Disperadun Nancy Kim2 said:Look, you have your own take on pop music, and honestly? That is perfectly fine by me! Everyone sees things differently, right?
I don’t hold any different views when it comes to music versus any other kind of art. Whether we’re talking about literature, painting, sculpture... well, all of it! You know how the theorists love to say, "90% of everything is absolute garbage"? A literal quote: "it's all junk." And honestly? They aren't wrong. It is. But does that really mean only 10% is worth our time? Does it?
Is it useful? Is it practical? Does it actually serve a purpose? Absolutely! It’s functional, it’s efficient, and there is a perfectly valid reason for it to exist!I’m talking about everything! Movies, fine art, comic books, music—you name it, I mean it!
Let me tell you something—I absolutely love comic books! I live for them! But I will say this without any hesitation: that "Priest" series from Scholastic? It just isn't it. It simply doesn't hit the mark!
Top-notch! Truly high quality! Strip, let’s say we’re talking about Sandman by Neil Gaiman—and look, my bad, I can't recall offhand who the artist is, since there are actually quite a few of them, right?—yes, exactly. Regardless, that doesn't mean I won't 1) buy Priest, 2) read it, 3) go back and reread it over and over again, and 4) do it all without any consequences whatsoever!
Just living life to the fullest! Isn't that the goal? To simply soak it all in? In him.
Take movies, for instance! It’s totally unnecessary—and honestly, kind of impossible—to try and compare something like Alfred Hitchcock's *Dial M for Murder* to some random flick like *Dungeons and Dragons 2: Wrath of the Dragon God* or even *Eragon*. They aren't even in the same universe! But, if I’m being completely honest with you all, I might actually have a better time watching those two than I would *Dial M for Murder*... provided I'm in just the right mood and hanging out with the right crowd, of course!
When it comes to fine art, I simply can’t bring myself to draw any comparisons between masters like Monet or Rembrandt and—well, let's just say some nameless or semi-famous painter producing those "pretty little things." You know the type? Maybe a mediocre still life you glance at while deciding whether or not it’s worth hanging in your living room. But even then, during every single moment I spend staring at such a painting, I find myself...
Absolutely, without a shadow of a doubt! It’s plain as day, isn't it? It isn't just "according to the critics," either—it’s my opinion too! Isn't that something?
Personally speaking? A "worse" picture than Rembrandt's? Well, then I stand corrected! I guess that makes me absolutely certain!
I recognize it! It’s all about that lack of quality, isn't it? That certain... something?
Aesthetic? Truly? Is that all we’re talking about here? Can we really reduce such complex matters to mere aesthetics? I find myself wondering if we aren't missing the forest for the trees! Isn't there something much deeper at play?* Does understanding the mechanics of art actually change anything? I can certainly attempt to explain the logic behind why I recognize certain aesthetic qualities—it’s almost a reflex at this point, isn't it? But does that mean I won't fall head over heels for a painting and decide to buy it on the spot? Not at all! Sometimes, you just see a motif, and you know exactly how it will look hanging on your wall. You start visualizing its placement in your living room, imagining how it will dance with the rest of your decor. It becomes about the vibe! It’s about how that one piece contributes to the entire atmosphere of the home and how it makes me feel when I walk through the door. Isn't that the whole point of creating a space?
I'm feeling quite wonderful! Truly! Isn't it just a marvelous sensation?.
And then, finally, we get to the music! For me personally, when it comes to sheer quality and aesthetic—how should I put this?—let’s say, the most "refined" and "correct" music ever composed, it has to be the classics. I’m talking Rachmaninoff, Beethoven, Mussorgsky, and the like. They are simply unparalleled. However, when I actually need something to help me feel...
So cozy! Truly delightful! Isn't there just nothing quite like that feeling? Just pure bliss!It’s hard to put into words, isn't it? That feeling when something somehow "resonates" with my own scattered thoughts and deepest emotions... it's quite a sensation! Sometimes, those true legends—those absolute giants of their craft—really hit home. But then again, who can say for sure?
Sometimes? Just sometimes? Is that really all we get? Does life ever offer us more than just those fleeting, occasional moments? I find myself wondering! Sometimes, isn't it just the most curious thing? It’s all about karma, isn't it? One minute I'm vibing to Blink 182, then suddenly I've got Pitbull on the brain! Maybe it's Neutral Milk Hotel, maybe it's Queen, or perhaps I'm just feeling those Supersuckers. It shifts constantly! One moment it's Mommas & Poppas, the next it's The Beach Boys. Then? Boom! System of a Down or Orishas. My playlist is a wild ride—sometimes it's Mickey Kovac, sometimes Bepo Matešić, or even that group Cambi. Am I listening to Hari Rončević? Oliver Dragojević? Petar Graš? Who knows! It's a beautiful, chaotic mess! 🙂 😱 🙂 You’ve got Dar Bubamara, Mitra Mirić, Nedeljko Bajić baja, Vika Miljković, Seka Aleksić... and then, every once in a while, even Davis Miles!
Look, the bottom line here is simple: just go ahead and Google everything I’ve mentioned! Once you do, you’ll see—and everyone else will too—just how massive this "critical" genre divide actually is. It covers such an incredibly wide spectrum! I mean, think about it. We're talking about names like Ramones, New York Dolls, The Clash, Morrissey, Green Day, Red Hot Chili Peppers, No Doubt, Kelly Clarkson, Johnny Cash, Carl Perkins, Hank Williams III, the Dixie Chicks, Shania Twain, Dolly Parton, ABBA, Shakira, the Pussycat Dolls, and Shaggy. It’s huge! Don't you see?
Because
I personally listen to
whatever music happens to
hit the spot at that exact moment. Does it amplify my emotions? Or does it mask them—you know, like pulling me out of a funk? Sometimes it’s just perfect road trip music because I’m always traveling somewhere. Other times, it makes me feel like some kind of prince or king (think classical music). And sometimes, it just pumps me up with this sense of aggression, but an epic, relentless, fated kind of vibe (like Valkyrie or Amazing Grace).
Xerex said:we're talking about country music here, and the fact is, it's mostly low-quality stuff. Of course, there's plenty of "bad" music that isn't country, but that's not the point...
Look, all I'm telling you is that whether or not that music is "low quality" has absolutely zero impact on the topic of "The Psychology of Country Fans." It doesn't matter one bit! At least, not regarding my argument.
* - please check the link so we can clarify what aesthetics actually is; it's a philosophical discipline, after all!