Spanking and physical discipline: what are your thoughts?
in Psychology ·
feralranger said:Azzura As stated by:
It is, of course, entirely your prerogative to characterize such blatant imputation and projection as a "meaningful contribution."
But I haven't actually imputed anything. That is an objective fact. Your elaborate little logical constructions simply do not constitute proof that I have committed any such "imputation."
"Quote"I am truly at a loss as to what part of this remains unclear, such that I find myself compelled to reiterate the point once more. Both incarceration and house arrest share an identical physical component—the outright deprivation of one's freedom of movement—as well as a shared psychological dimension: that pervasive, lingering sense of misery that inevitably follows such a restriction.
Azzura As expressed by:
To suggest that locking a child away or punishing them by withholding weekend outings is somehow comparable to actual imprisonment is a stretch, regardless of how many superficial similarities one might attempt to draw between the two. I shall refrain from repeating myself:Azzura As stated by:
Until this very moment, I wasn't even aware that anyone was actually looking for a "third" option in this discussion.
It is quite beside the point. House arrest is essentially a dual-layered punishment, acting as both a physical and psychological sentence. It isn't merely a restriction on one's movement, nor is it strictly a mental burden; since there is no third category to speak of, one is forced to conclude it is a seamless combination of the two.darkcanyon10 As stated by:
I currently serve as a counselor at one of our local American juvenile detention centers.
It has finally reached that unfortunate breaking point where we are seeing young people actually laying hands on their educators. It is truly a regrettable state of affairs.
It is my firm belief that nonviolence frequently serves as nothing more than the fertile soil in which violence takes root.
When a sixteen-year-old kid decides to charge at me with a clenched fist, I find that my vocabulary—no matter how carefully curated—tends to lose its efficacy quite rapidly.
I have officially enrolled in a self-defense course. 👏
It is simply the logical conclusion. The sheer absurdity of these extremes is becoming quite exhausting, isn't it? We seem to have drifted into a state where nuance has been completely abandoned in favor of these sweeping, polarized caricatures that leave absolutely no room for middle ground. It’s as if we’ve collectively decided that anything less than a total, uncompromising stance is somehow a form of intellectual cowardice. Honestly, watching the discourse unfold lately feels like a relentless exercise in futility—a bit like a modern-day Sisyphus, only instead of a boulder, we're pushing an ever-growing mountain of irrationality up a hill, only to have it roll right back over our heads. One can't help but feel a certain weary detachment when everything is framed as an all-or-nothing battle between two equally unhinged camps. It all boils down to that mindless, blind acceptance of whatever happens to be trending at any given moment—a sort of intellectual surrender where one simply swallows everything whole without the slightest hint of critical thought or scrutiny.
Whatever the cause... the reality is most schools and institutions in America are basically just sets for violent movies.
Parenting is just another controlled form of violence designed to trigger discomfort or pain in a kid to make them stop acting out. Parenting = violence.
Don't ruin kids by overdoing the affection; they need discipline.
Discipline is uncomfortable, and so is having clear boundaries. External structure builds internal structure.