandwiches are a luxury"? Should parents have to fund every single school whim just so a kid doesn't feel the gap between those who have it easy and those who don't? Honestly, instead of hiding the struggle, isn't it better to teach a child that there's no shame in living honestly on what you've got?
Personally, I think pretending to be a Rockefeller when you aren't is absurd. It's not a tragedy if you can't swing a McShit burger or a big trip to Disney World. What matters way more is our relationship with our kid and how they feel at home—love, connection, all that stuff. Money and McDonald's are secondary.
If we make a huge production out of it, our kids will too. If we don't make it a big deal, they won't see it as a tragedy either.
My little girl is modest and grateful; she doesn't care about the material stuff. Honestly, she's more mature than most kids her age because of it.
And then there are the stories of people maxing out credit cards just so their kid "doesn't feel left out," or being told they owe something because they weren't careful, or feeling forced into things after having a baby... my take is simple: a child cannot have everything. It’s actually good for them to realize that early on, before they grow up expecting everything to be handed to them on a silver platter.
And if you don't have the cash, there is zero shame in that.
One more thing... no amount of money can buy the love or that sense of security we provide through just five minutes of real conversation
when we explain why things are the way they are.