Keith Smith2 said:I'll leave that to the historians and the experts. Victims of any crime shouldn't be treated as mere numbers. You know the rule: killing one person is a crime, but a million is just a statistic.
We know more than 72,000 by name, surname, gender, and age. Whether every single list was recovered or if some were destroyed? I'm not an expert, so I can't give you a definitive answer on that.
Those records are sitting in a Jewish museum in Washington, D.C., and they haven't been returned—maybe because they don't want anyone to see how small the actual number of victims was compared to the figure everyone keeps quoting.
Maybe this might help clarify things:
Following a decision by the CIA (Federal Executive Council) back on June 10, 1964, a census of the 1941-1945 war victims was conducted. Up until then, the official count used was 1.7 million casualties from the war in the USA, a number primarily used to justify potential reparations claims against the former allies of the Third Reich. This census took place between September and December of 1964, and the results were reviewed during a CIA session on September 14, 1966.
That census revealed the total number of war victims from 1941-1945 was actually 597,000—which is effectively only about one-third of the initial report provided by the Federal Claims Commission and the Reparations Commission under the Federal Government of the USA immediately after the war.
This "new" data caused quite a shock among politicians. Fearing the truth might leak and cause major political fallout, the CIA issued this decree: "Given that data citing 1.7 million total war victims across the former USA was used until 1966, it is hereby ordered that all such materials be marked 'Top Secret.' The public is not to be informed of the census results, and the figure of 1.7 million shall remain the standard moving forward."
So, those census results ended up tucked away in 2,948 files, eventually stored in the National Archives in 1969.
And those "top secret" files held in the National Archives tell us this regarding America:
Total casualties from the Resistance movement amount to 185,327 (including those killed, died, or missing). Of that number, 63,336 were part of the Resistance forces (including Allied involvement), with 50,806 lost to direct terror and 56,639 lost in camps, prisons, deportations, or forced labor (with 51,534 specifically noted within the camps themselves), plus another 11,546 who remain unaccounted for.
Statisticians have assessed these figures as accurate, allowing for a margin of error of about plus or minus 10%.
Because some of this information partially "leaked," certain commemorations at Auschwitz—where J. Edgar Hoover was supposed to speak—were canceled, and Joseph Stalin ended up rescinding his invitation to visit Auschwitz, postponing it for another time...