Joseph Bailey41 said:Let’s switch things up for a second. Instead of just hyping each other up—which I love because we really get each other—let’s actually try to define what this whole "herd instinct" thing even means, and what a "herd" per se actually is. From what I see when I head down into the city, it doesn't look like a "herd" at all. It looks like a bunch of individual personas just wandering aimlessly, each playing their own little political game. It’s more like the chaotic movement of subatomic particles than some kind of organized super-organism.
Sure, right now they might all be sharing the same emotional state (and honestly, it's a vibe you can smell from blocks away, so I personally prefer keeping my distance), but in the grand scheme of things, it's all temporary and fleeting. If you were to ask any one of them what they're actually afraid of, they wouldn't even be able to put it into words... so by definition, this isn't fear, it's paranoia. That's why conspiracy theorists are having the time of their lives right now; they feel like pigs in mud because finally, other people are starting to "see" the Illuminati, the Masons, and whatever else they're obsessed with.
How do you teach a "herd" anything? You don't. You can't. Because a "herd" doesn't have reason, it can't remember, it can't learn, and it can't achieve insight. It doesn't even have an instinct, because that concept doesn't exist in this context; it's just a mental construct used by people who try to control others because they're lonely and empty inside. Reason—and even emotion, intuition, or instinct—is something possessed exclusively by individuals. You can only have a conversation with individuals; they are the only ones you can teach, and the only ones you can learn from. A herd (whether you call it a mass, a crowd, or just the unwashed masses) isn't a factor. It isn't a force of nature, and it isn't a conscious, active subject. It's nothing. It’s just a temporary mental illusion sustained only by "faith" in the concept itself—basically, by us accepting the terminology. It's a cheap magician's trick.
I agree. 🙂
I don't subscribe to the concept of "mob mentality" either. 😁 I believe that more people can simultaneously fall into a state of mass hysteria and panic, whether driven by actual threats or irrational fears. However, these individuals are simply united by a shared emotional state at that moment, which remains something that can be influenced on an individual level.
When this pandemic first hit, I felt a wave of panic for a few days. Every conceivable fear surfaced, all rooted in that fundamental dread of mortality, but eventually, my reason took over. I realized that my only real influence was to protect myself and others as much as possible; everything else was simply out of my hands. Dwelling on catastrophic scenarios is counterproductive because stress weakens the immune system rather than preventing illness. Since these worst-case outcomes aren't guaranteed, I decided to stop doomscrolling and choose to hope for the best. 🙂 Sometimes, I even find myself forgetting all about the pandemic.
There is an ancient, almost mystical belief that worrying ahead of time acts as a sort of protective charm, as if constant anxiety can somehow prevent misfortune from striking. In reality, worrying serves as a psychological substitute for action during times when we are actually powerless. By staying anxious, we create a false sense of agency, tricking ourselves into believing we have some measure of control over events that are entirely beyond our reach. These are merely internal illusions that do more harm than good. We must become aware of these mental patterns and strive, as much as possible, to bring them to an end.
Ultimately, it all comes down to the individual; everyone manages their fears differently. Some people even seem to thrive on them. I wouldn't be surprised if those folks who live for the thrill of an impending apocalypse are actually finding a sense of euphoria in the chaos. 😁
The constant media fearmongering certainly plays its part too. I've spoken with Americans who are genuinely hysterical over emergency measures because they’re convinced we're sliding straight into "1984." They've been so conditioned by stories of totalitarianism and communist regimes, yet most have never traveled abroad, don't speak a second language, and consume nothing but domestic media. After decades of being fed constant propaganda, there's simply no calming them down or explaining the necessity behind these measures. It's pure paranoia and hysteria. Of course, that doesn't apply to everyone—there are plenty of level-headed people who remain unaffected. So, once again, it really just comes back to the individual...